Islam on Its Own Terms

Category: Faith & Spirituality, Featured, Life & Society Topics: Islam Views: 5460

We Muslims have always been longing for a "return" to the good life for centuries now. And understandably so.

That's why it is not only regrettable, but oh so sorrowful, that we are totally mired in trying to understand what we as a people believe through the ideas and histories of others.

There are many reasons for this. But the most important is the widening gap separating us-not from knowing Islam's basic beliefs and rituals, but-from seeking to understand them and Islam's major concepts on their own terms.

Not to wax political, but the easiest example of this is the question ever in the backdrop of the public discourse on Muslims: Why do Muslims not have freedom and democracy?

But think about these two concepts for a moment, and conceptually they are filled with problems. Democracy started in Athens, enfranchised the rich, and totally divested the poor, the slave, and the foreigner, of any rights. One need only look around today to see there is still nothing close to a standard for its application in the cultures that celebrate it.

The same can be said of freedom, an even vaguer notion. Are women who must uncover their faces to access the public square in order to appease cultural insecurities free?

Islam certainly upholds the concepts of participation and personal and public choice in shura and other principles. In fact, its notion of participation in public life and policymaking is significantly broader and its freedoms far more sweeping and protected. But the crucial issue is what concepts are given priority.

Islam's prime social value-under which these two common concepts and all others are subsumed-is justice ('adl), and excelling in good-doing (ihsan), or personal social responsibility borne of religious conviction. Allah says: Indeed, Allah commands the execution of justice among you and the doing of good to others... [16:90].

Hence, in Islam because of its emphasis and elevation of prescribed justice, as opposed to undefined notions of democracy and freedom, even if there were slaves, as in Athens, or if someone's freedom was lost, as with a prisoner, there nonetheless could be no loss of justice. This has the virtue of preserving both participation and freedom because God has enshrined justice over these other concepts. You could not, for instance, in Islam deprive the slave or felon from voting, or the prisoner of war from sharing in your own food or clothing, even if you were yourself hungry and ill-clad.

The point is you cannot understand this if you are taking your conceptual framework-even for your own religion-from people fixated on certain ideas that have been developed in their societies and cultures as a reaction to their very distinctive histories. The result of this mixing can only be confusion. And values confusion, indeed, is what we Muslims are currently much about, in my humble observation.

We must learn and fathom the concepts of Islam on their own terms. In other words, as the Qur'an has defined them, as the Prophet, sallallahu alayhe wa sallam, has exemplified them, and as our scholars for the last 14 centuries have preserved, related, explicated, and translated them for our benefit.

That is not to say we should ignore and cannot learn from others. But wholesale importation of un-indigenized concepts and, especially, uncritically accepted frameworks from the historically shaped outlooks of others-this is disastrous. In fact, when it comes to Muslims, who are the prophetic community of the latter-day world, this is a dereliction of the highest order and communal cowardice.

Nowhere is what I've been talking about clearer than with the current environmental tragedy that is now literally threatening the entire planet and everyone and everything on it with annihilation. Could the stakes be higher?

Yet when it comes to the environment, Muslims are not merely voiceless, they are in a fetal posture of waiting to receive instructions from others-and the very same peoples whose cultural conceptions got us into this mess in the first place. How foolish is that?

Islam has everything to say and to give to the world when it comes to rescuing humanity from its current collective suicide, and rescuing the planet from humanity. This is because it knows that at its core the crisis of the environment is the spiritual crisis of man.

And, above all, Islam has the conceptual language and sources to reorient and re-inspire man to his humble yet gallant role as steward of the earth, khalifah. Islam understands that these concepts of preservation, conservation, protection, cooperation, abstention, moderation are not free-floating ideas, but Heavenly perspectives held together by two things: The divine decree of a single, solitary Master, God; and the human realization that He shall interrogate His servants, us, on that looming Last Day about the blessings-the furnished habitation, and the food, water, and air-He has bestowed to us, for both our enjoyment and our care.

Why not gift this, this perspective, this inheritance of ours, to the world, now, in its hour of need? Us. We Muslims. Forget about the power and the glory. Focus on conveying this panacea for humanity and its habitation to everyone.

