Anti Semitism is not the real danger to Jews today

Category: Europe, Faith & Spirituality Topics: Ariel Sharon, Europe, Judaism, Occupation, Racism Views: 3835
3835

Is anti-Semitism on the rise in Europe? Ariel Sharon, Israel's Prime Minister, this week gave warning of the re-emergence of "an anti-Semitism that has always existed". Attacks on Jewish targets in France and the bombing of the two synagogues in Turkey look like straws in the wind. And when a German MP assigns the Jews responsibility for the crimes of Bolshevism and the commander of the German special forces publicly agrees, then it is worthwhile addressing the question. 

No historian would want to deny the extent of European anti-Semitism in the early 20th century. However, the Holocaust led to a profound transformation of attitudes in Europe. After the war the commonly-held belief in scientific racism fell into disrepute and Unesco issued its famous declaration that race was a social myth. The basic law of Konrad Adenauer's West Germany explicitly outlawed racial prejudice. 

The Holocaust itself has become the single most-studied episode of the war, if not of the 20th century, and today there are Holocaust monuments, memorial days and museums - even in countries where it did not take place - and laws which criminalize Holocaust denial. So, contrary to what Sharon has indicated, only a few oddballs regard expressions of anti-Semitism as politically or culturally acceptable. 

Over the past 40 years there has been a huge generational shift in attitudes, and even the genteel prejudices of an earlier generation grate on the ears of the young. If a few echoes linger farther east, these too are dying away with the transformation of post-communist societies. 

But if the Holocaust eradicated anti-Semitism as a political force in Europe, it had another far-reaching consequence as well: it gave birth to Israel, thereby linking Europe, the Jews and the Arabs in a new way. If Israel looms large in the European political consciousness, it is not because Europeans are anti-Semites but because Europe itself is in many ways the architect of the present imbroglio. 

At a time when most Jewish emigrants were heading to the United States, Argentina and Western Europe, the British - for their own reasons - gave the green light for the creation of a Jewish national home in an Arab province of the Ottoman Empire. The British, the French, who successfully fought to prevent a Hashemite Greater Syria emerging in 1920, and the Nazis, who drove huge numbers of Jews into Palestine, between them turned out to be indispensable for the success of Jewish nationalism. 

Zionism, which brought "the people without land to the land without people", in fact implied the dispossession of Palestine's Arabs. Previously, anti-Semitism had been a negligible factor among the Arabs; there was little trace of it in the Ottoman world, where Jews and Muslims coexisted harmoniously. 

But even as European anti-Semitism dwindled, so it seemed to grow in the Middle East, fed by racial and religious myths imported from the defeated European Right. 

What has emerged is not at heart a racial antagonism but a political one - an anti-Zionism which takes Israeli rhetoric at face value by conflating Israelis and Jews. This is very different from the old inter-war European variety. The Nazis were not much bothered about Jews' political opinions; what counted was race. 

If anything, Zionists were the one kind of Jew that right-wing Europeans were prepared to deal with, since both sides desired the same thing - the departure of the Jews from Europe. Precisely the opposite is true for Arab opinion: conspiracy theories flourish, and so does Holocaust denial, but the real target is Zionism as a political doctrine. 

Israeli spokesmen, however, are now focusing not on sentiment in the Arab world but on signs of old hatreds in Europe. By doing so, they badly distort what is happening. When a German MP is forced to resign after comparing the Nazis with Jewish Bolsheviks, we are learning more about German frustrations over how the world deals with the Holocaust than about the dangers facing German Jews. 

Recently there has been a remarkable increase in the number of Israelis settling in Germany: so much for anti-Semitism there. Neo-Nazi and far-right groups continue to target synagogues and cemeteries. But this has been going on for years and has not pushed them into the mainstream - quite the contrary. 

What is new in the present equation is the violence mostly in France by young Arab youths against Jewish targets, a spill-over into Europe of the kind of anti-Zionism already described. 

Before we turn to the old catch-all labels of the past, we need to take a good look at the singer as well as the song. "The best solution to anti-Semitism," Sharon said in Rome last week, "is immigration to Israel." 

As Jewish migration from the former Soviet Union dwindles, the specter of depopulation looms large among Israeli officials who fear Jews may before long be outnumbered by the fecund Arabs in their midst. Sharon is the man, after all, who entered office vowing to bring a million new settlers to the country in order to reverse its alarming demographic deficit. 

