Science in Islam: E02 - Ibn Hanbal Inquisition
Caspian Report|/source/caspian-report
|
Caspian Report|/source/caspian-report
Source: Caspian Report Nov 12, 2017 No Comments
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UUx9NzzTz-0
{file:content.php} {function:blp_getCustomField} {postID:13241} {customField:theClapCount} {default:0}not-in-use-in-plain-child
Category: Featured, Nature & Science, Videos Topics: History, Islam And Science, Islamic Culture And Civilization, Islamic Golden Age, Silk Road Views: {file:content.php} {function:blp_getCustomField} {postID:13241} {customField:ic-view-count}2161



Science in Islam: E01 - Mu'tazila Free Will
Science in Islam: E02 - Ibn Hanbal Inquisition
Science in Islam: E03 - Ash'ari Predestination
Advertisement
Science in Islam: E04 - Al-Ghazali Incoherence
Category: Featured, Nature & Science, Videos
Topics: History, Islam And Science, Islamic Culture And Civilization, Islamic Golden Age, Silk Road
Views:2161
Topics: History, Islam And Science, Islamic Culture And Civilization, Islamic Golden Age, Silk Road
Views:2161
{file:content.php} {function:blp_getPosts_FAST()} {theNext:true} {taxonomy:post_tag} {terms:history OR islam-and-science OR islamic-culture-and-civilization OR islamic-golden-age OR silk-road} {count:12} {taxonomy2:category} {terms2:featured} {about:content.php/blp_getPosts_FAST()} {unwanted:13241} {randomize:1}
Related Suggestions
a:19:{s:8:"theTitle";s:20:"The Story of Hussain";s:12:"thePermalink";s:54:"https://www.islamicity.org/78873/the-story-of-hussain/";s:13:"theAuthorName";s:15:"Who Is Hussain?";s:12:"theThumbnail";s:56:"https://img.youtube.com/vi/emfT8syx7R0/maxresdefault.jpg";s:6:"isWhat";s:5:"video";s:7:"theIcon";s:33:"";s:8:"theEmbed";s:43:"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=emfT8syx7R0";s:11:"theCategory";s:44:"cannot-retrieve-category-see-cell-part-1.php";s:6:"theTag";s:25:"martydom|/topics/martydom";s:7:"theDate";s:10:"Jul 5 2025";s:11:"theDate_ORG";s:40:"August 11, 2021 {wpcf-soft-date engaged}";s:9:"theAuthor";s:38:"Who Is Hussain?|/source/who-is-hussain";s:5:"theID";i:78873;s:14:"theReadingTime";s:7:"28 min.";s:10:"theExcerpt";s:94:"This artilce gives an insight into the tragedy of Karbala, its reasons and its consequences ..";s:12:"theTitle_ORG";s:20:"The Story of Hussain";s:25:"processRelatedFacetsTitle";s:0:"";s:15:"whereItCameFrom";s:138:"content.php & related posts > post_tag=history OR islam-and-science OR islamic-culture-and-civilization OR islamic-golden-age OR silk-road";s:8:"theFacet";s:0:"";}
