Slamming the Door on Muslims

Category: Americas, World Affairs Topics: Barack Obama Views: 2747

If there is one thing that Muslims in America can credit this election for, it is throwing the ugly specter of Islamophobia into sharp relief. Being a Muslim running for office is now widely acknowledged to be a 'smear', and any association with the world's second largest religion is accepted as a case of political suicide. The worst part is that it is not only the uninformed American public but the politicians and stakeholders involved in this historic election that have themselves contributed to the hate rollercoaster by adding fuel to fire with their statements, or lack of thereof.

The controversy has oscillated from circulation of photos of Senator Barack Obama (D-Ill.) in Kenyan garb and a turban, to blatant lies by Fox News that he attended a Muslim extremist school, to fears that the first thing that Obama would do if elected is whip out his prayer rug in the Oval Office and say 'AHA, fooled you all!' (that one is mine). Regardless, it is shameful for a pluralistic and self-professed tolerant society like the United States to even entertain these fears. It is even more hurtful to call these claims 'fears'.

According to estimates by the Council of American-Islamic Relations, there are about 6 to 7 million Muslims in this country, many of whom have been living here for generations. This is an incredibly diverse community, harboring many different views and having many different faces (Arab, South Asian, African-American, etc.). Saying that there is something wrong with being a Muslim is highly offensive to the beliefs of this community-it offends our identity and suggests that no matter how long we have been here, no matter how many times we take the Pledge of Allegiance, we will never truly belong. Most of the Muslims in the United States and across the globe view the 'War on Terrorism' as a mindless crusade against their religion, and this is the wrong message to be sending.

Unfortunately, this atmosphere of hate-mongering against Islam is already having effects. Just over a month ago, thousands of copies of the anti-Muslim documentary 'Obsession' were distributed in swing states, by being inserted in major newspapers, sent through the U.S. Postal Service. The film was backed by the New York-based Clarion Fund that has publicly backed Senator John McCain's (R-Ariz.) candidacy. The week ended in an attack on Muslim children with a 'chemical irritant' at the Islamic Society of Greater Dayton in Ohio on Friday, Sept. 26th. The lack of reporting on this incident needs to be fully condemned.

It is regretful that politicians and the candidates themselves have not taken a proactive role in addressing such radioactive insinuations. John McCain needs to address why one cannot be an 'Arab' and a 'family man' at the same time. Barack Obama has to realize the implications of his refusal to visit a mosque, after having already visited churches and synagogues. Both candidates have to start thinking about the segment of society that they are marginalizing with their lack of enthusiasm on this important issue. 

Former Secretary of State Colin Powell's interview on Meet the Press in which he talked about the Muslim-American Kareem Rashad Sultan Khan who died in Iraq fighting for America at the age of 20 is testament to the sacrifices Muslims have made, and are still making for this country. What few people know is that Khan's tombstone is not the only one with a crescent in the Arlington National Cemetery. Colin Powell has taken a step in the right direction with his statement-but now other people need to follow.

Attempts to push these issues under the rug are no longer going to work. Come November, the next president needs to actively start working to improve relations between the Muslim world and America. He needs to take the initiative to protect a community that is already well-integrated and part of this society. No longer can America afford to associate with the actions of a bunch of misguided individuals who have squandered the name of this beautiful, peaceful religion for their own purposes. Neither can we-we are already suffering the consequences of it.

The author is a sophomore in the School of Engineering and Applied Sciences. He is the Media Coordinator of the Muslim Students' Association.

Owais Rasool is a contributing writer with 

  Category: Americas, World Affairs
  Topics: Barack Obama
Views: 2747

Related Suggestions

The opinions expressed herein, through this post or comments, contain positions and viewpoints that are not necessarily those of IslamiCity. These are offered as a means for IslamiCity to stimulate dialogue and discussion in our continuing mission of being an educational organization. The IslamiCity site may occasionally contain copyrighted material the use of which may not always have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. IslamiCity is making such material available in its effort to advance understanding of humanitarian, education, democracy, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law.