We surely can do it, with the permission of Allah-but not before we ourselves come to fathom our deen by and on its own terms. Within lies the answer.


Article provided by Al Jumuah Magazine, a monthly Muslim lifestyle publication, which addresses the religious concerns of Muslim families across the world.

To subscribe please visit

  Category: Faith & Spirituality, Featured, Life & Society
  Topics: Islam
Views: 5460

Related Suggestions

The opinions expressed herein, through this post or comments, contain positions and viewpoints that are not necessarily those of IslamiCity. These are offered as a means for IslamiCity to stimulate dialogue and discussion in our continuing mission of being an educational organization. The IslamiCity site may occasionally contain copyrighted material the use of which may not always have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. IslamiCity is making such material available in its effort to advance understanding of humanitarian, education, democracy, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law.

In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, and such (and all) material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.

Older Comments:
Excellent. May Allah subnahu wa ta'ala bless this Brother and grant us the capacity to learn the way.

Peace be with you !

I am sorry to begin with this sentence, similar to yours..."It is difficult to understand the
intellectual dishonesty regarding Islamic culture and concepts in" your comments.

If you have taken a minute to read Islamic History that only under the Islamic System did
a BLACK SLAVE, revered as Hazrat Bilal RAU, became of such stature that the Prophet
SAW Companions like Hazrat Ummar and others would refer to him as "our most
honored Leader".

And as for non-muslim slave, the daughter of the the famous generous man HAATIM
was captured in a battle she told him about the generosity and kindness of her father
and appealed to Him that she may be freed. Prophet SAW freed her and gave her
camel/money to go to her brother. He SAW also told her that ALLAH SWT loved the
attributes that her fathers had. When she reached her brother in Syria he was so
impressed by her narration of Prophet SAW that he travelled back to Madina and became
muslim. Till to this date he is revered as one of the companions of Prophet SAW, ADI BIN
HATIM (Razi Ullah-o-unhu)

As for democracy and freedom, please let me know where in history except in Islam, that
one of the greatest and sitting Caliphs Umar RAU could be questioned as to why his
dress is made of two sheets of white cloth where as every one was only given one sheet.
He stepped down and his son ABDULLAH replied that he gave his father his share of the

And where in the world except under Islam, that ALLAH SWT orders muslims that if non-
muslims is captured in battle and he claimed sanctuary to hear about Islam than do so
without harm and if he didn't became muslim he should be escorted to his place of
safety without harm.

And who has ever said except Prophet SAW "one who frees and married the capture
woman he would go to paradise as a reward".

Peace be with you

It is difficult to exaggerate the intellectual dishonesty regarding non-Islamic culture and concepts in this article. Which is really amazing considering how briefly it is covered. Lets take the statement about Athens. Athenian democracy did not divest the poor, the slave and the foreigner of rights. Those people didn't have any rights to begin with. That power resided in large numbers of "citizens" via voting rather than a handful of nobles via brute force was a remarkable advance. Modern democracies admire Athenians for beginning the journey, not for getting to the destination.

Anyway, what is a slave with rights? Its a meaningless concept. Muslims may tell themselves that Islam gives slaves rights, but what kind of rights are those in practice? Especially if the slave is a non-Muslim? No rights at all. The word of a non-Muslim is nothing next to a Muslim in Islam. Even if a slave adopts Islam (probably to have even a chance at rights), what will happen in practice? The powerful slave owner will get all the respect in court. Once the hierarchy of slave vs master, non-Muslim vs Muslim, is established any pretense that the slave or non-Muslim has meaningful rights is just the masters or the Muslims deceiving themselves so they can tell themselves how great they are. The slave and the non-Muslim are not deciev

Whats this about "women who must uncover... in order to appease cultural insecurities"? What a bizarre bit of mental gymnastics. I see numerous women who cover in my American city and nobody bothers them. If a woman covers her face that is strange. To me its not as strange as, say, a man who dresses like a woman, but both are free to behave as they want. I'm free to find them strange. If a woman wants me to treat her with full respect she should show me her face when she speaks to me. If she doesn't want to speak to me then her covering or not makes no difference - I won't bother her in either case. In all cases we're both fr