There has always been a debate among Jews about the importance of anti-Semitism in Europe, and Zionists for obvious reasons have tended to emphasize the threat it poses. But today Israel itself looks more like a source of danger for Jews worldwide than a refuge, and even Israelis - though the emigration statistics remain a closely guarded official secret -are voting with their feet. 

If Sharon is seriously concerned about anti-Semitism, there is no one better placed than he to do something about it by changing his Government's policies towards the Palestinians. 

The author is Professor of History at Birkbeck College London


  Category: Europe, Faith & Spirituality
  Topics: Ariel Sharon, Europe, Judaism, Occupation, Racism
Views: 3835

Related Suggestions

 
COMMENTS DISCLAIMER & RULES OF ENGAGEMENT
The opinions expressed herein, through this post or comments, contain positions and viewpoints that are not necessarily those of IslamiCity. These are offered as a means for IslamiCity to stimulate dialogue and discussion in our continuing mission of being an educational organization. The IslamiCity site may occasionally contain copyrighted material the use of which may not always have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. IslamiCity is making such material available in its effort to advance understanding of humanitarian, education, democracy, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law.


In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, and such (and all) material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.


Older Comments:
STEVEN SICA FROM USA said:
Very good if brief piece. The final sentence re PM Sharon is eloquent in it's statement of the problem. We need to hear and read more opinions like this in the USA.
()

JERRY MEENTS FROM USA said:
Is the author implying if Israel disappeared everybody will love the Jews? Instead blaming Sharon for his Goverment's policies,mayby if Arafat and his underlings change there policies toward Israel there can be piece and less anti-semitism in the world
()

SALEEM FROM INDIA said:
i for one do not believe in anti-semitism or any ism which deliberately goes for the kill for anything that walks. it is the extremes in the societies that are threat to the world. the supporters of zionism may give many a strong reason that they are defending their innocents against a suicide bomber is all hoax. one decides to kill himself only when he resigns for himself that there is no other way to defend his liberty, dignity et al. Why there is no single suicide mission from the zionists side. simply because they are not the oppressed.

i know there are jews living in yemen, syria, egypt side by side muslims and they do not have any problem there, but why the jews want to live in a fort. simply because they have usurped the land from the palestinians and wish to hide.

zionists and the hamas both are hardcore idealogists, the zionists should be taken more seriously as the oppressors and hamas will collapse as it will not have any thing to do.
()

MIKE C said:
There is no such thing as an Arab Palestine or Palestinians. The Arabs who occupy present day Israel have as much claim to that land as the Arabs and other Muslims who make up the demographic majority of present day Paris, France have to the Eifel tower. It is a myth that Jews robbed Arabs of their land. The word Palestine was the name given to Judea by the Emperor Hadrian, as a policy to disposses his newly conquered people of their land. he chose that name after the Phillistines of the Bible who for generations after the Exodus were at war with the Jews. Neither the Phillistines nor the word Palestine are of Arabic origin. Furthermore, prior to the establishment of the artificial state of Jordan, Palestine refferred to the land area that encompassed both present day Israel and Jordan. Arabs with Israeli citizenship enjoy civil liberties and representation unheard of ubder the Hashemites.
Jerusalem has no significance to Islam. In all the time that the city was under the control of the Ottoman Turks, and the 19 years that it was part of Jordanian, it was neither a politcal, cultrual, religious, or economic capital of either government. At no point in history have Arabs ruled over Palestine. Why then should Jerusalem all of the sudden be the capital of a "Palestinian" state?
All of Isreal's military actions target combatants, and Israel goes to great lengths to avoid civillian colateral damage. The actions of Hamas, Islamic Jihad, Al Aksa Martyr's brigade, etc. especially target civillians. If arrested, a terrorist in Israel has never been sentenced to death. Every Arab and Muslim regime practices brutal repression against its own people, executes for possesion of alcohol, Christian missionary activity, and blasphemy(against the religious establishment or the government). The monarchy of the gulf states defecate on gold plated toilet seats, yet never send any releif aid to the poor masses of the Middle East. Yet Israel is the made out to be the oppressor.
()

TO PAUL MORLAND FROM W/ HERMIT QUEEN said:
I apologize to Sir Morland for hurting his nationalistic/patriotic feeling. How could I have missed UK???

Sir Morland I suggest that you spell out the words next time or mention it in the main text if you are that sensitive. For example, UK = UNITED KINGDOM. Nothing to be ashamed of. It's not your fault what your grandpas did around the world in the name of civlizing he world. To give a few examples - the British thugs and the hermit Queens are responsible for SLAVERY and building slave ships, cutting off fingers of people who wanted grow rice instead of opium, killing Native Americans and putting them into concentration camps across the Americas. They were responsible for owning slave, selling human beings and separating husband from wife and children, lynching, raping, and forcefully making them (fellow human beings) cook Grandpa Morlands' food.

