I love interesting thesis, but this one, perhaps, excels all the others I have seen since the departure of our friend, Richard Perl, from the Pentagon.
I hope, you will forgive me if I asked you just a few questions:
1. What part of Afghanistan are you from?
2. Are you a Pukhtoon?
3. You won�t mind if I asked you about your qabeeleh?
4. Or, is it that you just happen to be residing in Afghanistan?
5 Where did you learn to pen down such good English, with no hint
with no hint whatsoever of any Afghaniness in it?
6. You don�t live near some poppy growing area?
(Once, I lived in an area like that and came to learn that just the air can induce such deep and interesting thought)
How were they formed?
Is it ever possible that sometimes, if not often, organisations do spring up in reaction to something?
Your post seems to suggest that Resistance Groups are not naturally cultured. They are always mandated by someone. An Afghan mind is ever more prone to considering "resistance" as a natural phenomenon. That's why I asked you the question if you just happen to be living in Afghanistan. Your mind, your angle and your script seems to betray some American think tank churn.
Considering that the Americans did not try to topple Khomeini and the Iranian Revolution
That's again a revelation for me and, I believe, for quite a few in our world who happen to have studied the situation. They tried their level best, but then even the best of a "super power" doesn't simply work.
Why didnt the Hezbulah go into Israel to destroy it and free Palestine?
I didn't realise that it was almost as easy as going into the Mustapha Hotel and picking up a hot chirgha for lunch?
The Government in Iraq is handed over to the Shiahs.
I agree with you, the Iraqi government should have been handed over to the Mandokhels of Ghazni, but the problem was that there are over 60% Shiahs in Iraq and these gangsters voted for their own guys.
We also know that Khomeini came to Iran from France... with a French plane.
Brother, I mostly travel on British planes, I sincerely hope, you won't start peddling me down the street as a British agent or something.
If it was so bad for Khomeni to travel on a French plane, you should sent him some nice Kunduz ponies for his ride to Qum.
I must apologise I am unable to deal with the rest of your post, I am in a very slow connection area, somewhere not very far from where you are residing, I am a Pathaan and for me resistance is the single most natural thing. Every Afghan I have ever met in my life thinks and feels like that. Please do forgive me for saying that I do not smell or vibe an Afghan in you at all. You are peddling something with a very simple agenda.
Good luck, but please do get a better script from the CIA for your next post.