Smoke is getting thicker in Afghanistan

SIX days after the attack on the World Trade Center, President George W. Bush declared that the capture of Osama Bin Laden was his prime objective. "I want justice", he said, "There's an old poster out west that I recall that said wanted dead or alive". He also said that the purpose of going to war was to "smoke him out".

The US and the UK then unleashed their bombs all over Afghanistan, killing far more innocent Afghans than were killed on 9/11. It did no good at all, and it certainly didn't touch Bin Laden and his team who were safely hidden in caves in the impenetrable mountains of Pakistan. Not long after Bush turned his attention to Saddam Hussein's Iraq. Less and less was spoken of the need to hunt down Bin Laden. None of this made sense. Afghanistan is now in a mess. The US and its allies are in as deep as were the previous Soviet invaders and the Taleban are as apt at keeping them on the defensive and wearing them down by a war of attrition as were the Mujahedeen 25 years ago.

Today the Western powers say their aim is to change the nature of Afghanistan society - ending militancy, liberating women, educating girls, building clinics and roads. But are we there to refashion a conservative society? That is not our business. 

And today the need to track down Bin Laden is given little consideration. Instead the firepower is aimed loosely at the Taleban, but often-innocent villagers, and in Pakistan the focus is on the leadership of the Taleban and other violent fundamentalist groups. No wonder many of us are confused.

What should have been done? There never should have been any bombing neither immediately after 9/11 nor today. The US should have chosen to run Bin Laden to earth as the wartime Allies and Israel hunted down the big Nazis who were on the run.

It was hard, dogged police work over decades. In numerous cases, including Adolf Eichmann, the concentration camps' supremo, it worked. What was needed after 9/11 was the recruitment of the most motivated Pashto speakers from the Pakistani Army, intelligence service and police force and then their training for the task ahead by the FBI and Scotland Yard. That should have been backed up by CIA and MI6 field officers working with all the tools of modern detective work (which the Israelis didn't have for their pursuit of Eichmann - forensic science, infrared capabilities and so on).

Washington and London would argue that for five years before the World Trade Center bombing they had been trying to hunt down Bin Laden and even three years before had sent operatives to Afghanistan in an attempt to encourage the leaders of the anti-Taleban opposition to capture him.

Later in 1999 the CIA trained 60 commandos from Pakistani intelligence to enter Afghanistan and capture or kill him. But when Gen. Pervez Musharraf staged his coup d'etat in Pakistan he forbade the continuance of this useful operation.

Police work and commando deployment of this kind is hard and frustrating. Yet there were also opportunities missed. In the early spring of 1996 the government of Sudan, where Bin Laden was living, made an offer to the CIA to arrest him. But the Clinton administration faltered. It passed up the possibility of bringing him to the US, believing it couldn't get a conviction in a US court and instead tried to persuade Saudi Arabia to take him in and try him. But there was an alternative, as President George W. Bush showed later - his internment on a US naval brig. Moreover, he could easily have been classed as a prisoner of war, subject to the Geneva Conventions but not to trial.

Samuel Berger, Clinton's national security adviser, revealingly told the Washington Post in 2001, "In the US we have this thing called the US Constitution, so to bring him to justice I don't think was our first choice. Our first choice was to send him some place where justice was more streamlined". 

This is how it came to be that Sudan expelled Bin Laden to Afghanistan, where he planned the bombings of the US embassies in Kenya and Tanzania, the near destruction of the American destroyer in Yemen and, finally, the devastation in New York and Washington.

Berger's account rings with contradictions. If he was convinced at the time that Bin Laden was such a danger to the US then it seems clear that the White House possessed incriminating evidence. Why did it not act upon it? Hundreds of thousands of lives could have been saved.

It is not too late to change the tactics in Afghanistan and Pakistan. We should recall the hunt for Adolf Eichmann, a more dangerous man than Bin Laden with a far worse record.

Jonathan Power is one of the world's leading columnists on international affairs, human rights and peace.

Related Suggestions

The opinions expressed herein, through this post or comments, contain positions and viewpoints that are not necessarily those of IslamiCity. These are offered as a means for IslamiCity to stimulate dialogue and discussion in our continuing mission of being an educational organization. The IslamiCity site may occasionally contain copyrighted material the use of which may not always have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. IslamiCity is making such material available in its effort to advance understanding of humanitarian, education, democracy, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law.

In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, and such (and all) material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.

Older Comments:
I simply and respectfully ask of those fighting the Holy War this question: What God, would allow one soul, let alone 76 virgin souls, to be used for one mans gradification? The youth are protected by innocence, as soft as clay. You will not whip a camel but allow children through innocence to die for what you believe in. We in this country that is hated, at least, allow those same children to grow to an age that allows them, an informed choice. If they die from this country, they at least travel with the information. We get no promises here. What say you?

I agree with saba and nadir .i want to tell these people who are the master mind of 9/11 the loss is there own.the truth will hit fact i feel pity for these people i call them to come to the common path of obeying one ALLAH,and repent .

I agree with some parts of the article. Bin Laden has nothing to do with 9/11. It was an inside job and it was done for the purpose of greed and to gain control of oil rich parts of the World. To spread the American domination across the Globe and to change the World order. In the process they demolished the twin towers and have killed so many innocent people. Then to further their interests they have killed scores of innocent people in Afghanistan and Iraq. When are we going to open our eyes and wonder what's going on in this World?

Yes, this is garbage. Bin Laden had nothing to do with Sept. 11. Doesn't it strike you odd that the Bin Ladens were chillin with the Bushes on 9/11, or how bout the molten pools of thermite used in US explosives in the mangled ruins of the towers. OPEN YOUR EYES!!!!

first of all 911 was conducted by the Israeli agancies shabak and mossad . bin laden was used because he refused the CIA to carry out drug trade as Islam forbids drugs of addiction but israeli jews and cia wanted to continue with their dirty activities so they had to go to afghanistan in blame game. and of course they were also intersted in the caspian sea oil reserves which bin laden had refused to contract with them remember the company UNOCOL .with all these things in mind Israel wanted to exapand its ambitions anyway for greater Israel and they used afghanistan also as an excuse to serve two pruposes .drug trade should thrive and the war in iraq with illegal occupation for the terrorist zionist jewsand their supporters to go after strong henchman saddma hussen see map of greater israel. Israel will never fulfill its plan and nato soldiers unfortunately will be defeated worse than the soviets in afghanistan just watch. 911 is an israeli false flag operation.and they are planning on more