Modernity and Morality

Category: Life & Society Topics: Modernity, Women Values: Morality Channel: Opinion Views: 5740

The values that I grew up with and learned as a child born in South Asia nearly half a century ago are quite different than the ones preached and practiced today in the West. In our zeal to be called civilized we have automatically assumed it to equate with modernity. Thus, in our political jargon when our western leaders talk about being civilized they mean how well we have adopted the modern western way of life. That means, to be civilized you should have not just an ordinary wired telephone but a wireless/cellular phone, TV, cars, computers and other amenities of the western modern life - running faucets, western habits and consumption patterns. Minus those modern amenities, you simply are not civilized. But that is not enough! You have to also mimic western way of life. On the top of that list comes women's liberation. That is, if women in your culture are not 'liberated' by discarding the traditional garb or dress, you must be 'oppressing' your females, and you are uncivilized! It is no accident that France and its president, born of a broken family and himself a playboy, Nicolas Sarkozy are now defining how the 'cultured' and 'civilized' French society ought to look like. 

Sarkozy is married, if I am not mistaken his third time, to Carla Bruni, a singer who is more known for exhibiting her naked body than her voice. So, as you can guess: hijab and Muslim veil, worn by many traditional Muslim women, are unacceptable in that 'emancipated' country whose 'civilized' natives still have not learned the basic hygiene, let alone the true meaning of morality. If you care not to expose your kids to sex, you better switch off the TV after sunset. In such countries of sin and immorality, where sometimes you can't distinguish a real politician from a part-time pimp and a prostitute, and, (probably pertinently so,) run by racists and bigots, it is no wonder that immigrants with their conservative values and family-oriented culture and tradition are considered a direct threat to the very foundation of those states. It is that age-old cry and fury of the 'liberated' inhabitants of Sodom and Gomorrah: you must be like us in order to reside here; there is no place for the Prophet Lut (Lot) or his righteous kind!

Sarkozy is surrounded by guys like Bernard Kuchner who not too long ago is accused by hard-hitting investigative journalist Pierre Pean in "The World According to K." of a "possible conflict of interests" in working as a consultant in Gabon and the Democratic Republic of Congo while serving as government-appointed head of a public body supporting health services in Africa.  In the Netherlands the far-right, anti-immigrant politician Geert Wilders of the PVV has won major gains in local elections, with results indicating that he may dominate the political scene in the run-up to the general election in June. After winning the election, Wilders told cheering supporters at a rally in Almere, "We are going to conquer the entire country ... We are going to be the biggest party in the country. The leftist elite still believes in multiculturalism, coddling criminals, a European super-state and high taxes." Wilders likens the Qur'an to Hitler's Mein Kampf and wants Muslim immigrants deported. 

Prime Minister Jan Peter Balkenende's Christian Democrats remain the largest party in the Netherlands, but for how long? On March 18, 2010, the PVV gave up trying to form a governing coalition in Almere, where it won more seats than any other party. In a press release, the party said most of the other parties had refused to give ground to PVV demands on what it describes as "essential issues". The PVV's demands included a ban on headscarves for city council workers and in all institutions and clubs "which get even one cent of council money." The ban would not have applied to other religious items such as Christian crosses and Jewish skull caps. Is it anything but blatant discrimination and religious bigotry? 

In the French-speaking Quebec province of Canada Premier Jean Charest this week proposed an anti-niqab bill. The proposed law is misguided and described by the Ottowa Citizen as a clumsy, politically-charged hammer. The newspaper says, "Of the 200,000 or so Muslims in Quebec, maybe a few dozen women wear a niqab, a veil that covers the entire face except for a slit for the eyes. To draft legislation singling out such a tiny minority suggests the law has more to do with pandering to fears about immigration -- specifically, the failure of some immigrants to integrate -- than solving any real, non-aesthetic problem posed by niqabs... The anti-niqab bill is clearly meant to be a political statement, and an ostentatious one at that, not unlike the infamous code of behaviour drafted by the Quebec town of Herouxville in 2007 that prohibited all sorts of practices, real or imagined, that are associated with immigrants. The joke was that Herouxville had virtually no immigrant population." The editor is absolutely right, but will the racist politicians in Quebec see the light, or follow their racist cousin in France? Never mind a westerner's preference for almost everything artificial and unnatural, cosmetics and perfumes to hide his/her natural imperfections and bad body odors, are the modern amenities the real measures of civilization? 

Let's consider TV. It has both positive and negative sides. There is no doubt that it allows us to learn about our planet and galaxy. A peasant in Lalmonirhat in Bangladesh can now get a glimpse of life in Louisiana, USA - located on the other side of the globe without ever having to sail or fly there. But news, history, geography, health and science are not the only things shown on TV. Seldom do we realize that with TV, we have brought violence and sex into our family rooms, and not the kind of things family members can watch together in the same room! Just turn on any major channel in the USA between 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. You will see soap operas about dysfunctional families where everyone seems to be cheating - husband cheating his wife and vice-versa, let alone the unmarried guys and gals whose preoccupation seems all about sex. In places like Germany and France, it is much worse; you can hardly find a channel in the evening that is free of showing sexual stuffs. If this kind of lifestyle is what a western civilization has ended up producing who in the right mind would need this poison? 

