Weathering the Globalization Storm

Category: World Affairs Views: 4882

I spent much of the last three years working and traveling across the Middle East and Asia in one of the most unique and fulfilling experiences of my life.

Not only did my journey require me to question and adjust a range of values and perceptions which for long I've held as absolutes, but in fact it cemented my sense of "out-of-placeness," which has become a integral part of me, being a descendant of Palestinian refugees expelled from their homes in Palestine nearly six decades ago. And yet, through living and visiting many countries on four continents, I came to accept that "not belonging" is no longer a limitation, but a unique position that has helped me forcefully transcend beyond stereotypes and superficialities.

However, one of many realizations that I have also aggregated is the incredible and deliberate conformity that most Third World countries are pressed to embrace, one that is unquestionably forcing the uniqueness of these cultures to disintegrate in favor of imposed and manufactured cultural alternatives.

The traditional village structure of the Arabia Gulf cultures for example, has nearly disappeared in its entirety, to be replaced by skyscrapers and housing compounds that neither represent nor relate to the cultural identities of the inhabitants. Of course it is not modernity that is on trial here, but the rash attempt to embrace Western symbols of civilization while disposing of one's own.

In the tiny Arab state of Qatar, for example, abandoned traditional villages following subsequent oil booms starting in the 1960's are left bare. 
Standing close to one, you could swear you could hear the wailing of a baby or the laughter of children. Scattered like ghost towns in the middle of the vast desert, there seems to be no governmental plans to renovate or preserve them in any way, despite of the billions of dollars spent on giant Western-style structures and artificial islands that seem to serve no specific purpose.

But more or less, the age of globalization is uncompromisingly incessant on discarding local cultures altogether for failing to present any sort of viable economic potential. Thus, falafel restaurants in most Middle Eastern cities are nearly obsolete, while American fast food joints spring up at enormous speed throughout the region.

This cultural encroachment -- and subsequently the abandonment of one's own culture -- is turning the once dominant and self-asserting cultures of the Third World into inconsequential and highly symbolic discourses, at best, indigenous cultures fighting for survival.

According to the classic definition, to speak of a people being indigenous is to concede to several understandings; First is the probable assumption that a geopolitical territory of a fixed group of people who had occupied that space for a reasonably extended period of time has been expropriated or dominated by another, by way of direct foreign interference or into a new political setting such as a nation state. Second, is to also acknowledge that that group of people has distinct social, cultural, religious and even economic attributes, of which some are to be maintained in order for the designation of being indigenous to be preserved.

It comes as no surprise then, that the classic imperialism of the past and the more concealed cultural imperialism of the present were and are adamant in ensuring the slow yet irreversible dismantling of what makes a targeted indigenous culture distinctive and unique, its social and spiritual attributes, its economic pillars, its religious adherences; thus, its way of life.

It goes without saying that indigenous cultures are under incessant attack, both literally and figuratively. Some have survived, some disintegrated and others still endure a fateful and decided struggle for recognition, for rights and for a space in an increasingly polarized world.

From Arabia to Borneo, I am left with little doubt that the seemingly dominant cultures of these regions have long ago conceded their dominance -- though not yet their relevance -- and have relegated to the position of indigenousness. However, even that secondary role is under unrelenting attack from the pressing speed of economic globalization, so polarized and domineering.

In this growing age of globalization, we must understand that clinging to age-old tradition and heritage is not analogous to backwardness. It remains to be seen whether globalization has left much room for indigenous cultures to negotiate a space for themselves in a world of encroaching global polities and often uncompromising nation-state boundaries.

Ramzy Baroud is the author of "The Second Palestinian Intifada: A Chronicle of a People's Struggle." (Forthcoming. Pluto Press, London) He is also the editor-in-chief of He can be reached at [email protected]

He is also the editor of the anthology: "Searching Jenin: Eyewitness Accounts of the Israeli Invasion."

To buy "Searching Jenin: Eyewitness Accounts of the Israeli Invasion" CLICK HERE

  Category: World Affairs
Views: 4882
The opinions expressed herein, through this post or comments, contain positions and viewpoints that are not necessarily those of IslamiCity. These are offered as a means for IslamiCity to stimulate dialogue and discussion in our continuing mission of being an educational organization. The IslamiCity site may occasionally contain copyrighted material the use of which may not always have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. IslamiCity is making such material available in its effort to advance understanding of humanitarian, education, democracy, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law.

In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, and such (and all) material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.

Older Comments:
Author ..did not even understand about cultures or globalisation process even after travelling the most historic part of the world which is Asia/Middle East.

I think this article is so sloppy it should have been rejected by Iview editor as it offers no light whatsoever.

Author think constructing high rise buildings and skycrappers is globalisation and modernisation. Wrong.

I strongly urge the author to study Quran first and then study the complete biography of our beloved Prophet Mohammed SAW/PBUH.

Building skyscrappers is not modernisation or globalisation. The phophet all SAW/PBUH already peophesied that a shepards will build skycrappers so if villagers building buidings is not at all mean leaving culture and Islam is not by the way a culture. It is the most complete way of life guided by the creator of the mankind and the universe.

Make it short I will tell you that a day will come insaallah even the western people will even worship Allah in those skyscappers and will folllow the way of life as per the Prophet of Allah SAW/PBUH soon as western way of life has destroyed their own social moral values and all of will us still will be eating burgers, fries, shawarma, falafil etc.


Peace be upon those who worship allah n follow his prophet SAW/PBUH

It is a design of Israil. It will never be successful, because Allah Himself decided to divide the mankind so that try to understand each other. The final punishment for Jess from Allah is still to come, and in order to escape from that they are trying to create all sorts of proble. Will they be succesful againat Allah's wishes.

To be with Asnam Al-jarab or NOT-west Asnam
or both or NEITHER


THOMAS said:
The author makes it sound like Globilisation is a new phenomemon, which is not the case. The death of cultures however lamentable has been happening for many thousands of years. With migrations of peoples, wars, disease and assimilation, many cultures have unfortunately disappeared in the history of Mankind. Every Continent has had in its past conquests of cultures by other cultures. To blame it on globilisation only by the West or only by imperial powers is incorrect. With the expansion of Islam indigenous cultures have been impacted on severely also in the past and even in the present.