IslamiCity.org Homepage
Forum Home Forum Home > Religion - Islam > Interfaith Dialogue
  New Posts New Posts RSS Feed - According to Christian Doctrine / Teaching About L  What is Islam What is Islam  Donate Donate
  FAQ FAQ  Quran Search Quran Search  Forum Search   Events   Register Register  Login Login

According to Christian Doctrine / Teaching About L

 Post Reply Post Reply Page  <1 345
Author
Message Reverse Sort Order
Al Saadiqeen21 View Drop Down
Guest Group
Guest Group
Avatar

Joined: 19 August 2012
Status: Offline
Points: 547
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Al Saadiqeen21 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 23 February 2014 at 7:17am
Originally posted by Lachi Lachi wrote:

Some interesting points. That the Gospels are not eye witness accounts, and contain contradictions, is self evident just by reading them. But the Gospel of Luke was written before the Acts of Apostles, and whilst the Gospels are contradictory over sequences or location of events, do they not all record the words of Jesus? Is not the message of Jesus the important thing?
 
First The Prophet / Messiah Isa son of Mary Nevever said anything the Bible Matthew , Mark , Luke , John  said The Prophet / Messiah Isa son of Mary said this that or the other . But
 
Lakum Diinukum Wa -Ya Diin = '' You will have your decision , And I will have mine .
One doesn't go to school let His / her's mind to die , They go to school so that their mind will come alive .

Back to Top
Lachi View Drop Down
Senior Member
Senior Member
Avatar
Male
Joined: 18 February 2014
Status: Offline
Points: 140
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Lachi Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 22 February 2014 at 5:09pm
Some interesting points. That the Gospels are not eye witness accounts, and contain contradictions, is self evident just by reading them. But the Gospel of Luke was written before the Acts of Apostles, and whilst the Gospels are contradictory over sequences or location of events, do they not all record the words of Jesus? Is not the message of Jesus the important thing?
Back to Top
Al Saadiqeen21 View Drop Down
Guest Group
Guest Group
Avatar

Joined: 19 August 2012
Status: Offline
Points: 547
Post Options Post Options   Thanks (0) Thanks(0)   Quote Al Saadiqeen21 Quote  Post ReplyReply Direct Link To This Post Posted: 21 February 2014 at 5:13pm
 
Because the recorders of The Gospels wrote what They Heard as Opposed  to what they saw . None of the recorders of The Synoptic Gospel were present after they fled to The Garden . Yashu'a  called Twelve Men to Discipleship , Our of the Twelve Two of them  wrote their Version of the Crucifixion . John son of Zebedee's account is Fact , Where as the other , Gospel's accounts are Tales . The other Two Writers  of The Gospel , Luke , And Mark, weren't Disciples .  Why is it that Peter has no record of The Crucifixion , And he was there to see everything that happen . He never even recorded the fact that he denied Yashu'a Three Times . In Paul's Book , He mentions something about The Crucifixion , But he doesn't actually say that Yashu'a died on the cross .
 
The fact is , The Synoptic Gospels are writings of what these Men Were Told  by way of Mouth , None of the Disciples were present and Mark and Luke weren't Disciples at all . Mark was a Judahite  from Jerusalem ; And a property owner . His mother Mary was a supporter of The Prophet / Messiah Yashu'a  teaching and thus open her home to The Disciples and their followers for it to serve as their gathering place .
 
John joined The Disciples Barnabas and Saul, Shaool , Paul The 13th Self -Appointed Apostle , On their first Missionary Journey , 47-48 A.D. , And travelled to The Greek Isle of Antioch to propagate the word of The Prophet / Messiah Yashu'a  to The Lost Sheep Of The House of Israel . He served as Minister to Barnabas and Paul and was considered a Deacon or Servant . Who adided them . Mark also served as an Interpreter and attendant to  Saul, Shaool , Paul . He would Translate  Saul, Shaool , Paul's Sermons into Greek so that the Gentiles could understand .
 
Mark Eventually left the first missionary journey and returned to Jerusalem . The caused dissension between Barnabas and Paul . Paul resented Mark leaving him and would not allow him to go on the second Missionary journey . However Barnabas insisted that he come . Barnabas and Paul ended up going their separate ways .
 
Luke was a Greek Physician  who was a companion of Paul on his second journey to Teach The Gentiles. He also accompanied Paul on the third missionary journey whose destination was Rome . Luke was also a well -travelled man with knowldge of navigation and was a great writer . He was able to bridge the gap between The Jews ( Jebusites of Canaan ) and the Gentiles . He taught that The Prophet / Messiah Yashu'a was a Universal Savior . The other Books of the New Testament aside from The Book of Revelation ; Acts of The Apostles and The Twenty -One Epistles were written by Luke and Paul . The Prophet / Messiah Yashu'a did not inscribe any of these books nor were they Divinely Inspired . They , Like Synoptic Gospels
, ( Are Words Of Men ) And therefore should not be trusted .
 
Contradiction Of Luke .
 
( 1 ) . Holy Ghost bestowed the day of Pentecost ( Acts 1;8 , 2;4 ) ...... Holy Ghost bestowed before Pentecost ( John 20 ; 22 ) .
 
( 2 ) . Luke says the disciples were instructed to go to Jerusalem and stay there . ( Luke 24 ; 49 ) .......The disciple were commanded to go to Galilee immediated after the resurrection ( Matthew 28 ; 10 ) .
 
( 3 ) . Luke says the disciples were instructed to go to Jerusalem and stay there ( Luke 24;49 ..... Matthew says it was Galilee on a mountain . ( Matthew 28 ; 16 ) .
 