a:19:{s:8:"theTitle";s:42:"History of Imam Ḥusayn and His Martyrdom";s:12:"thePermalink";s:73:"https://www.islamicity.org/6340/history-of-imam-husain-and-his-martyrdom/";s:13:"theAuthorName";s:18:"Abdullah Yusuf Ali";s:12:"theThumbnail";s:86:"https://media.islamicity.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/martyrdom_of_imam_hussain2.jpg";s:6:"isWhat";s:7:"article";s:7:"theIcon";s:0:"";s:8:"theEmbed";s:0:"";s:11:"theCategory";s:44:"cannot-retrieve-category-see-cell-part-1.php";s:6:"theTag";s:33:"imam hussain|/topics/imam-hussain";s:7:"theDate";s:10:"Jul 4 2025";s:11:"theDate_ORG";s:41:"January 29, 2007 {wpcf-soft-date engaged}";s:9:"theAuthor";s:41:"Abdullah Yusuf Ali|/by/abdullah-yusuf-ali";s:5:"theID";i:6340;s:14:"theReadingTime";s:7:"28 min.";s:10:"theExcerpt";s:94:"This artilce gives an insight into the tragedy of Karbala, its reasons and its consequences ..";s:12:"theTitle_ORG";s:42:"History of Imam Ḥusayn and His Martyrdom";s:25:"processRelatedFacetsTitle";s:0:"";s:15:"whereItCameFrom";s:138:"content.php & related posts > post_tag=history OR islam-and-science OR islamic-culture-and-civilization OR islamic-golden-age OR silk-road";s:8:"theFacet";s:0:"";}
a:19:{s:8:"theTitle";s:34:"Why Thomas Jefferson Owned a Quran";s:12:"thePermalink";s:68:"https://www.islamicity.org/16209/why-thomas-jefferson-owned-a-quran/";s:13:"theAuthorName";s:13:"Peter Manseau";s:12:"theThumbnail";s:77:"https://media.islamicity.org/wp-content/uploads/2018/07/tj_koran_vols_583.jpg";s:6:"isWhat";s:7:"article";s:7:"theIcon";s:0:"";s:8:"theEmbed";s:0:"";s:11:"theCategory";s:44:"cannot-retrieve-category-see-cell-part-1.php";s:6:"theTag";s:41:"thomas jefferson|/topics/thomas-jefferson";s:7:"theDate";s:10:"Jul 4 2025";s:11:"theDate_ORG";s:37:"July 1, 2018 {wpcf-soft-date engaged}";s:9:"theAuthor";s:31:"Peter Manseau|/by/peter-manseau";s:5:"theID";i:16209;s:14:"theReadingTime";s:7:"11 min.";s:10:"theExcerpt";s:1:" ";s:12:"theTitle_ORG";s:34:"Why Thomas Jefferson Owned a Quran";s:25:"processRelatedFacetsTitle";s:0:"";s:15:"whereItCameFrom";s:138:"content.php & related posts > post_tag=history OR islam-and-science OR islamic-culture-and-civilization OR islamic-golden-age OR silk-road";s:8:"theFacet";s:0:"";}
a:19:{s:8:"theTitle";s:60:"Truth vs. Tyranny: The Eternal Struggle from Karbala to Gaza";s:12:"thePermalink";s:93:"https://www.islamicity.org/105098/truth-vs-tyranny-the-eternal-struggle-from-karbala-to-gaza/";s:13:"theAuthorName";s:12:"Sirat Within";s:12:"theThumbnail";s:56:"https://img.youtube.com/vi/HdtjK7KCT24/maxresdefault.jpg";s:6:"isWhat";s:5:"video";s:7:"theIcon";s:33:"";s:8:"theEmbed";s:43:"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HdtjK7KCT24";s:11:"theCategory";s:44:"cannot-retrieve-category-see-cell-part-1.php";s:6:"theTag";s:23:"karbala|/topics/karbala";s:7:"theDate";s:10:"Jul 1 2025";s:11:"theDate_ORG";s:37:"July 1, 2025 {wpcf-soft-date engaged}";s:9:"theAuthor";s:33:"Sirat Within|/source/sirat-within";s:5:"theID";i:105098;s:14:"theReadingTime";s:6:"1 min.";s:10:"theExcerpt";s:186:"If you’ve ever wondered why Karbala still matters, or if you see its reflection in today’s headlines, its message remains deeply relevant.
