How is Jesus Both God and Human? |
Post Reply | Page 123 4> |
Author | ||
Israfil
Senior Member Joined: 08 September 2003 Status: Offline Points: 3984 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
Posted: 07 April 2005 at 7:15pm |
|
As'Salaamu Alaikum,
I myself do not like to talk about subjects concerning just one prophet since glory is due solely to God. But by this being an interfaith dialouge which is meant for the Abrahamic faiths, this subject I believe is quite appropriate. Many Christians whom I have discussed many times with always used the Christian explanation when question about the nature of Christ, how he was both God and both human. Over the course of my dialouge many have given good explanations and some outrageous ones as well. The concept of Jesus like all other prophets in Islam are obviously explained, if one is equipped with the basic understanding of Islam. My primary concern is the spiritual nature of Jesus. A man who lived in a chaotic time. A man who lived in a chaotic time, whose surroundings consisted of a paganistic society and whose people were in turmoil due to greed, power, and other vices which can corrupt civilizations. My question to my Christian brothers in faith is, how can such a man be both God (Creator) and man? On this website we have discussed this question in countless arguments and countless debates and we still are at ground zero without even coming to answer such a question. On a more complex scale it would seem logically impossible and quite contradictory in the Metaphysical sense (yes I have to go back to the science and Philosophy of things because this is how God created everything). How does such a being who is not limited in time is limited in time? For the Christian how does paradox seem logical for belief? Is it something like faith regardless of its paradox one believes in the God whom is called Jesus? Even as a former Christian I have struggled with many things under this question. Priest, Catholics, Evangelist have not clearly explained this phenomena. To better understand this question clearly I even dabbled with the question that maybe God can morph (as in the physical sense) from n incorporeal being to a temporal being. If this was the case then the nature of God is not infinite but is dual. Perhaps God is both infinite and temporal in nature as if representing some eternal balance within himself such as Yin and Yang for a more extreme view. I also went further in saying that if the nature of God is dual then perhaps if the nature of God is negative and positive then is it possible that the famous parable is right, that God can create a rock so heavy he cannot lift. With all these questions I could never find answers from my Christian friends so I implore my Christian brothers and sisters in faith to help me understand the nature of Jesus in respect to his divinity I could have a clear answer. The only catch is your post cannot be just Bible verses as verses are subject to interpretation so it wouldn't be really clear if you just posted just verses without your own explanation. Edited by Israfil |
||
Angel
Senior Member Joined: 03 July 2001 Status: Offline Points: 6641 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
Have you actually gone to the Triniterians? who actually do believe Jesus is God. What I think the problem is that some people have gotten it wrong about the word becoming flesh, which some must have interpreted as God becoming flesh/human. I've been doing some reading on the trinity which this issue of yours is connected with. And found some interesting stuff.
This is what don't understand, and I know we (the board) have gone down this road before, Why would it be that the nature of God is not infinite ? If you say that God in the human physical body is limited in what he can do, then I would might agree with you..sort of. If God can do all things, create everything then don't you think it might just be possible that God has a way to and can morph into a temporal being and back to incorporeal being, and perhaps back to temporal being. If God is limitless in what He can do then he obviously can do this. And If Angel Gabriel showed himself to Muhammmed dressed as a man sometimes in public, then why not God Himself do the same ? Both God and Angel Gabriel are incorporeal beings, are they not ? while God is the greater. Wouldn't the concept be the same as that of Gabriel ?
Masculine and femimine . I don't know about balancing Himself since as the story goes, it was only one time. If He was balancing Himself out then it would be back and forth but it was/is not. |
||
~ Our feet are earthbound, but our hearts and our minds have wings ~
|
||
Angel
Senior Member Joined: 03 July 2001 Status: Offline Points: 6641 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
Have you actually gone to the Triniterians? who actually do believe Jesus is God. What I think the problem is that some people have gotten it wrong about the word becoming flesh, which some must have interpreted as God becoming flesh/human. I've been doing some reading on the trinity which this issue of yours is connected with. And found some interesting stuff.
This is what don't understand, and I know we (the board) have gone down this road before, Why would it be that the nature of God is not infinite ? If you say that God in the human physical body is limited in what he can do, then I would might agree with you..sort of. If God can do all things, create everything then don't you think it might just be possible that God has a way to and can morph into a temporal being and back to incorporeal being, and perhaps back to temporal being. If God is limitless in what He can do then he obviously can do this. And If Angel Gabriel showed himself to Muhammmed dressed as a man sometimes in public, then why not God Himself do the same ? Both God and Angel Gabriel are incorporeal beings, are they not ? while God is the greater. Wouldn't the concept be the same as that of Gabriel ?
