Free the Muslim Women

Category: Americas, Faith & Spirituality, Life & Society Topics: Women Views: 3145

If the media and its ensuing stereotypes are to be believed then Islam does not have very much to offer women, except for a life of misery, oppression and slavery. However, if one bothers to look closely at Islam then it has an abundance to offer men and women alike.

There is little doubt that many Muslim women are subject to abuse and subjugation  without making sweeping generalizations, many women in some so called Muslim lands are denied the rights given to them by Islam  rights to which they are entitled as human beings and as women. However we must separate Muslims from Islam; we must separate theory from practice. In Islam this separation is possible  Islamic legislation has given women unprecedented status, even if Muslims did not always live up to these amazing standards.

Let us take a quick look at some of the rights of women in Islam, comparing them with some of the legislation relating to women in Britain:


Considered by many these days as a basic human right, in Islam both men and women are duty bound to seek education for the Prophet Muhammad said: "The search for knowledge is a duty on every Muslim" [Bukhari]. So, while there were no places at British Universities until the late 1870s (Ox. Ill. His. Brit. p493), there have been records of Islamic Universities with women students throughout the history of Islam: Nafisah was an early 8th century hadith scholar and the great jurist Imam al-Shaf'i participated in her circle at Al-Fustaat. Shaika Shuhuda another 8th century scholar was a lecturer at Baghdad University  the Oxford and Cambridge of its time. Nazhun was a 12th century scholar and of course we cannot forget Aisha (ra), the wife of the Prophet who in the 7th century was one of the greatest relaters of hadith.

So, whilst Muslim women were attending universities and were lecturers and scholars in the 8th century, 80% of London Women and 100% of East Anglican women were illiterate in 1640  figures taken from A. Fraser page 129 and D. Cressy page 178.

Political Participation

Women in the UK managed to gain the right to vote in 1918, but that was only for women over thirty. They did not manage to gain full voting rights equal with men until 1928. These gains were not achieved easily though  to gain the vote the Suffragettes marched, rallied, chained themselves to railings, went on hunger strike and eventually one of them jumped in front of the Royal Horse on Derby Day. Muslims women however each had the right to give or not to give their allegiance from the beginning  and this right was given them without them having to march, rally, not eat or jump in front of a horse.


Up until 1801 British women did not have the right to own anything  not even themselves. For up until this time a husband had the right to sell his wife. In Sweden in 1984 a man was entitled to half his wife's earnings. Islam though has allowed women to own their own property from the outset. Everything a woman earns belongs to her. She is not a chattel to be bought and sold, but rather an individual human being, responsible to no one for her income except for God. A married woman may remind her husband: "What's his is theirs, what's hers is her own!"

It would be easy to go on with a list of the rights of women in Islam  but how does Islam really benefit women?

Islam has given women the right to be themselves! They are equal before God  on the Day of Judgment they will be answerable as individuals and cannot say "my husband told me to do it", "my, father, brother, uncle  led me astray". Nor will they be treated unfairly because they are women  women have souls in Islam  and there has never been any debate about that in Islamic history unlike in Christianity!

Islam offers to women, as it does to men, a belief in God, and this upholds everything. Belief in the Creator gives life a wholeness, and a balance, for it means that we do not look at everything in the short term  the intrinsic whole is this world and the Hereafter. This belief in God, this taqwa  God consciousness  thus shapes everything in Islam.

Men and women in Islam are protecting friends of one another; they are garments of each other hiding each other's faults. The Qur'an says:

"Verily, for all men and women who have surrendered themselves unto God, and all believing men and believing women, and all men and women who are true to their word, and all men and women who are patient in adversity, and all men and women who humble themselves before God, and all men and women who give in charity, and all self denying men and self denying women, and all men and women who are mindful of their chastity, and all men and women who remember God unceasingly: for all of them has God readied forgiveness of sins and a mighty reward". [Surah 33: verse 35]

This verse offers women so much; it offers them paradise on the basis of their own actions. It demands of them good character, tells both men and women to be active; and instills in them the sense of individual responsibility.

So, Islam offers to women, as it offers to men  paradise as a reward, it offers a complete picture which considers both this world and the hereafter  built solidly upon the foundation of a believe in The Creator. A relationship with one's Creator brings untold peace  for men and for women.

Islam allows women to know themselves as they are. Thus in Islam women are equal to men, but they are not the same. Men and women are equal before God  they are the protecting friends of one another, they are garments of one another, hiding one another's faults; but they are not the same. In Islam  imitation is not liberation.

Women are not men  an obvious statement, but one which is often overlooked. Islam offers a balance  which can be seen if one looks to nature  black and white, up and down, day and night etc. etc. Two halves to form a whole. Balance is absolutely vital. But, after the industrial revolution women and men are becoming more and more alike. Men have become cogs in the system. Women have also been pulled into the consumerism of an industrialized society and have been forced into the work place, but still receive no help at home  a recent study showed that 9 out of 10 men were not 'New Men' and did not help out at home (The Times, Nov. 1995).

Western society has ignored the balance and told women that for them to have status they must achieve what men achieve. Western society has created a new image for women based on the male  and this is very objectionable. Rather than highlighting her individual strengths, she is told to compete according to male criteria in order to have value. But she is not given any help to cope with her additional responsibilities. "Work, have a career to achieve status  but we will not provide crucial facilities, or time off during school holidays." We are now facing a situation where, as the President of Bosnia, Alija Ali Izebegovic, said:

"Modern civilization has disgraced motherhood... It has preferred the calling of a salesgirl, model, teacher of other people's children, secretary, cleaning woman and so on to that of mother. It has proclaimed motherhood to be slavery and promised to free women from it." [Islam Between East and West p.144145]

So, we have put down the feminine and are saying: 'masculine criteria is the best, indeed only thing to judge by, feminine criteria is second class  useless'.

But in Islam both are equal, but they are different. So in Islam we do not have the situation where: the logical is perceived as better than the lateral; the firm is perceived as better than the tender; the analytical is perceived as better than the intuitive. In Islam women do not say: "I'm only a housewife"  Where did this ONLY come from?  It came from taking the masculine criteria as best. Why is being in the rat-race superior to being a mother? Because we see the masculine as superior to the feminine. Where is the spirit of the Malcolm X (Malik-al-Shabazz) quote:

"If you educate a man you educate one person; if you educate a woman you educate and liberate a nation".

Women in Islam of course have a role beyond that of motherhood  one does not spend 25 years preparing for and another 25 years recovering from motherhood  but the point is do not demean motherhood; and do not demean and belittle the feminine. Islam offers to women pride in the feminine. The equal but different roles of men and women in Islam have to be understood, and in understanding individuals can be themselves, and thus find a balance and true happiness.

And this peace and security allows and gives room for the development of a woman's potential based on her own strengths.

Young Muslims is a Canadian based Islamic organization working towards educating the public on the balanced and correct message of Islam 

  Category: Americas, Faith & Spirituality, Life & Society
  Topics: Women
Views: 3145

Related Suggestions

The opinions expressed herein, through this post or comments, contain positions and viewpoints that are not necessarily those of IslamiCity. These are offered as a means for IslamiCity to stimulate dialogue and discussion in our continuing mission of being an educational organization. The IslamiCity site may occasionally contain copyrighted material the use of which may not always have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. IslamiCity is making such material available in its effort to advance understanding of humanitarian, education, democracy, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law.

In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, and such (and all) material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.

Older Comments:
I was hoping someone to write up column for muslim WOMEN to own up to their responsibilities of raising the right children in islamic way rather than worrying about what rights men have or women have.
All men(including myself) and women should check themselves in the mirror and see if they are doing their part of spreading the knowledge of islam to their children and are implementing it themselves properly, start with making salat at right time and being honest and humble.
If every muslim family takes care of their own first in an islamic way . that will be a good start.

Dear Muslima, although you don't agree with my comments I agree with yours. However, you should go back and read carefully what I wrote. I never said that so called "modern or western society" have introduced universal laws or women rights. Nor have they introduced anything new, (because the key word was this 'century') these societies have to a greater degree promoted and encouraged Islamic teaching. AGAIN, my comparison was Muslim society verses western society, but you made the same mistake of understanding Muslim society to be "Islamic". There is a difference between Muslim societies and Islamic teachings. If I criticize Muslim societies it does not mean I'm criticizing Islamic teaching. You must distinguish between the two. In addition Muslima, if I find faults with Muslim societies today, does that make me "secular". Why do you assume that I am a secularist, is it because I judged the quality of Muslim societies??? Is it that same old argument 'you're either with us or against us'? Please in the future do not make assumptions about my schooling(you would be surprised) because to assume without have any facts that is "arrogance". I am fully aware of Islamic teaching and history and I can distinguished between Muslim societies and these teaching. To add to your points even today's International laws and are a carbon copy of Islamic teaching. Making assumptions of my identity will not make your agrument any stronger, it will actually makes it weaker because your avoiding the argument.You must learn to read *carefully*.