Sir Morland!!! Please stop hiding your shameful past under the carpets by blaming Arabs for slavery.
The Arabs who own slaves were the proxies of British empire exactly like kings and Queens of Middle East are stuanchest proxies of United States toid.... & these thugs and the American and British transgressor are responsible for all the turmoil in the world today. Yet, they claim to be peace makers!!! Very sad and stupid.

Are there Arab Slave ships docked at Red Sea or at Niles today? I do not think so. So just stop making up stories.

Regarding anti-semitism, again it is you the Europeans started it and killed 8 million Jews. Again it is you the British thugs and American evil- doers encouraged all Jews around the world to forcefully occupy Palestine and kick out the native palestanians.

Did not you have enough land in Europe or in America for few million Jews? WHy displace one group of people (Palestanians) in order to accomodate another group? These are anit-warped facts of history. Learn to swallow the truth instead of denying. That's better for you both here and hereafter.





()

PAUL MORLAND FROM UK said:
In reply to 'To Paul Morland'

The idea that Zionism was created when the Jews decided to crucify Jesus and then ship Blacks to America is the most extraordinary nonsense I have ever seen on this site. You cannot really argue with someone who has such a warped understanding of history. Indeed, responses like this undermine the argument in the article that anti-Semitism is not really a problem. There is something very sad and very sick going on in the Islamic world today which brings a great religion and civilisation into disrepute.

As for my being an American, you obviously do not know what 'UK' means, which does not surprise me.

And are you saying that Arabs were not engaged in the slave trade for millenia - and still are?
()

JOHN NORMAN FROM UK said:
To the anonymous writer: As Torah preceded Islam by more than 1600 years, your charges against Jews are incoherent, incomprehensible and sheer nonsense. Nor did Jews arrange for the murder of Jesus. This was done by the Roman authorities.

You should really stop peddling your hate right now: you only give Islam and Muslims a bad name
()

TO ANNA ......FROM H.A. FROM NEXT TO THE WALL OF RACISM said:
Sorry My Dear Sister....You came on this site to learn about Palestanians????? Hmmm....wow!!!

Why don't you go to Palestine and learn about them and see the reality?

Good luck passing thru Israeli's checkpoints!!!
I hope you are not BULL-DOZED and come back to San Francisco in a body bag!!!


All my best wishes.
()

TO PAUL MORLAND FROM IN THE CENTER OF SLAVE TRIANGLE said:

"Zionism did not exist until decades after the transatlantic slave trade stopped..."

Hmmm...you (the Zionist) must be sleeping with the American moron too much.The zionism started when SOME JEWS (not all) started the plotting to Kill prophet Isa or Jesus (PBUH) and also when the day your Rabbias (Jews priest) changed Torah to a pamplet that permitted Jews to hate the Muslims and follow the footsteps of the great SATAN.

In year 2003, Not Jews are Zionist, but OBVIOUSLY you are an avid fan of Zionism. Keep up the good work.

Hmmm...blaming Muslims for slavery!!! Yeah, people know that. Don't try to hide your history (if you're a American who became a Zionist).

Heard about Colin Powell!!! The American gov't still treats him like a slave. Nobody listens to his ideas, although he is much more brilliant than the American cowboy. It's so sad that Mr. Powell can't wait to quit.

That's wrap. I hope you can handle the truth.
()

ANNA FROM USA said:
This article is biased and does not take into account the severity of anti-semitism. The writer may think the incidents are isolated, but that is not the case. It is growing and I myself have experienced it. I came to this website hoping to learn more about Palestinians. But when I hear something like this, I get upset. Everybody experiences pain in one way or another. The Israelis are doing something wrong. So are many Palestinians. But that does no give anyone the right to say that ant-semitism or arab-hatred does not exist? Even in such peaceful places as San Francisco I experience it. And my great grandmother experienced it long before Israel came into its modern existence. The problem with these articles is that they are all black-and-white.
()

PAUL MORLAND FROM UK said:
Zionists funding the slave ships that crossed the Atlantic. Hmmm... Zionism did not exist until decades after the transatlantic slave trade stopped, although at the time it was created, the Arab trading in Black slaves was still going on, as it is today in Sudan. Muslims blaming Zionists for the slave trade - now that really is rich.
()

