I don�t appreciate the topic being closed

AstagfirAllah!  Please don't use such condescending speech with your Muslim sisters, Brother.  And the clash was among those who believe the hadith modify the Holy Quran, and those who believe that if Hadith do not support the Holy Quran that it is not valid -- which I adhere to.


It was a good topic. Music is a skill... God doesnt punish you for learning other skills... writing? drawing? unless you use them for some evil purpose...

Ameen.  It is a skill and a blessing from our Loving Lord, a tribute to His glory and majesty.

But this goes to show - that if you complain enoupgh .. you can make anything happen. Get a topic closed just because you dont like what somone is advocating.

herjihad wrote: Bismillah,   AstagfirAllah!  Please don't use such condescending speech with your Muslim sisters, Brother. And the clash was among those who believe the hadith modify the Holy Quran, and those who believe that if Hadith do not support the Holy Quran that it is not valid -- which I adhere to. Ameen.  It is a skill and a blessing from our Loving Lord, a tribute to His glory and majesty. Was that why it was closed?  I thought it was because this site will always close a site when a person like me says that they firmly believe that hadith do not change the Quraan, but are only valid when they complement the Holy Quraan.

So what if they were non muslims.. would that be ok to Condecend them?... Just because somone flys the Muslim banner does not give them automatic protection from criticism. Its called being religously biased and its sickening. If "The muslim sisters" dont want to be called catty.. then they shouldnt be catty.

You see.. I told you, the moderators rule based on their own interpretation of islam. But no.. they are "DOing a good job" as you were so fond of saying. Everything is good untill it affects you undesirably. Its a law of human nature.

As much as I disagree with Peacemaker on many issues including this one, I respect that he has to make decisions because noone else will do so.  This is my communication to him on my feelings on the topic asking him to consider what I am saying.  I cannot be a moderator as the responisibility is tremendous and would be overwhelming for me.  I appreciate the brothes and sisters who undertake this unpaid avocation. 

Your comment that everything is good until it affects me is off base completely.  You don't know me, and this occurence doesn't prove this to be true in my character at all. 

I read the guidlines... and i'm sure few people have.. it only has 109 Views as of this moment.

I have read the guidelines a couple of times at least.  I think that other members have read them also.  Why are you so sure that few people have?  When we have continued discourse on a topic, it's obviously going to get more Hits.

Compare that to "Mishmish the New Moderator" 704 Views... or "The Fifa - World Cup" Thread.. which has well over a 1000 views.  If the rules were broken in the "Halal Music" Thread.. then slap my head and call me silly because they are also broken every where else on this forum all the time...

but its ok... I rather see 1 Locked Thread every few weeks rather than 15 every time I log on...  

Ps. I wasnt being condecending any way.. maybe you should look up Catty on dictionary.com

Dictionary.com doesn't have all of the derivations or connotations implied in this word.  This coyness concerning the derogatory nature of the word catty as it clearly not only implies nastiness, but nastiness and subversiveness particular to females, is not an appropriate adjective for women discussion important issues, especially your Muslim Sisters.  That women are cattish or catty or engage in cat fights is incorrect and I seek the abolishment of such foolish, incorrect characterizations which demean either men or women for the fun of it.  Men aren't really dogs and women aren't catty.  Men can be disloyal, and women can be aggressive in conversation.  While the animalistic terms are great for comedy, they are inappropriate for serious, considerate discussions amongst equal adult people.

herjihad wrote: Your comment that everything is good until it affects me is off base completely.  You don't know me, and this occurence doesn't prove this to be true in my character at all.

Dont be self-centered... I dont pretend to know you... and I wasnt talking about you when I said everything is ok untill it affects you.. I said it was a law of Human nature.. not "Her-Jihad's Nature"..

But I dont care much for semantics... they are as trivial as counting the number of sand-grains on mars.

that aside..

Good - Great... Wonderful... Well Done ol Champ.

If I have to respond again to this repetative issue.. i'll do so with a musical tune on my guitar... how poetic? hahaha... then some of you can tell me how much of a sinner I am... haha.. ..