Salamu alaikum,

I cannot but comment on Leila's point. It is troubling to notice that she misses the points raised and take it as critic and offense to some extent to the so called "modern" society. My experience have been that the young generations of ours have been raised in the so called "secular" schools so no wonder they are totally ignorant of 2 main things to be fully muslims: The Islamic teachings and History.
For e.g. where do these "universal standards" come from? They are from Allah s.w.t. only since He sent his message and legislation as universal method for all man kind. It is amazing to notice how much the young genration is more and more ignorant of History to think that every thing or almost have been invented in this "modern" society. The human rights charter that have been captured in the Western law only the last 60 years have been based on the Islamic heritage. One has only to scrutinize the Roman/Napoleonean Code and the English Common Law to notice that it is based on possession, control and power. Working women is not new and special to today's western world. We can trace working muslim women all over the muslim land today and in the past. The only period where they have been prevented from any outside or community activities is during the colonization (150 years ago). This has created the calamity of generations of muslim men completely ignorant of the Islamic teachings and coming back to their pre-Islamic tribal and cultural habits in feeling good controlling women and children and any dependent people on them. The dellusional situation of working mother is only another catastrophy of this "modern" era. Society has to adapt its structure to help a working couple otherwise the result is shattering the family and all the misery we see around us every day. Muslim society has the structural support based on family close and extended as well as the neighborhood to help women work outside the home so why not use this framework instead.

Salamu alaikum Young Muslims,

Very nice article may Allah keep you and all of us on the straight path. I enjoyed the points raised and with a bit more research you would gain more clarity and soundness. It is sad to see nowadays muslims women ignoring their rights and duties in Islam. Muslim women and men have equal rights and responsible choices before Allah, equal chances and opportunities to grow in Islam. They just have to work on it and for it. Allah s.w.t. created us complementary and different and the difference has been accounted for in the Islamic legal framework and legislation. Every thing a woman does is for Allah sake and Allah s.w.t. only. The miserable state the muslim land has reached today is only the clear reflection of the muslim community ignorance of the Islamic teachings. For who's ever familiar with History imposing, controlling and killing are clear behavior of ignorant, arrogant and non God fearing humans. Islam came to free people from these plagues by submitting to Allah s.w.t. ONLY and Allah only no one else. The only path for women to be free is to be well knowledgeable of their rights and duties in Islam. Our Islamic knowledge and history is full of muslim women role models to follow the first ones are: Maryam, Assia (Pharao's wife), Bilqees queen of Saba, the wives of our beloved Prophet s.a.w. Khadeeja, Aycha, Hafsa just to name these. Up to the 19'th century we can trace women as leaders of teachings of Quran and Hadeeth in most muslim land. We can also trace women working in various fields especially in handcrafts, agriculture and trading. During and after the colonization period the muslim teaching structure has been completely wrecked every where in the muslim land to the point where the Talibans went and banned women and girls schooling preventing them from acquiring their rightful Islamic teachings (sic!). Islam has put motherhood as the family pillar for it's the first and main support and guidance for the children.

Dear writer, you lack clarity.As a reader I appreciate your attempt to illustrate the difference between Muslims and Islam on treatment of women, however you bit more than you can chew.You note that Western society and modern civilization has rejected and refused to take notice of "Motherhood", but what about Eastern or Muslim society?What have our Muslim societies accomplished for women or motherhood in this century, or what is the status of women in those societies. It is easier to nitpik other societies instead of our own. In addition, the right to work is not a male criteria, it is a universal standard, which the judgment and decision is based on the individual. What about a salesman,cleaningmen, male-teacher are they preferred over a father?The same question can be asked for males "Why is being in the rat-race superior to being a father?". What a paradox that the writer requests not to demean motherhood or feminine, but we as Muslims are the greater ones "today" that demean these qualities.Please, in the future define the key aspects of the article. Such as, what are "The equal but different roles of men and women in Islam"? Islam is about growth, the rights given to women in Islam were meant to grow and be further encouraged, not to stay static in a certain time frame or culture.You have to upgrade your agrument, because in today's age (predominantly in the Western world)women can work and be mothers at the same time. Women should not be limited to one or the other, they should have the power and opportunity of choosing. Somewhere in this argument there are negative masculine undertones, please review it. Dear writer, thank you for your effort, I truly admire it.