Primordial Illogic and Primitive Cruelty

Category: Life & Society, Middle East Views: 3389

screaming face

There is nothing more logical than setting arbitrary times of day when a Palestinian is allowed to leave his home and come back to it. There is nothing more logical than forbidding him to leave his field in a pickup truck to take his crops straight to market. It is logical to forbid him to receive guests, to take a donkey-drawn wagon, to ride a bicycle, to visit his parents a few kilometers away - or to bring a goat into his house `without coordination` so as to provide some fresh milk for his children.

There is nothing more logical than to fence the Palestinian into his village, neighborhood, and land, with an electronic barrier, and then set a minimum age to leave. It is logical to appoint 19-year-old soldiers to watch the gate, which is sometimes opened on time and sometimes not, and to impose the rules - 29-year-olds are not allowed out, 30-year-olds are, pregnant women are allowed out, non-pregnant woman are not.

It is logical to forbid all crossing when the Shin Bet suddenly requires it, leaving outside a 65-year-old man who went out to buy something a kilometer and a half away, or a young man who went for dental treatment, or a mother whose children stayed at home because only children under the age of 21 are allowed out.

It is so logical to forbid a Palestinian to go to the beach 300 meters from his home, and to prevent half a million people from nearby towns from going to the beach. It is so logical. After all, that`s what army commanders and soldiers do, day in and day out, hour by hour, in Gaza, in the Siafa area in the north and the Mawassi in the center of the Strip.

It`s logical, because the IDF`s mission in the heart of Gaza - which it did not leave in 1994, despite the Oslo legend - is to guarantee the safety and security and lives of Israelis whose government continues to encourage in moving to occupied territory. It is logical because Israeli governments since the 1970s and on, Labor and Likud, decided to settle Jews in the main open areas in the narrow Gaza Strip, in the prettiest area of dunes and on the most spectacular beach, in an area blessed with fresh water compared to the rest of the Gaza area.

It is logical to lock people up in their homes and villages, and to sabotage the farming of their land because it is logical to subsidize the Jewish settlement in the land of the forefathers of Gush Katif and northern Gaza. It is logical to connect Jewish settler homes to electricity and water while forbidding Palestinian neighbors from connecting to the electricity grid and the water and sewage lines.

It sounds cruel to lock people up in their homes and uproot their groves and orchards that they spent decades nurturing. But it`s a logical cruelty, Israel is convinced, if that is what it takes to foil the cruelty of others - to prevent an armed Palestinian attack on a nursery school or a plant nursery or to plant a landmine on the route of a tank that is patrolling to protect the nursery school and the plant nursery.

During the Oslo years, many good Israelis made do with the logical thought that `eventually` the settlements in Gaza would be dismantled. Logic and policy are two different things. Meanwhile, even before the bloodshed broke out in September 2000, the settlements in Gaza expanded, their infrastructures were improved and their security required the army to dictate various Draconian prohibitions of movement for a million Palestinians.

The northern Gaza Strip, with its minuscule settlements, was cut off from the rest of the strip and de facto annexed to Israel. Palestinian representatives tried to speak to the logical minds of their Israeli counterparts at the negotiating table. It didn`t work. On the contrary, the number of settlements in Gaza only grew.

With subsidizes and expanding infrastructures and good roads and an expanding market for their worm-free lettuce - why should they leave? And why should the government dismantle the settlements when the Palestinians themselves signed the agreements that did not require the settlements to be dismantled? The quiet that most Palestinians kept most of the time proved to Israelis that it was possible to get peace with the settlements.

That quiet relieved the Israelis of the duty to deal with the primordial illogic, the primordial cruelty - establishing the settlements. The governments used the Palestinian quiet to continue developing the settlements. And after September 2000, what the appeals to logic did not accomplish, the armed attacks certainly won`t accomplish. After all, Israel will never give in to terror.