Unfortunately, a dominant culture is like a magnet that attracts others to mimic its ways. Many in the third world and developing countries are, therefore, learning those bad ways faster and unquestioning. Take a look at the beaches in South America where traditional bikinis worn by women are getting fast replaced by G-string bikinis. It is no surprise that we see many young boys in South Asia today with earrings, a practice that was not known or seen in the past. Many youngsters are now addicted to drugs -- another statement to show off their borrowed modernity and liberated soul. Many possess illegal arms. It is not difficult to find a strong correlation with a rise in sex-related crimes, violence and divorce in these societies today. Women in traditional homes are discarding natural herbs for synthetic cosmetics! 

In this culture of modernity often times it is the large and small screen actors that become the role models to copy. The things that they wear become our fashion and style. We are not shocked any more to learn that most Hollywood actors live immoral lives; they are into drugs and sex. Divorce and sex scandal are rather common facets of life in the Hollywood.  The hottest topic that dominated the media the last week was all about sexual abuse scandal within the Catholic Church. It is obvious from the reports unearthed thus far that Pope Benedict has a long history, dating at least back to 1979, of condoning such sexual abuses within the Church. As a micro-manager all his life, he was on the top of all such affairs and cannot now evade accountability. He allowed the transfer of molester priests that preyed on children. There are also questions about Benedict's directive as a Vatican cardinal in 2001 that bishops worldwide were to keep pedophilia investigations secret under threat of ex-communication. Regrettably, the church leaders chose to protect the church instead of the children.

As a child growing up in Bangladesh, I remember the story of a rickshaw puller who stopped by a well to help a village girl to put her water pitcher on the head. Neither the doer of the kind act nor the beneficiary had to utter a single word; he knew the kind of help the girl needed. After he was able to place the water pitcher on the head of the girl, he left for his rickshaw while the girl left for her home. No "thank you" was even needed to be uttered by the girl. It was all that natural - giving and receiving. That is what real civilization is all about: where each member of the society does continuous small acts of charity without expecting reward or recognition. It is also free of hypocrisy or pretension.

Surely, a society and civilization that prides in its modernity where immorality, sex and abuse are engrained into its very core, and fascist inclinations are interwoven with its sinful and faulty character cannot be the role model or guiding light for anyone, much less for others with strong life-giving and -sustaining ethics, values and mores.

  Category: Life & Society
  Topics: Modernity, Women  Values: Morality  Channel: Opinion
Views: 5740

Related Suggestions

Related posts from similar channels:

The opinions expressed herein, through this post or comments, contain positions and viewpoints that are not necessarily those of IslamiCity. These are offered as a means for IslamiCity to stimulate dialogue and discussion in our continuing mission of being an educational organization. The IslamiCity site may occasionally contain copyrighted material the use of which may not always have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. IslamiCity is making such material available in its effort to advance understanding of humanitarian, education, democracy, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law.

In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, and such (and all) material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.

Older Comments:
I liked the example of the Bangladeshi Rickshaw puller's empathy towards the girl with pitcher. I think we lost this generosity. I remember we stopped talking with our girl classmate when we saw our professor passing by us in Curzon Hall campus. I would like to read your book or more articles. Thank you. May Allah Bless you and your family.

This article is an illustration of the moral degeneration in the
non Islamic countries. Between Islamic values and others, Islam
will always prevail for the simple fact that the more Islamic
values are challenged the faster they grow. Islam is a force to
reckon and it will spread through out the world by the will of
Allah, the Creator of the Universe.

Please don't forget that we all human race are fallen. It will lead us no where by pointing fingers on other's culture or other's sin.I hope you first see your fallen nature then you will understand other's too and so the salvation offered by Lord through Jesus's death on cross.He loves you too and has died for you too, so that you can reconcile with HIM. May Lord bless you.

i understand where Paagle is coming from, just like we hate that only a muslim's killing is considered terrorism and a non-muslim's killing is because of some psychological problems, he too feels that generalising this 'western civilisation' angers him.

And this is what the article is trying to address...coz if this article was so baseless then why would the former first lady of the U.S.A bother to take a whole load of 'modern' clothing, perfumes etc for the Women in Iraq?..why would we women who choose to cover ourselves be considered oppressed?...why does it matter so much that a child reports their parent for trying to discipline them to the point that parents become helpless in raising their own children? like Paagle said, there is not enough space to go on....