SUHAYB FROM CANADA said:
after reading the weird comments,one last thing. To begin with racism is reading a human situation with a racial physical approach... The important thing is not to know how much "semite", the Europeen jews are. Playing with words is good for children but if one wants to go further...because i guess we could have fun trying to know who is "REALLY" arab, right? the answer is easy though...
()

MATTHEW CIVILETTI FROM USA said:
I find it difficult to believe the extent to which people misrepresent history and politics. While I do not support Sharon, the belief that somehow Israeli actions induce anti-semitism is riduculous, and is an insult to the millions who have perished because of ant-semitsm. Although there is some honest anti-israeli sentiment throughout Europe and the Middle East, it is a stretch of the truth (beyond anyone's wildest imagination) to deny that anti-semites have found an excuse in today's political arena. Perhaps Sharon and the Israeli right wing do not have the best interests of the Palestinians in mind, but politics NEVER induces hatred of an entire group--hate (including anti-semitism) flows from biased hate-mongers who use politics as an excuse. Even if Israel did not exist, anti-semites would find another excuse to propogate their disgusting and despicable ideology. This is why we must all join in the crusade for peace, tolerance and justice--only then can Muslims, Christians, Jews, Buddhists, Hindus, Atheists, etc. peacefully coexist.
()

WAZIR SHAKOOR FROM U.S.A. said:
Everywhere we look, we hear and see the retelling of the story of horrors that befell the Aryans who call themselves Jews. We whose ancesters were enslaved by Europeans of Zionist mindset find it amazing that the Zionists dont speak more of those who died on the slave ships they financed, on there way across the Atlantic Ocean. The native Americans were treated in the same way that the Palestinians are by the Zionists. Their land was taken in the same manner,(settlements, superior weapons, and economic isolation).
()

JOHN FROM UK said:
Zorro, once again, displays his ignorance for all to see.
()

SUHAYB FROM CANADA said:
obviously the author never tried walking through Paris with a Kippa on his head, if he had, his opinion would be so different...! Of course if Sharon changed the Israeli politics towards Palestine things would get much better in the arab world but just a little better in europe. way before the second intifada, my sister had to look at her school book with hitler written on every page...we're not even jewish, but our name is...welcome to France...pitbulls thrown in elementary jewish schools, synagogues burnt and daily beating...THATS FRANCE! also many many muslim brothers in jail, arabs are refused entrance to some public places etc...refusal for us to build Mosques, for our sisters to get education if wearing hidjab and so on...
()

ZORRO FROM UK said:
Defining anti-semetism as being exclusively anti-jewish is a common lie which needs to be addressed. The largest group of the semites in the world are the Arabs, not askheNAZI jews from east Europe who are the descendents of Khazar converts to Judaism. Talk about a bizzare case of identity theft.
Jews will find acceptance when they renege on their racist Zionism, otherwise quit whinning.
()

ZINEDINE FROM MOROCCO said:
asalaamu alaikum,

The media has successful imbedded the belief that today's Jews are Semites giving the impression to the ignorant & arrogant masses & elites that modern Jews are the descendants of the twelve tribes of Jacob aka Israel. Jules Masserman, an American Jew, testify that this belief especially common among the American ding dongs & hamburger brains is totally untrue. He supplies us with genetic evidence that about 90% of today's Jews are non-Semites & only about 10% are Semitic. So where does this 90% of the Jews came from? Most of them came from Kasaria during the reign of king Bulan. They were Christians and converted to Judaism in 850 CE mostly for political & financial reasons. Jules Masserman calls them the 13th tribe.
Most Semitic people today are the Arabs & the Ethiopians but since the Zionists & the Western powers control knowledge through their hegemony over all forms of mass media, ignorance will thrive & darkness will prevail for many more decades to come until the masses wake up & decide to make sacrifices. Until then, evil will always prevail.

Smack the Zog,

Zinedine
()

YAHYA BERGUM FROM USA said:
Lest we forget: "One cow in Palestine is worth more than all the Jews in Poland." -- Izaak Greenbaum
()

KASHIF SHAIKH FROM CANADA said:
Assalamua'alaium / Peace Be Upon You,

A timely and well worded article.

Something I can with honest heart forward to my Jewish, Muslim, Leftist, and others contacts/emailing lists.

Such as www.tikkun.org and www.comocanada.org

Jazak-Allah Khair(May God Reward You and Keep you Safe) to author.

()

J.D. said:
i always find it funny when muslims talk about the tolerance of jews during the ottoman reign. like dhimmitude was some kind of wonderful gift. well, apparently the jews didn't like it that much. they seemed unimpressed by that second-class citizenry. i wonder why?
()