What's so difficult about the Islamic calendar?

Imagine if for the months of September, October and December, one had to wait until the 29th night of the preceding month to know whether the start of the new month will be the next day or the one after. There would be non-stop controversies and chaos, right? And people would have demanded, and obtained, solutions to such a situation.

Well, that's essentially the situation that the Muslim world has been in for ages with regard to its religious months, particularly the holy months of Ramadan, Shawwal, and Dhul-Hijjah (the first being the month of fasting, the second being the month of feasting after Ramadan, and the last one being the month of pilgrimage to Mecca.)

What's going on? The Islamic month is a lunar month, based on the phases of the moon, from new crescent to full moon and back to new crescent again. It has been the practice since the times (and simple injunctions) of Prophet Muhammad to start and end any month upon sighting the new crescent by naked eyes, since during those times (in the early seventh century CE), there were no optical aids. (We'll get to the status and role of the telescope in a short while.) And for religious purposes, that practice seemed fine for some time, as it allowed anyone anywhere to determine whether the new month, especially the crucial month of Ramadan when every adult (save for those who are exempted for one reason or another) is supposed to fast (during the whole month, from dawn to sunset.)

But quickly, the Islamic society turned into a real state and civilization, and people realized that months need to be structured into a calendar, which then serves many civil purposes in addition to the religious ones. At the same time, Muslims were coming into contact and becoming aware of the sciences that had been developed by other nations and cultures, including the astronomy of Indians, the Babylonians, and the Greeks. So the field of "Islamic Astronomy" quickly emerged to address such questions as the Islamic calendar, prayer timetables, and others. And soon an Islamic calendar was constructed by Muslim astronomers and was used by the rulers for various purposes, including the payment of salaries, the scheduling of various civil deadlines, etc.

But these calendars remained for "civil purposes" only, and for religious times (e.g. Ramadan), the practice of sighting the crescent on the 29th evening of the previous month remained in effect. And that did not create any chaos, for two reasons: a) due to the lack of fast communications and travel, societies remained largely local, and only travelers noticed discrepancies in dates of religious or civil occasions between different lands; b) economies were primitive and slow, and so one day off now and then did not wreck things significantly enough for anyone to protest.

Today the world has changed so much, and yet the practice has remained largely unchanged, leading to more chaos. Indeed, because different Muslim-majority countries follow different approaches and rules in determining when Ramadan (and other holy months) start, including the stronger or weaker reliance on astronomical knowledge, we routinely find the Muslim world celebrating the start or end of Ramadan on three or four different days.

Now, one of the difficulties lies in the fact that the Islamic month is based on the new crescent, not the "new moon" (the moment of passage of the moon between the earth and the sun). The latter is a purely astronomical moment, and it can be calculated with great precision, but the appearance of the thin new crescent (some 15 to 30 hours after "new moon") is rather complicated matter, as it also involves atmospheric and meteorological effects, not to mention the ability of the human eye, or of a telescope, to see a thin crescent. Still, astronomers have made huge progress on this problem and can now confidently predict in which regions of the world the crescent will be seen (by naked eye or with optical aid) on any given night.

But then, if this can be determined ahead of time, why should there be a problem at all? Can't we simply tell people when the crescent will be seen and thus when the month will start or end, and then both the religious occasions and the civil functions (appointments, travels, etc.) can be taken care of all at once? Yes, indeed, we could - if this calendar calculation is accepted by the authorities (religious and political.)

And so we come to the crux of the matter: the need to move on from the old injunctions and their literal applications ("sight the crescent with your eyes") to a more objectivist interpretation of the intention ("use your best tools, including telescopes and computers, to ascertain the start of the month") on the part of the Muslim authorities.

Until we digest the importance of moving from the simple, limited and limiting rules to a more intelligent understanding and applications of the ideas underlying them, we will continue to witness various types of chaos. I don't know, as I write, whether Ramadan will start on July 31st, August 1st or August 2nd. I don't know when a TV show on the topic will have to be scheduled, and when I will have to travel for it, and millions of people (including my students) don't know when they will have to travel home to celebrate Eid with their families or plan for pilgrimage in Mecca.

It is astounding that a problem that science can today solve without disturbing the main religious principles underlying it could still constitute such a socio-economic predicament, entirely due to the religious authorities' reluctance to give up the old literalistic ways.

Source: Huffington Post - Nidhal Guessoum, a Professor of Physics and Astronomy at the American University of Sharjah.

  Category: Faith & Spirituality, Featured, Nature & Science
  Topics: Islamic Calendar, Moon, Ramadan
Views: 6711

Related Suggestions

The opinions expressed herein, through this post or comments, contain positions and viewpoints that are not necessarily those of IslamiCity. These are offered as a means for IslamiCity to stimulate dialogue and discussion in our continuing mission of being an educational organization. The IslamiCity site may occasionally contain copyrighted material the use of which may not always have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. IslamiCity is making such material available in its effort to advance understanding of humanitarian, education, democracy, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law.

In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, and such (and all) material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.