No matter how much we want to exist as one 'Global Village', we must understand that we have different cultures with different ways of life that suit each people...yes we should try and learn about other cultures and pick what is good and leave the rest and if one finds that a particular culture suits them then they may adopt it fully but NO CULTURE SHOULD BE IMPOSED ON OTHERS JUST BECAUSE ONE THINKS THEIR CULTURE IS SUPERIOR OVER ANOTHER! People have a right to choose but do not impose on them that which they do not desire.

We should try and fight the evils that exist in ALL CULTURES such as child, domestic and drug abuse and try as much as possible to do unto others as we would like done unto us in all life's situations.

Z.S FROM USA said:
Paagle intellectual garbage understate the word "confusion". Hey Paagle: try to give your explanation the people living in villages all over South Africa where HIV and AIDS is rampant. The Muslims Prophet made it simple for evryone i.e clean yourselve after you use the bathroom, do not spread VD and now AIDS by having sex with evryone that turn you on, etc. etc. Can anyone make things simpler than that.

Very well said, echoing my very thoughts. I do take exception to one thing, and one thing alone: the view that the possession of "illegal" arms is something negative and to be discouraged. The bearing of arms for defence of self and property, among other things, is absolutely essential and shuld be encouraged. Forbidding law-abiding people from carrying weapons only makes it easier for criminals to take advantage of them.

As-Salaamu alaikum, this article is one of the best on this topic. Today in any part of the world we see people trying to imitate the western culture in all sorts of activities without even recognizing if its correct or wrong (ethically or religiously or even morally). As said by the author, with the misnomer of civilization there have been many impacts and one of the worst is the dying of our native cultures and traditions. Its sad to see many languages have died, people using foul lang in public as they say its "cool" and ask others to "chill", on commenting. Most of the people have even killed their own blood relations as a side effect of civilization. One of the recent article in a leading newspaper also threw light on the meaning of civilization, the author was not allowed to enter a 5 star hotel by the guards to interview a celebrity just because he was dressed simple in kurta and pyjama( a traditional indian outfit).
One of the main source of learning these absurd things(of modernization) is TV which show casts programs encouraging (and indirectly teaching) people to follow wrong ways(eg. like in Indian roadies we can see contestants bitching against each other). It seems the present generation needs to go back and learn the definitions of good, bad, morals, ethics. One of the best thing to find these defn would be in the religion.
There are lots of examples that we can say or write and even see in our daily life. But still, to avoid these things happening in the world, rather than saying or writing or commenting we should try to correct ourselves and our family members.... Its high time we need to correct ourselves and by our own will and strength. Early people were lucky to have a prophets to guide them, but today we need to preach and mainly follow teachings of our beloved prophet pbuh, as we may not see any other prophet coming in our life time (if the final day is nearer we will have prophet Isa pbuh). Pray allah to help us ameen.

This article highlights what we all know about this fake 'civilisation', unfortunately for us who care, true civilisation is boring, not profitable and does not allow for arrongant, corrupt, thieving and immoral individuals who thrive in this new Jahiryah period.

It hurts to read this article and recognise the truths in it especially regarding how we are bringing up our children, glued on television with most of its programmes useless in terms of morals.

May Allah guide us and our offsprings to the straight path; the path of those whom He Has favored.

May Allah amply reward the writer for the impassioned article. Very timely.

A light hearted article the essence of which I fully agree with. But what happened to the used language? The author seems to have written several books in english and if this article is an indcator of their content then this is pretty rubbish writing. Or is this a bad translation?

I presume if I say "Orientalism" every reader of Islamicity will nod in agreement. In fact, the "Zionists Against Zion" article, published just prior to this article on Islamicity, is written by a modern champion (M. Shahid Alam) of the much lionized Edward Said's tretise that the West's view of Islam is grossly distorted and self-serving.
Shahid Alam, Edward Said and their ilk certainly have some valid points. They may even a lot of valid points. But if there is an "Orientalism" in the west's view of Islam, there is at least as great an "Occidentalism" in Islam's view of the west. And this article is an example of the a particularly shallow Occidentalim. It is in fact so shallow I must also call it craven.

Shallow because it identifies some characteristics of the western world and assumes/asserts that these things are the foundation upon which westerners judge "civilized." It identifies assaults upon Muslim's right to be conservative in liberal society (which exists regardless of the fact that liberals are accorded no right to be liberal in Muslim societies) while at the same time betraying the attitudes that lie at the root of such hostility to begin with. Somehow Sarkozy's position on the self-isolating niqab is invalidated by the fact that his wife was a model (described sneeringly as "exhibiting her naked body"). From here the article gets more ridiculous - even veering into hygene! Are diseases spread by unhygenic practices thriving in the west? - if so, then why despite a low birthrate are there so many healthy westerners making life miserable for poor, ever-victimized Muslims? Space limits prevent me from going on...

Craven because I believe anybody with significant contact with the west that so badly misjudges it must be either deliberately ignoring its virtues (so as not to face the corresponding flaws in their own culture) or else lived in it but never bothered honestly interacting.