Masculine and femimine . I don't know about balancing Himself since as the story goes, it was only one time. If He was balancing Himself out then it would be back and forth but it was/is not.
I have come to understand and this is somewhat inline with my own thoughts, that reading some verses Jesus was godlike and this is taken as Jesus being God, for some, but being godlike is not actually being God. In the bible Jesus does say "godlike and ye are gods" but is it in capital letter ? If Jesus actually meant he is God don't you think he would've have used "G" instead ? It's all in the way its written. The Bible or Jesus doesn't actually say he is God, when I have said that Jesus said he was God, I was taking in the sense of others not my own actual beliefs, that being said I also somewhat understood the the term differently "Jesus is God" as not being God despite the capital "G" in the phrase. I thought people knew that Jesus wasn't God so I was trying to explain how they might see how Jesus is God, but I was wrong and people (some) actually do see Jesus is God. So that bit has been rendered fruitless but as I said above that things have come into line with my thoughts about the issue not all is fruitless . I think But since some others, namely the triniterians actually do believe that Jesus is God, not sure at this stage how they got to understand or why they believe that. But it seems also they are wrong. must go, got to do the other post on the trinity Edited by Angel |
||
~ Our feet are earthbound, but our hearts and our minds have wings ~
|
||
blond
Senior Member Joined: 30 March 2005 Status: Offline Points: 218 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
There is nothing "spooky" about all of this. I will list an Ayat from the Quran concerning this topic, that is in plain language, easy to understand. But watch how allegory will creep into the responses of those who respond to the Ayat I list. You will see clearly how we can be easily lead astray. Allah is plain in His language when He says;
No morphing, no magic. Edited by blond |
||
DavidC
Senior Member Male Christian Joined: 20 September 2001 Location: Florida USA Status: Offline Points: 2474 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
Catholic thought refers to the unexplainable parts of Christianity as the
Mysteries http://www.catholic.org/clife/prayers/mystery.php. Christians in general run the gamut between thinking of Jesus as a prophet in the Muslim sense to literal trinitarianistic concepts. Since God is beyond human understanding, it seems logical Jesus divinity is beyond our understanding too. DavidC |
||
blond
Senior Member Joined: 30 March 2005 Status: Offline Points: 218 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
This statement calls to mind the introduction of many Bibles, "... translated from the Original tongues of the Lost Books of the Bible". The Books were not lost, they were hidden by those who altered the words of the Books from their original places. Substituting the revealed word of God for their own word, then telling the people that it was from God. I appreciate the Western man for one great reason alone. While all the other peoples of the Earth looked up at the sky and saw the rain come down, the Eastern people said, "Allah is great for giving us the rain". But, the Western man said, "I can do that" and seeded the clouds. While the people of the East marvelled at the Sun in the sky, Western man said, "I can do that" and produced nuclear power. While the people of the East marvelled at the Moon circling the Earth, Western man put up satellites and rockets. Western man does not deal with Allah in a "spooky" way. He understands the Law of Cause and Effect. For there to be a real effect, there had to be a real cause, not a mystery spooky god. God is Real. Edited by blond |
||
DavidC
Senior Member Male Christian Joined: 20 September 2001 Location: Florida USA Status: Offline Points: 2474 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
But we do not believe we are God because we can seed clouds.
Christians believe Jesus was 100% man and 100% God =(200%). We are not denying the 100% that is reality, but there is also knowledge that can only be passed along through paradox, parable and symbolism. Christianity seems to have much in common with Sufism in this regard, but unfortunately the gnostic influences have been largely purged from our religion and has left those aspects sterile. DavidC |
||
AhmadJoyia
Senior Member Joined: 20 March 2005 Status: Offline Points: 1647 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
|
This christian belief is based on conjecture only and that too, derived through the books of unknown authors which were selectively chosen based upon the recommendations of concil of humans gathered almost 5 centuries after Jesus; merely a guess work. The total argument usually given in support of this kind of belief is by asking the question that; is it not possible that since God is all powerfull, in his infinite capacity, he can come to earth in a human form? This is inherrantly a flawed reasoning as one can ask a question on similar basis that can God make such a load heavy that he himself can't lift it? Any answer to this question would be selfcontradicting. This type of reasoning works only for the ignorant people who would put their beliefs on conjectural mysteries. It is for this very reason that quran ask them to leave the conjecture and follow the true path based on facts. However, since the time of Prophet Jesus, extremely little probability exists that anyone can figure out facts from their available resources. Hence, there is all the more logical reasons for them to study Islam and recognise God through it without any conjectures, paradoxes, parables and symbolism. |
||
Post Reply | Page 123 4> |
Tweet
|
Forum Jump | Forum Permissions You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot create polls in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum |