Is Healing A Divided America Achievable?

In 1967, the Kerner Commission, created by President Lyndon Johnson to investigate the riots that had engulfed America's cities. It concluded that "Our nation is moving toward two societies, one black, one white – separate and unequal."

As last year's mass demonstrations against police violence and racial inequities, in addition to the mobilization of the Trump-led white grievance movement, made clear, we may be worse off today. There are signs that the American polity has become like two warring tribes who speak different languages and see reality through different eyes. The question is, "How did we get to this point?"

I've written before about the blight of systemic racism and the damage it continues to inflict on Black lives in America. Less examined has been the other side of our nation's divide. None of this can excuse the white nationalist, armed elements, which led to the violent insurrection. Instead, it is to understand the mass base of discontent from which they drew their support.

As I watched the emergence of the Tea Party in 2009, the Trump rallies from 2015 on. The insurrection at the Capitol Building in 2021 was evident that many who participated were white working and middle-class Americans angry at being left behind and who felt betrayed and abandoned by the government. They had also come to believe that only Donald Trump understood their grievances and was going to fight for them. It was true that Trump used racism and fear of immigrants as bait, but the message that resonated was his promise to bring jobs and hope. How was it that this narcissistic, hedonistic, billionaire reality TV star appeared as their savior?

I believe two factors account for this: the decline in belief in the American dream and the loss of confidence in government institutions and leaders.

Back in 1995, I was at an afternoon coffee conversation with then-President Bill Clinton. He had invited a small group to discuss problems facing the country. I used the opportunity to speak with him about what had happened in my hometown. My neighborhood had been made up of mostly immigrant families and their descendants, living in two-family homes. The men worked in unionized factory jobs. Their one salary allowed them to provide for their children and their elderly parents. They were secure. Then the mills closed and moved down south, where labor was non-unionized and cheaper.

Thousands lost work. Many were forced to move. Extended families were severed, and even many nuclear families fractured under the pressure of unemployment. Within a few decades, my hometown lost nearly one-half of its population. Neighborhoods fell into ruin, and social problems grew.

I asked the president, who had just celebrated NAFTA's implementation, which many labor leaders opposed because they feared it would result in more significant job loss, what he would do about hometowns like mine? His response startled me. He said something like, "We're never going back there again. Those jobs are gone. That's why we need to invest in retraining, portable health care, and opportunities for people to relocate to where there is work."

While I was impressed with how immediately he responded, I was shocked at how flippant and unfeeling it was. He wasn't speaking about my neighbors – what they had invested in their homes, the hopes they had for their children, and their dreams that had come to naught.

Much the same happened during the economic collapse of 2008-9. In just a few months, unemployment doubled, pensions lost 30-40% of their value, and one in five homeowners were in danger of losing their homes. The White House and Congress responded by bailing out the banks and Wall Street, but average Americans were left waiting for money to trickle down to them eventually. Some saw benefits, but not enough to restore most Americans' confidence that the government cared about them. In just six months, polling showed a dramatic decline in belief in the American Dream.

In addition to this sense of economic dislocation and abandonment, there was a loss of confidence in government institutions. During the Bush presidency, Americans came to feel that the government couldn't keep them safe (9/11), couldn't be counted on to tell them the truth (the Iraq War), or even respond to national emergencies (the disastrous response to Hurricane Katrina).

And then, there were the governance dysfunctions created by the growing polarization of our politics. Democrats and Republicans each courted their supporters. Every issue came to see through the lens of this hyper-partisan struggle. Democrats came to be seen as caring more for "minorities" and women's issues for the white working-class, leaving the field open for Republicans to prey on the feeling of abandonment of white voters. Despite the Republican agenda consistently favoring the wealthy (with lower taxes), corporations (with deregulation), and religious conservatives (with anti-abortion and anti-LGBT legislation), they nevertheless made significant inroads with working-class voters.

Then came Donald Trump, who, while never veering from this Republican agenda, cast himself as the white working class's champion. Although everything about his history was antithetical to their needs, he spoke to their grievances. He promised that he would: bring back their jobs and defend them against the elites who had turned their backs on them. He would make them great again.

Despite having done none of the above, once casting their lot with him, they feared admitting they were wrong. His enemies became theirs. Those who were "stealing this election" were stealing their chance to succeed. This was why 75 million voted for him. And this was why they were so intensely concerned with his loss.

Having witnessed the Republican's shameful behavior in the wake of the insurrection, I have no hope they will change direction. Some leaders in that party are still blaming "leftists" for creating the violence. One senator who initially condemned Trump made a pilgrimage to Florida. He returned, celebrating that "We are the party of the working class, the party of Trump" and cautioning that Republicans can't win without him.

It is, therefore, up to Democrats to broaden their outreach and to craft a message and policies that speaks to all voters, black, brown, and white, and is sensitive to their economic, political, and social concerns. This is something Joe Biden is equipped to do. It won't be easy, but we must address both the reality of racial inequities and the loss of hope of white working-class voters. Unless we do both and bridge the deep polarization of American society, our divisions will continue to take their toll.

Related Suggestions

The opinions expressed herein, through this post or comments, contain positions and viewpoints that are not necessarily those of IslamiCity. These are offered as a means for IslamiCity to stimulate dialogue and discussion in our continuing mission of being an educational organization. The IslamiCity site may occasionally contain copyrighted material the use of which may not always have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. IslamiCity is making such material available in its effort to advance understanding of humanitarian, education, democracy, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law.

In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, and such (and all) material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.