( 4 ) . Luke and his friend ( Paul ) said the promised land never belonged to anyone . ( Acts 7;5 / Hebrew 11 ; 9.13 ) ..... Abraham's seed dod receive the promised land ( Genesis 13;14 ./ Genesis 13;15 ,17 ; 17;8 )
 
( 5 ) . Christ's mission was one of peace , Only ( Luke 2 ; 13 , 14 ) . Not so says Matthew . ( Matthew 10;34 ) .
 
( 6 ) . A Good name is a Curse says Luke , ( Luke 6;26 ) .... A Good name is a Blessing , ( Ecclesiastes 7 ; 1  , Proverbs 22 ; 1 ) .
 
( 7 ) . Abraham bought land for Sepulchre . ( Acts 7 ; 16 ) ....... Jacob purchased it says Joshua ( Joshua 24 ; 32 ) .
 
( 8 ) . Importunity ( Persitence ) in prayer is commended ( Luke 18 ; 5 , 7; 11;8 ) ..... Repetitious prayers are condemned ( Matthew 6 ; 7-8 ) .
 
( 9 ) . Women are in subjection to their Husbans ( 1Peter 3 ; 1 ) ...... Women can Prophesy . ( Acts 2;18 , 21 ; 9 ) , Contradicts Paul ( 1Corinthians 14 ; 24 , ( 1Timothy 2;12 ) .
 
( 10 ) . If you break the Law or Disobey The holy sporit you are a sinner . ( Mark 3;29 ) ,..... All that Believe have Sins of the Laws of Moses taken away ( Acts 13 ; 39 ) .
 
( 11 ) . Luke says Satan entered into Judas before the supper . ( Luke 22;3,4,7 ) ....... Satan entered Judas during the last supper , ( John 13 ; 27 ) .
 
( 12 ) . Luke says Judas purchased the Potter's field . ( Acts 1;18 ) ..... Matthew says the chief priests purchased the potters ( Matthew 27 ; 6 , 7 ) .
 
(13 ) . More than three Women came to The Sepulchre , ( Luke 24 ; 10 ) , ...... Just three Women came to The Sepulchre says Mark ( Mark 16 ; 1 ) .
 
(14 ) . Two men stood by The Sepulchre says Luke . ( Luke 24 ; 4 ) , ...... Only one man sat beside The Sepulchre  says Matthew ( Matthew 28 ; 2-3 ) .
 
( 15 ) . Luke said that Salah was the son of Cainan ( Luke 3 ; 34,36 ) , ....... Salah was the son of Arphaxad , ( Genesis 11; 12 ) .
 
( 16 ) . The infant Christ  was not taken into Egypt , ( Luke 2;22,39 )  ......  The infant Christ  was taken into Egypt . ( Matthew 2 ; 14 , 15 , 19 , 21 , 23 ) .
 
( 17 ) . Christ's first Sermon was in the plain . ( Luke 6 ; 17 , 20 ) , ..... Christ preached his first Sermon on the mount , Matthew 5 ; 1,2 ) .
 
Luke contradicts himself ;
 
* Christ ascended from Mount Olive ( Acts 1 ; 9 -12 ) .
* He says , ''No , I mean from Bethany ( Luke 24 ; 50 - 51 ) .
* Sell you garments to buy A Sword ( Luke 22 ; 36 ) .
* The same man change his mind ( Luke 12 ; 4 ) .
* Luke tells of Paul's vision , He said; The men heard a voice and stood speechless ( Acts 9 ; 7 ) .
* The men saw a light , But heard no voice ( Acts 22;9 ) .
* No , They all heard a voice ( Acts 26 ; 14 ) .
 
What it all boils down to Luke wrote The Book of Acts to verify Saul, Shaool , Paul The 13th Self -Appointed Apostle , '' calling '' . He contradicts the events of the ''Calling '' Three times . Its in The Bible !!! Luke's words are not to be trusted !! He wrote his own Opinions ( Yes,Opinions! ) of what actually took place during Yashu'a Ministry . Dates confirm that The Books of Acts was Written 27 Years  After The Alleged Crucifixion . The Book of Luke was Written 25 Years after that .
 
Therefore , He was Never Present at any of The Events He Wrote About . Luke 's only Movtive was to Gain Fame and Recognition for himself . Luke's opportunity arrived when  Saul, Shaool , Paul The 13th Self -Appointed Apostle , ( His Friend ) , Claimed Aposteship and eventual inclusion of The Gentiles to the Covenant . Can't you see ? The foundation that the Churches are Built is like the House that was carelessly Built On Top Of Sand . ( Matthew 7 ; 26-27 )
 
Mark Proclaimed ( Disciple of The Prophet / Messiah Yashu'a ..... Luke Proclaimed ( Disciple of The Prophet / Messiah Yashu'a .....
 
Luke Never got his calling from Yahuwa He did his Own Thing according to his Own Book !
 
The Gospel According to Luke 1 ; 1-4 , Where It States ; And I Quote ; Forasmuch as many have taken in hand ( To Set Forth In Order a declaration of those things Which Are Most Surely Believe among us . ( 2 ) .Even as they delivered then unto us . which from the beginning were eyewitnesses , and Minister of the Word . ( 3 ) . It seemed good to me also have had perfect understanding of all things From The Very First to write unto thee in order , most excellent Theophilus  ( 4 ) . That thou mightest know the certainty of those things , wherein thou hast been instructed . < King James Version ( Hebrew -Greek ) Keyword Study Bible >
 
One doesn't go to school let His / her's mind to die , They go to school so that their mind will come alive .

Back to Top
 Post Reply Post Reply Page  <1 345
  Share Topic   

Forum Jump Forum Permissions View Drop Down

Forum Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 12.03
Copyright ©2001-2019 Web Wiz Ltd.