In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, and such (and all) material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.

Older Comments:
Living in the USA, I was so happy to hear a person as prestigious as Colin Powell lecture on religious tolerance in this country and point out to short-minded people it did not matter if Senator Obama was Muslim or not. However, whatever unfortunate Muslim intolerance we have here in the USA I can turn right around and bring up similar religious intolerance issues in the Muslim world. Take for example the city of Mecca. According to the Wikipedia (and I am assuming it is somewhat accurate), non-Muslims are not permitted to enter Mecca by Saudi law. In my opinion as one who likes to travel around the world just understand different cultures, there is no better way to understand the Islam faith than to go to where the religion was born. But I cannot, which in my belief is religious discrimination, goes against the spirit of the teachings of the Qur'an, and hinders religious understanding of the Muslim faith by non-Muslims. I cannot speak Arabic but from an interpretation of the Qur'an that I have read, Sura 42:15 means "Please do not pay the least attention to any sectarian view, but courageously and openly proclaim to all: 'I affirm the truth of every Revelation which has come down as a Holy Book for the Source of Truth, and I am instructed by this very Source to be impartial among the peoples of Revelation. The Ever Present Source, Who calls itself by countless Divine Names, is the Source of our spiritual nation and your spiritual nations. We have our integral practice of the holy way of life, as you have yours. There need be no fundamental disagreement among us. Allah Most High will draw us all together as we return home to the Source of Love'".

You are entitled to your opinion as I am entitled to mine, and I agree with you mostly on your points. However, this religious issue is not one-sided. I don't think the Muslim world can afford to associate itself with unfortunate views by a few individuals for their own purposes. We all need to be open-minded.

It is unfortunate to see people are still so skeptical and ignorant generally about Islam and Muslims.The impression some non Muslims and even other Muslims are giving is as if being a Muslim itself is a crime which is so unfortunate.
We must differentiate between the Islam which the Prophet brought that made the Companions succesful in both life and our Islam of today.We believe some of us are not good example as some want us to be, nonetheless if we cling to the teachings of the Prophet we will be successful in this life and the Hereafter which is our ambition. May Allah make all of us examples to save mankind from misery and catastrophy.

We Muslims deserve this treatment. Our egos, our stupid ideas of copying other communities are blindly chasing us back. Democratic and Republican party is completely controlled by one specific community. What is the point of winning either of them like dogs? If we Muslims support Ralph Nader, the first thing will happen is his party will get a status of federal contribution. Muslims are no less than 3 million of voters. If they join hands with poor white Americans, blacks, spanish and support Green Party, then they can have a separate block of let us say 30 senate seats. Now, we can leverage those seats into our favour. I hate to vote Muslim candidate by the way. Muslims should not run for offices. It is wrong to begin with. How can you share podium with conservatives who loot the poor, and how can we share the podium with liberals who promote filthy social agenda? We need to become kingmakers. If we peg the Muslim vote and bargain our agenda without directly participating in elections, we will be the ultimate winners. We need to function on three pillars as minorities. 1) Character Building and higher education, 2) Contribution and Dawa 3) Indirect political participation. Very simple. Prophetic traditions are clearly guiding us that "pick your fight at your time, at your style, at your time".


This is politics, baby. Both parties can afford to marginalize muslims; what they cannot afford to offend is christians and jews who are far more in number and far far richer who pay campaign bills. Moreover, Obama is going to be around for 8 years maximum; and in that time, muslims are not going to become politically important to be of any threat to him; so he can afford to ignore them.

Muslims are their own worst enemies. They have refused to understand the US; one tries to keep mosque and plitics separate in this country, not mix it. By mixing poltics and mosques, muslims become a liability, not an asset; and nobody wants liabilities.

Politics is the art of winning; and catering to muslims is sure to lead to losing.