Israel Still Holds Keys to Peace

Category: Middle East, World Affairs Topics: Occupation Views: 1924

Despite Elections Charade, Israel Still Holds Keys to Peace

While blaming the victim is nothing new in US Middle East foreign policy and in Israel's uneven handed conflicts with its neighbors throughout the years, the reality continues to be as appalling as ever.

The atmosphere created by the Palestinian 'presidential' elections was nothing but a spurious charade. It was a dishonest representation of the real problem, and unfortunately many Palestinians played along. 

The charade however is nothing new. Throughout the years, any hope for peace between Palestinians and Israelis, often born out of some peace initiative cooked jointly by the U.S. government with an Israeli nod, is the upshot of a faulty premise: that Palestinians must show serious interest in peace before Israel is expected to reciprocate. Even the Road Map, which many Palestinian officials lauded, is no exception. 

The Road Map was the handy craft of pro-Israeli elements in the US administration, and they are plentiful. It failed to rebuke Israel, even if slightly, for its disproportionate and costly violence against the Palestinian people. As if every word were scrutinized time and again to ensure that Israel would be shielded from any criticism, even if inferred. 

The document however, may possibly yield one conclusion: only by reining in Palestinian terrorism can Israel and the Palestinian Authority achieve common ground for a lasting peace. The problem again, begins and ends with the Palestinians. Israel can only be urged to display patience, restraint and symbolic gestures of good will. 

The Israeli lobby made sure to exercise every smidgen of pressure it possesses to mold President George Bush's supposed brainchild to appease Israel. Predictably, the PA responded with a big unconditional "yes", so that Palestinians would not be viewed once again as the predicament to peace. Israel hesitated, deliberated, and finally agreed with conditions that disfigured the face of the already unsightly agreement. That positive Israeli response was at once celebrated as a victory for peace and symptomatic to Israel's very compromising nature, which has shown us before that no matter how "painful" its "concessions" might be, it's a worthy price for peace. 

Of course, the Road Map was neither the first nor the last of these Shakespearian dramas. The path to peace in the Middle East is swamped with these staged shows that are hardly linked to reality by any stretch of the imagination. The overstated value of the Palestinian elections fully conforms to these past experiences: only by altering their backward political culture and fully committing to the everlasting principals of democracy can Palestinians achieve peace with Israel; only by being at peace with themselves can Palestinians be at peace with Israel; only by shunning the anti-democratic elements from their ranks, can Palestinians be a worthy peace partner with the "only democracy in the Middle East." And once again, Israel is demanded to do nothing in return, save some mythical steps of reciprocity that never seem to materialize, and 'confidence building' measures devoid of any real political value.

It was almost as if Israel couldn't help itself, as it carried on with its abrasive and bloody policies even during the elections campaign. As if its insistence to humiliate Palestinians knows no limits, it repeatedly arrested Palestinian candidates, beating them on camera. One candidate was shown on TV being jerked by the necktie, and having his arm-twisted in so painful a way by some thug-looking Israeli-boy soldiers. Dr. Mustafa Barghouti was arrested on more than one occasion during the brief campaign; he was beaten and harassed repeatedly. If this had happened to a presidential candidate anywhere in the world it would be a story to remember for years to come. Coming from Israel is not even worthy of a little rebuke. It can hardly change the fact that the failure is fully Palestinian, that Israel has been an icon of patience and self-restraint.

But how unfair and cunning these designations are. While blaming the victim is nothing new in US Middle East foreign policy and in Israel's uneven handed conflicts with its neighbors throughout the years, the reality continues to be as appalling as ever. 

How could any self-respecting politician, commentator or any other deliberately skip the greatest obstacle to peace in the region, and that is the almost four-decades long Israeli occupation of East Jerusalem, the West Bank and Gaza, added to the never folded episode of dispossession and systematic murder that took place in 1948? 

Is it possible that such a vital factor such as Israel's violations of dozens of UN resolutions, the Fourth Geneva Convention and the International Court of Justice ruling be worthless compared to Palestinians' need to select a leader for a hollow political institution like the Palestinian Authority? 

Why are Palestinian sins, the suicide bombings and such, even if a bloody response to a much bloodier occupation augmented beyond comprehension, while Israel's killing of thousands of Palestinians obliges no reproach? 

Is it true however, that the Bush administration with its pro-Israeli cronies and the ever willing Tony Blair cannot fully see the foolishness of it all, trusting that peace between both parties is possible while Ariel Sharon has made it so indisputably clear that he is neither interested in dismantling his illegal settlements from the West Bank, nor returning captive East Jerusalem to its rightful owners? 

According to Sharon, a Palestinian state is only possible on 42 percent of the West Bank, less than ten percent of the total size of historic Palestine, without the refugees ever exercising their right of return, without actual control over the borders, without Jerusalem, without removing the over 200,000 illegal Jewish settlers from the West Bank. And even then, a state can only actualize after the Palestinians guarantee Israel's security. How could a defenseless nation guarantee the security of its occupier? Is this rational? 

But we must render all of that irrelevant at the moment and simply reflect on this golden opportunity where Palestinians have finally seen the light of democracy, even if under the chains of a tank, and a soldier's boot. This is, of course, the furthest possible scenario from genuine democracy, that is based on freedom and sovereignty, that is an accumulative process that doesn't begin at the ballot box nor does it end their. What is happening in Palestine is nothing but a construct, an illusion, which only indicates that Palestinians and their deficient political culture are in need of serious revamping, while Israel can only be expecting to exercise restraint. But restraint never meant settlement freezes, and end of land confiscation, house demolitions, tree toppling and a mini massacre now and then. There is nothing new about this charade. It's as old as the conflict itself, and as always expects to deliver, win Israel time and discredit the hapless Palestinians. It's the ingenious stratagem that managed to eradicate peace in the Middle East for generations, and is the lucky charm that shielded successive US governments from the wrath of the Israeli lobby for many years. 

So if you are holding your breath, expecting peace following the Palestinian elections, you can exhale now, Israel still holds the keys.

Ramzy Baroud is a veteran Arab-American journalist. A regular columnist in many English and Arabic publications, he is editor-in-chief of and program producer at Aljazeera Satellite Television

He is also the editor of the anthology: "Searching Jenin: Eyewitness Accounts of the Israeli Invasion."

To buy "Searching Jenin: Eyewitness Accounts of the Israeli Invasion" CLICK HERE

  Category: Middle East, World Affairs
  Topics: Occupation
Views: 1924

Related Suggestions

The opinions expressed herein, through this post or comments, contain positions and viewpoints that are not necessarily those of IslamiCity. These are offered as a means for IslamiCity to stimulate dialogue and discussion in our continuing mission of being an educational organization. The IslamiCity site may occasionally contain copyrighted material the use of which may not always have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. IslamiCity is making such material available in its effort to advance understanding of humanitarian, education, democracy, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law.

In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, and such (and all) material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.

Older Comments:
This article was well planned and thoughtful. I would like to make a pointthough. Many believe that the Israeli lobby is a powerful force in Washington, and that that is the reason for US foreign policy concerning the Middle East is the way it is - but that is really not the case, you give the lobby too much credit - if you take the last election results as a whole - the vast majority of the religious right and conservative Christians which are numbered in the tens of millions support Isreal virtually 100%. It is the constituants of the Congress that puts pressure on the lawmakers, they see the numbers (and the votes) - not the lobbist. You give them too much credit.

Now having said that - the tsunami killed at least 300,000 muslims at last count. The survivors are being fed and getting supplies because of the United States Navy and Marine Corp - and the Isreal search and rescue teams (which I have witnessed in Sri Lanka first hand) are doing remarkable things to help and show the rest of us that they are truly the best search and rescue teams in the world. - let us give credit to those Isreali's and Americans when it is due.
Warning: Attempt to read property "comment_date_gmt" on string in F:\inetpub\wwwroot\Accounts\\wp-content\themes\plain-child\content.php on line 1537

This opinion by Ramzy of course is the small part of the whole story that the world don't fully comprehend, nevertheless it is eye opener for those people who see news on CNN and feel they know what is going on. the pressure on Palestine victims is the result of many factors including the blind support the Israelis are getting from powerful groups as the Palestinians lose land and life everyday told to sacrifice and submit to murderess regimes including the sitting Israeli PM Sharon. I have no illusion peace will prevail; there is no way Palestine be a reality; there is no way stone throwers dismantle the illegal settlements that has been built since 1948. the day will come the Palestinians will have their land back even if it is a hundred years from now, the refugees needs to transfer their property through maps pictures and stories that would keep alive the hope of Palestinians until they get back their land, in the mean time Palestinians who are yet not pushed out of the small land they have left, needs to fight back systematically and made to Israelis costly occupying Palestine! They are just doing that. Thank you Ramzy.
Warning: Attempt to read property "comment_date_gmt" on string in F:\inetpub\wwwroot\Accounts\\wp-content\themes\plain-child\content.php on line 1537

REEDZ said:
With Mr Abbas as the new president of PA, i'm hoping that there will be peace between the palestinians and israelis. It may seems far fetched of an idea to be living in peaceful harmony side by side with your own neighbour country that you've been in war with for 4 decades! Then again lets be optimistic about it. Mr Abbas victory and as an individual himself is greatly being accepted by the US government, European countries and importantly Israel PM Ariel Sharon. Unfortunately, true victory only comes along when the Palestinians have their own land back with East Jerusalem as its capital city.
Warning: Attempt to read property "comment_date_gmt" on string in F:\inetpub\wwwroot\Accounts\\wp-content\themes\plain-child\content.php on line 1537