Even before any Qassam rockets were fired at Sderot, the army shot to death people who dared approach settlements and the fortifications that protect the settlements. Some were armed, but many were simply shepherds and peasants and their stone-throwing children. All the farmland around the settlements was shaved down to nothing - raked, flattened and demolished, to improve the vision of soldiers preserving the settlements. How logical.


  Category: Life & Society, Middle East
Views: 3389
The opinions expressed herein, through this post or comments, contain positions and viewpoints that are not necessarily those of IslamiCity. These are offered as a means for IslamiCity to stimulate dialogue and discussion in our continuing mission of being an educational organization. The IslamiCity site may occasionally contain copyrighted material the use of which may not always have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. IslamiCity is making such material available in its effort to advance understanding of humanitarian, education, democracy, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law.

In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, and such (and all) material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.

Older Comments:
Muslims have forsaken quran and hadith.
and so the consequences are upfront not just in palestine but throught the globe.
struggle in palestine have been reduced to a nationalist struggle for establishement of a independent palestinian state,to give homeland to palestinians.
so why should any muslim living in any other country help, its struggle for palestinians and they should fight it.its for thier country, not for alqsa or islam or against injustice and kufr.
its for a secular palestian state.
and such staruggle is doomed to be a failure and result in more mysery and suffering for help of Allah is away from it.

When it comes to "letting the cat out of the bag" Jews-for-Allah (.org) seems to do the best job. A page at their site explains how the Laws of Moses are being broken through the present day occupation of Palestine. A related page explains how Allah's promise to Ibrahim (peace be upon him) was conditional - according to the behavior of his descendents (peace be upon them).

Also, the land was intended for Ibrahim's offspring. The term "offspring" is plural - as everyone seems to agree that Ibrahim (peace be upon him) had more than one son (peace be upon them).

Peace be upon you as well.

I strongly believe that what goes around comes around. THE DAYS WILL COME.

Clearly the Isrealis have not learned the slightest bit of history. Soon the Horn will be blown and Justice will be served. May the believers continue in the efforts against opperssion. La illa ha Il Allah.


Yusuf I think you have the wrong choice of words. please do not offend other Muslims by calling them impotent. The plain and simple fact is that the Ummah is suffering from a serious mental obstruction. This obstruction is built upon fear. We fear being persecuted, we fear how we will be treated...but we do not fear Allah as much as we should...let alone fear him we do not submit to his command...this takes Taqwa dear brother, not only Iman and Salaat will do. We cannot just fear Allah, we must have constant consciousness of Him. He is aware of all that we do. We should give him the recognition he following his law, his code of behaviour and ethics that we have in the Qur'an and the Sunnah of our beloved Prophet (SAAW). Then will we only see that Allah (SWT) will make our lives prosperous and righteous. Let's start by opening our hearts and our minds to Allah (SWT).

As long as Muslims remain impotent, they will always be treated worse than animals - as animals have rights that Israel, the US and Britain deem Muslims don't deserve. Countries born from terrorism and slavery are now dictating 'morals' to Muslims, whose own background gave light to a dark world.

My Prayers are with all who suffer. May god ease their suffering in this world and reward them with paradise in the next.

As for the persecutors, may god show them the pit of fire they dig for themselves so that they may repent and beg god's forgivesness.

May Allah remove the burdens from our backs and hearts.


Cruelty is good diplomacy. You can scare just about anyone into a dump compromise by putting tremendous pressure on them.

And nothing puts tremendous pressure than the loss of ones freedom. Remove a person's freedom and he becomes dehumanized. And 19-year old Isreali soldiers like nothing more than shooting dehumanized Palestinians. Just as their ancestors were shot by Germans.

I guess dishonoring the memories of their ancestors seems like an easy price to pay for an Israeli state free of a Palestinian infestation.

Their cruelty, efficiency, public policy and inhumanity resembles very much the NAZI regime that considered all Jews rats that should be exterminated without guilt.

It has become more important than before to overthrow all the so-called Muslim governments starting from Saudi Arabia, who has secretly cooperated with Americans in all aspects of destruction and carnage.

Shuja Syed