9/11 Ten Years On: Who Will Remember the Muslim Dead?

Category: World Affairs Topics: United States Of America Views: 4045

On the 10th anniversary of 9/11, there has been extensive media coverage of the attacks that led to the death of nearly 3000 people on that day. There is no doubt 9/11 was a unique event in history. Nor can we doubt the terror and suffering inflicted on people in the United States that day. The United States and the West are entitled to recall that fear and remember their dead. No self respecting people or nation ignores those killed by wars, conflicts or terror. A government that does not respect the sanctity of life of its people is not a government at all.

In the United States people have gone one-step further and declared the whole of the area and streets around Ground Zero as sacred. They object to the building of a mosque anywhere near it. Imagine If Muslims were to adopt this logic, i.e. an area attacked by your enemy is sacred ground. We would then have the entire territories of Afghanistan, Iraq, Lebanon, Kashmir, Chechnya and Palestine as sacred lands and Western exclusion zones!

In the build up to the 10th anniversary, many Muslims have lamented, "what about the hundreds of thousands of Muslims killed by Western occupation since 9/11?" We can raise these issues as long as we wish, but we need to understand that Western governments do not care about Muslim life, they care for their own, and their interests above all else.

As we have just witnessed in Libya and Egypt, ethics, values and morality are not part of the Western political DNA. For decades these governments supported and aided regimes that inflicted great suffering on Muslim peoples. When the dictators could no longer survive, they swapped sides and pretend they are champions of the human rights of the people, without an ounce of remorse or guilt.

Anybody who believes that by highlighting these inconsistencies and hypocrisy there will be change in western policy towards the Muslim world is deluded. If the revolutionary movements in the Arab world have taught us anything, it is that the West will not change its behavior and policies unless forced to do so, or they can no longer sustain them.

Above all we must realize these policies will continue unless and until we Muslims change our own attitudes to Muslim life and suffering. Therefore, the real question we need to be asking ask ourselves is, how much do we respect the sanctity of Muslim life and property.

The Prophet Muhammad, peace be upon him. established the importance of this issue for us in his farewell sermon. He invited the people to listen to his farewell Hajj message at Mount Arafat a few months before his death. He asked his followers to listen carefully as he was about to address some important issues that needed to be conveyed to future Muslims. After 23 years of conveying messages of divine guidance on almost every issue, what is the very first issue of importance that he utters?

"O People, just as you regard this month, this day, this city as Sacred, so regard the life and property of every Muslim as a sacred trust". 

This sanctity of Muslim honor, life and property, is emphasized in various narrations We are even told it is forbidden to hand over a fellow Muslim to those who would do them harm. The duty to protect Muslim life and property therefore represents the key duty of Muslim brotherhood and being an Ummah. But are we are fulfilling this duty?

In recent decades we have witnessed appalling crimes against Muslims around the globe. We support charitable giving to these causes, and march the streets in protest. But that is just about it. An attitude that treats Muslim life and property as a sacred trust requires much more from us.

Do we remember the crimes committed against Muslims? Can we describe the horrific nature of them? Do we know that names of every person killed? Do we know how their families suffered and coped? Do we know if they are suffering still? Have those who have committed the crimes been named, have we exerted any effort to bring them to justice? Have we pursued the aggressors to pay for loss of life and property?

If we look at a few examples we find that our memory and interest is short. The Soviet Union illegally occupied Afghanistan for over a decade, and destroyed its infrastructure. No one asked Russia to pay a penny in compensation. There are 10,000 Palestinians held in Israeli prisons without trial, do we know them? Israel habitually attacks Gaza, the West Bank and Lebanon, and Muslim money rebuilds? Yet Muslim nations host Israeli embassies, tourists and engage in trade. Is such behavior consistent with a respect for the sanctity of Muslim life?

In Chechnya, a quarter of the Muslim population has been killed and almost all infrastructure destroyed, has this been raised by any Muslim States? Who is recording the atrocities committed? In Bosnia, around 6000 Muslim men and boys were shot in cold blood in one day, as the UN looked on. Do we care to remember this massacre each year? In 1998, the United States bombed the only civilian drug factory in Sudan. This led to thousands of innocent people being killed and dying because of lack of drugs. Where is the memory of this event and the compensation?

Muslim states have for decades been torturing, imprisoning and killing their own people. They have even been running ghost prisons to torture for the West and handing people over to them. In Pakistan the state kills on behalf of the United Sates and razed to the ground entire towns in Waziristan. No self-respecting state kills its own people for others.

And after the recent occupations of Iraq and Afghanistan, what do Muslim states do? They trade and offer contracts to the West as if nothing had happened. They reward the killers with 60 billion pounds arms deals, giving them the financial strength to go on and do more killing. They host and treat with respect a war criminal like Tony Blair as if he was a friend of Muslims. They even pay him incredible amounts of money for his speeches and accept him as a Middle East peace envoy! Is it surprising then that he wants more wars in the Muslim world and claims Muslims have a false sense of grievance!

These behaviors and attitudes are inconsistent with respect for the sanctity of Muslim life and property. So why are we surprised when the West treats Muslim blood with total disregard? Because of our attitude and failure to expose and remember all this suffering, we have allowed Muslims and Islam to be presented as the aggressor and not the victims, in all these conflicts.

Any revolutionary change in the Muslim world must have at its core and any new constitution, the sanctity and respect for Muslim life, property and dignity that Islam proscribes. These revolutionary movements must also ensure that those in the West should not be rewarded for their support of oppression and dictators with lucrative contracts; to do so would show a total disregard for all those who have suffered and lost their lives and families as a consequence of Western foreign policy.

It is high time Muslims started to remember the suffering that has been inflicted on Muslims around the globe. There are far too many 911's for us to remember, so let us have an International Muslim Day of Remembrance. I can think of no better day to have it than on 911.

Jahangir Mohammed is the Director Centre for Muslim Affairs and can be reached at cenmuagmail.com

Source: New Civilization

  Category: World Affairs
  Topics: United States Of America
Views: 4045

Related Suggestions

The opinions expressed herein, through this post or comments, contain positions and viewpoints that are not necessarily those of IslamiCity. These are offered as a means for IslamiCity to stimulate dialogue and discussion in our continuing mission of being an educational organization. The IslamiCity site may occasionally contain copyrighted material the use of which may not always have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. IslamiCity is making such material available in its effort to advance understanding of humanitarian, education, democracy, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law.

In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, and such (and all) material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.

Older Comments:
a superb article.. but who will take it forward?

Reading this article has filled my eyes with tears. Its a clarion call to all muslims to really be uninted and heed to the call of the rasul when he said we should want forour brothers what we want for ourselves.May Allah have mercy on the souls of our innocent brothers and sisters who have lost their lives and bring the prepetrators to justice.


‎​R.I.P to the 2,976 American people that lost their lives on 9/11...

BUT also R.I.P to the 48,644 Afghans and the 1,690,903 Iraqi people that paid the ultimate price for a crime they did not commit.

Indeed there is no epitome of ethics,values and morality in western political DNA.This is largely due to the facts that the west has no regards or respect for human life and human right since the life of thousands of muslims who were mosly civilians were wasted and killed without any remorse or regret,yet no western political leader or leaders care to remember and recognise the life of those innocent souls that were lost under the guise of the so -called war against terrorism

Alhamdulilah! someone finally spoke out. Am tired of reading some crazy stuff by so called moderate Muslims. This article gives me relief


We as Muslims must always strive to embody the ideals of justice and
fairness, especially when it comes to dealing with non-Muslims. We
cannot cause religious strife or be intolerant towards non-Muslims
simply because they follow a different religion.

The fact is, we Muslims have a long way to go to embody the traits of
justice, tolerance, fairness and protection in our character.

We have been tired of reading apologetic articles on the web, written by educated muslims. Thanks for the exception. It's true our brothers and sisters in the west are passing a more or less hard time; but why should we overlook the obvious?

Oh delicious irony!

"We would then have the entire territories of Afghanistan, Iraq, Lebanon, Kashmir, Chechnya and Palestine as sacred lands and Western exclusion zones!"

Religious minorities are badly persecuted in Afghanistan. The heroes of Islam, the Taliban, even used centuries old Buddhist statues as target practice!

Christians in Iraq are fleeing if they have the means. If they don't have the means they keep their heads down and hope to not be killed by their fellow Iraqis.

Kashmiris recently staged large protests against Hindus visiting an ancient Hindu holy place. Some pilgrims were killed.

Palestine too is becoming increasingly intolerant of its Christian minority. Lebanon is, at least, safe for non-Muslim religions in parts not dominated by the Army of God. Chechnya I don't know about - it may be fine for non-Muslims.

It appears to me that Muslims are great at demanding rights for themselves that they refuse to give others when they are in power. For what its worth, I fully support the Park 51 mosque.