Arrogance and Ignorance at War

Category: Middle East, World Affairs Topics: Occupation, Palestine Channel: Opinion Views: 4495

Israel has been telling us that "all she wants is peace and security," and that "she works for peace." Blaming the Palestinians for lack of progress toward peace.

 For a long time, especially during the times of Arafat, they said "they don't have a partner for peace." Then came along Mahmoud Abbas. Abbas was the man Israel had been looking for: a soft and compromising leader, almost a political "pushover."

Israel had the now-infamous settlement activity frozen for the past 10 months. Then, with President Obama's efforts, the recent peace talks have been restarted a few weeks ago. Israel had seemingly finally found her peace partner in Abbas.

But the settlement freeze came to an end on Sept. 26, 2010, AND in spite of all the above "wait" and "efforts," Israel did not extend the moratorium on settlement activity. Yes, that is right, they are not extending the settlement freeze, while the much-anticipated peace talks have just started!

(Mind you, a couple of months ago, they had the audacity to announce settlement activity in East Jerusalem--again, an internationally recognized Palestinian land--even while the US Vice President Joe Biden was visiting Israel supposedly to jump start the very peace talks we are talking about!)

I have been following the whole Israeli-Palestinian issue more than ten years, very closely. This issue is most critical for the stability of the whole world. If not dealt with soon, and that in a just way, sooner or later it will trigger a larger regional war encompassing the greater Middle East, drawing in the great world powers along with it. This thought will send shivers down anyone's spine.

I have pasted below a map I got from the BBC website showing the cumulative Israeli settlement activity in the West Bank, the land on which most of the future Palestinian State will supposedly be built. Please have a look at it, and while listening to your hearts, tell me whether you see a peace-wanting Israel in it.



Caption by BBC:


  • 62% under full Israeli control. This area contains all Israeli settlements, roads used by settlers, buffer zones and almost all of the Jordan Valley

  • 38% under Palestinian civil control. In more than half of this, Israel has security control 

  • There are 149 settlements and 100 outposts (settlements not authorized by Israel) 

  •  Population: 2.4 million Palestinians, 500,000 Jewish or Israeli settlers

Anyone with an iota of brain will know that Israel must have different plans undercurrent here. They are clearly on a path to totally colonize the West Bank, and drive out the Palestinians by making their lives miserable with scores of checkpoints and land restrictions (again, see the map below). The Israeli settlers --from overseas, whose native tongues are not even Hebrew- have long been terrorizing the Palestinian farmers.

I cannot rationalize their behavior to be other than a direct result of a potentially fatal arrogance to have the nerve to tell the rest of the mostly unsuspecting world that they want peace even while they are gobbling up more and more West Bank land.

Muslims at this stage are useless to be able to do anything. They perhaps had a better chance pre-9/11 days. But thanks to Al-Qaeda and other terrorists who hijacked Islam, and who positioned themselves to be at the center of this whole "interaction" between the West and the Muslims, Muslims have an insurmountable public relations mountain to scale before they can even come close to be of any help in this issue.

Leery of their own corrupt governments, some Muslims bought into the illusion that Al-Qaeda might provide the answers to many of their problems with the West. Ten years on, what do we have?

After 9/11, the Palestinian situation got unconscionably worse... Some Muslim countries got occupied by Western armies, resulting in the deaths of thousands of innocent Muslims... Muslims started killing each other even in their sacred mosques... Muslims in the West began to be profiled, and in certain cases discriminated against, and on and on and on...

What other results would a sane person expect from people who believe that they can reinstate the glory of the Islamic civilization by indiscriminately killing civilians using an un-Islamic combat method, i.e. terrorism, and still expect to win the hearts and minds of people toward their cause?

What other results would a sane person expect from people who believe that they can restore the glory of the Islamic civilization by measuring the length of beards of young men, instead of "measuring" the human genome; or by blowing up the girls schools, instead of blowing up protons as they do in CERN.

Bin Laden and his protege are under the fatal illusion that they are the glorious "mujahedeen," who will restore the glory days of Saladin, while posing to photographers with soviet-made AK-47's, not laser-guided precision missiles made in "Talibanistan." They are under the fatal illusion that they are the ones worthy of the legacy of the Holy Prophet Muhammad, while their mentality does not so much have the vision to make even one single nail.

Then we have the Hamas mentality which presupposes that success can only come through violence, incognizant of the fact that there might be many different legitimate and feasible means of achieving or at least getting close to one's goals, especially if one is dealing with a shrewd and super-powerful adversary.

All of this made the Muslim position unimaginably weak, and the other parties pressed on with their intended goals unabated. They know best how easy it is to make inroads while the extremists are at the helm of the Muslim side.

Muslims must wake up before the situation becomes worse for them...They can start  first by disillusioning themselves from the extremist hogwash that democracy is un-Islamic. Little wonder why corrupt and ruthless dictators have been ruling us for decades until their death after which their sons takeover the power in a seemingly unending cycle.

They can start waking up by reclaiming the quintessentially Qur'anic characteristic of ratiocination, not regurgitation of 1000 year-old (perhaps then fresh but now stale) fatwas and thoughts. To me today's Muslims don't seem to be the Qur'anic people of "those who think/reason." It is long overdue that we shuck off our crippling ignorance.

But all that does not mean that the other side of this whole issue, that is Israel and the West, does not have any lesson to take from here. I wrote my version of that lesson in a piece titled "Turkey is Crucial to a Stable Middle East," which ran on Jim Lobe's blog. A slightly modified version of it is this:

Israel does have every right to exist peacefully in the region. This means that Israel will want to live in this overwhelmingly Muslim neighborhood of the Middle East forever. Who in their right mind can believe Israel will achieve that by always maintaining a superb military edge? Arrogance is folly. Don't trust your seemingly invincible strength! Tides pertaining to militaristic power do always turn! What will happen then? The Jesus' saying "those who live by the sword will die by the sword" will necessarily come true. Do the Jews want that? I doubt it.

Is there any other way? Yes! No matter how powerful a country Israel is today, no matter how successful, rich, and most importantly, how they produce (in my mind) some of the wisest people on Earth, they should humbly start to work with Muslims to start a new era of peaceful coexistence. That can be achieved by first being sincere in wanting to have peace. An incontrovertible sign of that sincerity in our context is to stop the settlement activity unconditionally, and evacuate the all the illegal settlers from Palestinian territories, and simultaneously seize the opportunity with President Abbas to establish a viable Palestinian state next to Israel.


Dr. Serkan Zorba is assistant professor of physics at Whittier College, CA, USA. He is originally from Turkey.

  Category: Middle East, World Affairs
  Topics: Occupation, Palestine  Channel: Opinion
Views: 4495

Related Suggestions

Related posts from similar channels:

The opinions expressed herein, through this post or comments, contain positions and viewpoints that are not necessarily those of IslamiCity. These are offered as a means for IslamiCity to stimulate dialogue and discussion in our continuing mission of being an educational organization. The IslamiCity site may occasionally contain copyrighted material the use of which may not always have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. IslamiCity is making such material available in its effort to advance understanding of humanitarian, education, democracy, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law.

In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, and such (and all) material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.

Older Comments:
Alhamdolilaha very nice article, we need think tank of such people in our Muslim community to turn the table down & show the world what is really peace.
The palestine issue can only be solved by having our own media to communicate with the real world .Currently only people see one face of the coin, other face is completely ignored & even if it shown then as a terrorist (black ship do exist in all community).

This is that rarity by Muslims in the western (or at least English) media: an honest, self-critical look at Muslim responsibility for their own problems. I applaud it. This recognition makes me far more receptive to the largely justified criticisms of Israel and the US.

There are two additional points I'd like to see recognized.

1) Israel is, in many ways, even less unified than the Palestinians. The difference is that they have a healthy system to resolve their differences. The settlers are simply one interest group among the Israelis, and not a terribly popular group at that. By focusing on the misdeeds of the settlers and ignoring the significant Israeli peace movement (at least, significant before the second Intifada), Muslims self-gratify themselves with a comfortably demonized enemy, but essentially castrate their Israeli partners for peace. In many ways this is the flip side of Israeli and US focus on, and empowerment of, Hamas.

2) Many of the Jewish citizens of Israel are refugees from what is now the Muslims world. Jews have historically been at risk in Muslim lands ever since a tribe of Jews betrayed Mohammed (by the Muslim account - that the winner writes the history is true in the Muslim world more than anywhere else). Their conditions have varied from tolerated 2nd class citizen to threatened minority. Unfortunately it is far more the latter in the few places they still live in the Muslim world. Until Muslims learn to treat their non-Muslim citizens in a fully equal way, any refugee from their lands will generate enormous sympathy from the outside world (on the eastern side as well as the western side).

This is the article that has nailed all the things that I have been thinking about it and I wish that iviews would print more articles from this writer as he knows what he is talking about...Thank you Dr.Zorba