Is Palestine another Karbala? In Kar......";s:12:"theTitle_ORG";s:60:"Truth vs. Tyranny: The Eternal Struggle from Karbala to Gaza";s:25:"processRelatedFacetsTitle";s:0:"";s:15:"whereItCameFrom";s:138:"content.php & related posts > post_tag=history OR islam-and-science OR islamic-culture-and-civilization OR islamic-golden-age OR silk-road";s:8:"theFacet";s:0:"";}
a:19:{s:8:"theTitle";s:31:"Muharram and Sectarian Politics";s:12:"thePermalink";s:65:"https://www.islamicity.org/58071/muharram-and-sectarian-politics/";s:13:"theAuthorName";s:14:"Aslam Abdullah";s:12:"theThumbnail";s:82:"https://media.islamicity.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/shia-sunni-curved-road.jpg";s:6:"isWhat";s:7:"article";s:7:"theIcon";s:0:"";s:8:"theEmbed";s:0:"";s:11:"theCategory";s:44:"cannot-retrieve-category-see-cell-part-1.php";s:6:"theTag";s:33:"imam hussain|/topics/imam-hussain";s:7:"theDate";s:11:"Jun 30 2025";s:11:"theDate_ORG";s:40:"August 19, 2020 {wpcf-soft-date engaged}";s:9:"theAuthor";s:33:"Aslam Abdullah|/by/aslam-abdullah";s:5:"theID";i:58071;s:14:"theReadingTime";s:6:"7 min.";s:10:"theExcerpt";s:186:"Those who take pride in calling them Sunnis will focus on the migration of Prophet Muhammad (Peace Be Upon Him) from Makkah to Medina in 622 C.E., and those who describe them as su......";s:12:"theTitle_ORG";s:31:"Muharram and Sectarian Politics";s:25:"processRelatedFacetsTitle";s:0:"";s:15:"whereItCameFrom";s:138:"content.php & related posts > post_tag=history OR islam-and-science OR islamic-culture-and-civilization OR islamic-golden-age OR silk-road";s:8:"theFacet";s:0:"";}
a:19:{s:8:"theTitle";s:50:"History of Hijrah: Migration for Peace and Justice";s:12:"thePermalink";s:82:"https://www.islamicity.org/6327/history-of-hijrah-migration-for-peace-and-justice/";s:13:"theAuthorName";s:19:"Nimah Ismail Nawwab";s:12:"theThumbnail";s:84:"https://media.islamicity.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/iStock-1191767465-scaled.jpg";s:6:"isWhat";s:7:"article";s:7:"theIcon";s:0:"";s:8:"theEmbed";s:0:"";s:11:"theCategory";s:44:"cannot-retrieve-category-see-cell-part-1.php";s:6:"theTag";s:35:"makkah (mecca)|/topics/makkah-mecca";s:7:"theDate";s:11:"Jun 26 2025";s:11:"theDate_ORG";s:40:"January 7, 2008 {wpcf-soft-date engaged}";s:9:"theAuthor";s:43:"Nimah Ismail Nawwab|/by/nimah-ismail-nawwab";s:5:"theID";i:6327;s:14:"theReadingTime";s:7:"10 min.";s:10:"theExcerpt";s:137:"Hijrah was not a flight but a carefully planned migration which marks not only a break in history but the beginning of the Islamic era ..";s:12:"theTitle_ORG";s:50:"History of Hijrah: Migration for Peace and Justice";s:25:"processRelatedFacetsTitle";s:0:"";s:15:"whereItCameFrom";s:138:"content.php & related posts > post_tag=history OR islam-and-science OR islamic-culture-and-civilization OR islamic-golden-age OR silk-road";s:8:"theFacet";s:0:"";}
a:19:{s:8:"theTitle";s:43:"Muharram: The Start of the Islamic Calendar";s:12:"thePermalink";s:75:"https://www.islamicity.org/6321/muharram-the-start-of-the-islamic-calendar/";s:13:"theAuthorName";s:20:"Muhammad Taqi Usmani";s:12:"theThumbnail";s:85:"https://media.islamicity.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/08/desert-night-muharram-isp.jpg";s:6:"isWhat";s:7:"article";s:7:"theIcon";s:0:"";s:8:"theEmbed";s:0:"";s:11:"theCategory";s:44:"cannot-retrieve-category-see-cell-part-1.php";s:6:"theTag";s:23:"history|/topics/history";s:7:"theDate";s:11:"Jun 26 2025";s:11:"theDate_ORG";s:38:"March 4, 2003 {wpcf-soft-date engaged}";s:9:"theAuthor";s:45:"Muhammad Taqi Usmani|/by/muhammad-taqi-usmani";s:5:"theID";i:6321;s:14:"theReadingTime";s:7:"13 min.";s:10:"theExcerpt";s:212:"The number of the months according to Allah is twelve months (mentioned) in the Book of Allah on the day in which He created heavens and the earth. Among these (twelve months) there are four sanctified (Quran) ..";s:12:"theTitle_ORG";s:43:"Muharram: The Start of the Islamic Calendar";s:25:"processRelatedFacetsTitle";s:0:"";s:15:"whereItCameFrom";s:138:"content.php & related posts > post_tag=history OR islam-and-science OR islamic-culture-and-civilization OR islamic-golden-age OR silk-road";s:8:"theFacet";s:0:"";}
a:19:{s:8:"theTitle";s:29:"History of The Persian Empire";s:12:"thePermalink";s:64:"https://www.islamicity.org/105023/history-of-the-persian-empire/";s:13:"theAuthorName";s:16:"Beginning to Now";s:12:"theThumbnail";s:56:"https://img.youtube.com/vi/5EtbBU0beus/maxresdefault.jpg";s:6:"isWhat";s:5:"video";s:7:"theIcon";s:33:"";s:8:"theEmbed";s:43:"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5EtbBU0beus";s:11:"theCategory";s:44:"cannot-retrieve-category-see-cell-part-1.php";s:6:"theTag";s:17:"iran|/topics/iran";s:7:"theDate";s:11:"Jun 24 2025";s:11:"theDate_ORG";s:38:"June 24, 2025 {wpcf-soft-date engaged}";s:9:"theAuthor";s:41:"Beginning to Now|/source/beginning-to-now";s:5:"theID";i:105023;s:14:"theReadingTime";s:6:"7 min.";s:10:"theExcerpt";s:186:"Summary of "The ENTIRE History of The Persian Empire":
The video presents a comprehensive historical overview of Persia (modern-day Iran), one of the world’s oldest and most res......";s:12:"theTitle_ORG";s:29:"History of The Persian Empire";s:25:"processRelatedFacetsTitle";s:0:"";s:15:"whereItCameFrom";s:138:"content.php & related posts > post_tag=history OR islam-and-science OR islamic-culture-and-civilization OR islamic-golden-age OR silk-road";s:8:"theFacet";s:0:"";}
a:19:{s:8:"theTitle";s:49:"The Sixth Crusade: Global War from Gaza to Tehran";s:12:"thePermalink";s:83:"https://www.islamicity.org/104925/the-sixth-crusade-global-war-from-gaza-to-tehran/";s:13:"theAuthorName";s:14:"Roy Casagranda";s:12:"theThumbnail";s:56:"https://img.youtube.com/vi/CSFaEFZ8sgY/maxresdefault.jpg";s:6:"isWhat";s:5:"video";s:7:"theIcon";s:33:"";s:8:"theEmbed";s:43:"https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CSFaEFZ8sgY";s:11:"theCategory";s:44:"cannot-retrieve-category-see-cell-part-1.php";s:6:"theTag";s:31:"imperialism|/topics/imperialism";s:7:"theDate";s:11:"Jun 17 2025";s:11:"theDate_ORG";s:38:"June 17, 2025 {wpcf-soft-date engaged}";s:9:"theAuthor";s:33:"Roy Casagranda|/by/roy-casagranda";s:5:"theID";i:104925;s:14:"theReadingTime";s:7:"29 min.";s:10:"theExcerpt";s:136:"Historian Roy Casagranda argues that the U.S.-Israel "War on Terror" is a modern-day Crusade, rooted in European colonialism and racism.";s:12:"theTitle_ORG";s:49:"The Sixth Crusade: Global War from Gaza to Tehran";s:25:"processRelatedFacetsTitle";s:0:"";s:15:"whereItCameFrom";s:138:"content.php & related posts > post_tag=history OR islam-and-science OR islamic-culture-and-civilization OR islamic-golden-age OR silk-road";s:8:"theFacet";s:0:"";}
a:19:{s:8:"theTitle";s:52:"“Be”: The Monosyllabic Prompt of Divine Creation";s:12:"thePermalink";s:80:"https://www.islamicity.org/104787/be-the-monosyllabic-prompt-of-divine-creation/";s:13:"theAuthorName";s:19:"Muhammed Nafih Wafy";s:12:"theThumbnail";s:72:"https://media.islamicity.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/AI-and-Islam.png";s:6:"isWhat";s:7:"article";s:7:"theIcon";s:0:"";s:8:"theEmbed";s:0:"";s:11:"theCategory";s:44:"cannot-retrieve-category-see-cell-part-1.php";s:6:"theTag";s:43:"islam and science|/topics/islam-and-science";s:7:"theDate";s:10:"Jun 1 2025";s:11:"theDate_ORG";s:37:"June 1, 2025 {wpcf-soft-date engaged}";s:9:"theAuthor";s:43:"Muhammed Nafih Wafy|/by/muhammed-nafih-wafy";s:5:"theID";i:104787;s:14:"theReadingTime";s:7:"26 min.";s:10:"theExcerpt";s:61:"God can bring anything into existence in the blink of an eye.";s:12:"theTitle_ORG";s:52:"“Be”: The Monosyllabic Prompt of Divine Creation";s:25:"processRelatedFacetsTitle";s:0:"";s:15:"whereItCameFrom";s:138:"content.php & related posts > post_tag=history OR islam-and-science OR islamic-culture-and-civilization OR islamic-golden-age OR silk-road";s:8:"theFacet";s:0:"";}
a:19:{s:8:"theTitle";s:33:"Qur'anic Insights on the Universe";s:12:"thePermalink";s:67:"https://www.islamicity.org/103971/quranic-insights-on-the-universe/";s:13:"theAuthorName";s:11:"S. M. Yunus";s:12:"theThumbnail";s:79:"https://media.islamicity.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/quranic-reflections.jpg";s:6:"isWhat";s:7:"article";s:7:"theIcon";s:0:"";s:8:"theEmbed";s:0:"";s:11:"theCategory";s:44:"cannot-retrieve-category-see-cell-part-1.php";s:6:"theTag";s:37:"quran guidance|/topics/quran-guidance";s:7:"theDate";s:11:"May 26 2025";s:11:"theDate_ORG";s:41:"January 27, 2025 {wpcf-soft-date engaged}";s:9:"theAuthor";s:25:"S. M. Yunus|/by/s-m-yunus";s:5:"theID";i:103971;s:14:"theReadingTime";s:7:"23 min.";s:10:"theExcerpt";s:106:"Just from a casual glance at the night sky it appears to us that the universe is magnificent and majestic.";s:12:"theTitle_ORG";s:33:"Qur'anic Insights on the Universe";s:25:"processRelatedFacetsTitle";s:0:"";s:15:"whereItCameFrom";s:138:"content.php & related posts > post_tag=history OR islam-and-science OR islamic-culture-and-civilization OR islamic-golden-age OR silk-road";s:8:"theFacet";s:0:"";}
a:19:{s:8:"theTitle";s:28:"The Science of moon-sighting";s:12:"thePermalink";s:61:"https://www.islamicity.org/2717/the-science-of-moon-sighting/";s:13:"theAuthorName";s:14:"Khalid Shaukat";s:12:"theThumbnail";s:92:"https://www.islamicity.org/global/images/photo/IC-Articles/ramadan_moon_chartIC__600x409.JPG";s:6:"isWhat";s:7:"article";s:7:"theIcon";s:0:"";s:8:"theEmbed";s:0:"";s:11:"theCategory";s:44:"cannot-retrieve-category-see-cell-part-1.php";s:6:"theTag";s:53:"nature and environment|/topics/nature-and-environment";s:7:"theDate";s:11:"May 23 2025";s:11:"theDate_ORG";s:43:"September 22, 2005 {wpcf-soft-date engaged}";s:9:"theAuthor";s:33:"Khalid Shaukat|/by/khalid-shaukat";s:5:"theID";i:2717;s:14:"theReadingTime";s:6:"9 min.";s:10:"theExcerpt";s:122:"Most people associate visibility with the age of the moon. Age of the moon is simply the time lapsed since the new moon ..";s:12:"theTitle_ORG";s:28:"The Science of moon-sighting";s:25:"processRelatedFacetsTitle";s:0:"";s:15:"whereItCameFrom";s:138:"content.php & related posts > post_tag=history OR islam-and-science OR islamic-culture-and-civilization OR islamic-golden-age OR silk-road";s:8:"theFacet";s:0:"";}
COMMENTS DISCLAIMER & RULES OF ENGAGEMENT
The opinions expressed herein, through this post or comments, contain positions and viewpoints that are not necessarily those of IslamiCity. These are offered as a means for IslamiCity to stimulate dialogue and discussion in our continuing mission of being an educational organization.
The IslamiCity site may occasionally contain copyrighted material the use of which may not always have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. IslamiCity is making such material available in its effort to advance understanding of humanitarian, education, democracy, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law.
In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, and such (and all) material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.