Wants a proof that Quran is God's word !! |
Post Reply | Page <1 1920212223 27> |
Author | |||
asep garutea
Senior Member Male Islam Joined: 18 January 2019 Location: Indonesia Status: Offline Points: 281 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
||
@ Airmano (Thanks for your open reply.) Answer: You're welcome Airmano. 1) The people participating in the discussion put their feelings and/or state of knowledge on the table without deforming or hiding [part of] the information they have. Answer: Yes you're right, after I studied many other books that exist today, then I match them with scientific knowledge of humans. And only the Qoran has a lot of information about things related to science. 2) Each participant accepts the idea that he/she [himself] may also be proven wrong [change his mind] provided somebody else comes along with a deeper understanding or more convincing arguments. Answer: I think not all participants will follow a more convincing understanding because it returns to one's reasoning or way of thinking about proof of a truth. From what you wrote I'd state that you probably conform to 1) but not to 2). Answer: Yes you're right for no. 1, but for no. 2 is relative. In this context I feel it as ironic to ask me "to read the Quran with an open mind" when there is no ability to comply to this very principle on the other side. Answer: In this case it is up to someone's curiosity whether they want to read the Koran or not (there is no compulsion), and for all of that, there is already the Almighty and the Most Decisive. |
|||
asep garutea
Senior Member Male Islam Joined: 18 January 2019 Location: Indonesia Status: Offline Points: 281 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
||
@ Tim the plumber (1, Go to the sea side and look at any stream or river entering the sea. It will mix very easily. The water in say the Thames estury where the river's valley has been flooded by sea level rise 12,000 years ago when the great ice sheets melted, will be 100% fresh above the tidal zone but gradually change to 100% salt water with a gradual increase in salinity as you go along it. Try it out for yourself you don't need to be qualified to do this.) Answer: Sorry Tim, what I mean in the Qoran is not all rivers that flow into the sea, but certain places as proof of God's power. A proven example is the Strait of Gibraltar which can be explained scientifically. The Strait of Gibraltar is a meeting between the Mediterranean Sea and Atlantic Sea. Cousteau said: "We studied the statements of certain researchers about the barriers that separate the oceans and observed that the Mediterranean Sea has different salinity and density as well as being a dwelling place for the flora and fauna that are typical of that place." He added: "The two seas showed different characteristics even though they were side by side. This is very surprising. "A magic veil prevents the two from mixing. A similar veil is also observed in Bab Al Mandab in the Gulf of Aden which meets the Red Sea." The boundary between the meeting of these two types of water was explained about 14 centuries ago in one verse of the Qoran. "And it was He (Allah) who let the two seas flow (side by side); this one is tasteless and fresh and the other is very salty and bitter; and He makes between the two walls and the boundary which is not transparent." (Qoran 25: verse 53) (2, The Moon may well have a geologic history. It indeed does. That does not mean that the thing was ever split during the last couple of billion years. So no human could have possibly witnessed sucha thing. You know that the Quoran say it happened.) Answer: No one in this age will be able to witness because it happened around 14 centuries ago. However, historical evidence is still exist today that at the time it was witnessed by many people. |
|||
airmano
Senior Member Joined: 31 March 2014 Status: Offline Points: 884 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
||
@ Asep
"In this case it is up to someone's curiosity whether they want to read the Koran or not (there is no compulsion)" I did read the Quran at least a good part of it and even with an open mind. It is not to insult, but I classify it among the 10 most pointless books I've ever read (sure my eyes must be sealed). From my side it reads as: Funny fairy tales about beings out of smokeless fire, 7 Heavens (why not 8 ?), rivers of wine (but devoid of alcohol) stories of a huge ship built by one guy without decent tools; so big that it could take all species; so much rain that the ship could even end up on top of a mountain (strange that the water didn't flow away), Allah creating humans which interestingly enough share 98% of their genes with monkeys, us made out of water ? or dust ? or hold on, was it clay after all ? Never mind, nobody will notice the difference anyway. Still, I found that it takes a lot of belief to accept the story of Muhammad having a hike to heaven[s] ending up negotiating the number of prayers per Day with God. Why did God even enter into the negotiations ? He's all-knowledgeable, I think he should have known the result before. But well, these are just stories after all... Airmano
|
|||
The word God is for me nothing more than the expression and product of human weaknesses (Albert Einstein 1954, in his "Gods Letter")
|
|||
airmano
Senior Member Joined: 31 March 2014 Status: Offline Points: 884 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
||
@Asep
"I believe more in Tom's statement." Great that you trust Tom, when you go on his website airandspace.si.edu/stories/editorial/shrinking-tectonically-active-moon you find a clear scientific explanation on how the fault lines formed. Any moon-splitting there ? Airmano
|
|||
The word God is for me nothing more than the expression and product of human weaknesses (Albert Einstein 1954, in his "Gods Letter")
|
|||
asep garutea
Senior Member Male Islam Joined: 18 January 2019 Location: Indonesia Status: Offline Points: 281 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
||
@ Airmano (Great that you trust Tom, when you go on his website airandspace.si.edu/stories/editorial/shrinking-tectonically-active-moon you find a clear scientific explanation on how the fault lines formed.) Any moon-splitting there ? Answer: Yes, I would be more inclined to the statement of scientists who approach the word of Allah. And that's what I meant that humans in discovering something that is still a mystery will go through several experimental processes. So it's not certaintly the same among one scientist's statement with the others. As an example of differences in opinion among scientists about the earth as the center of the circulation of the sun and the sun as the center of the circulation of the earth. And today, all scientists agree that the earth circulates around the sun even the sun also has a center for its circulation. |
|||
asep garutea
Senior Member Male Islam Joined: 18 January 2019 Location: Indonesia Status: Offline Points: 281 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
||
@ Airmano I did read the Quran at least a good part of it and even with an open mind. It is not to insult, but I classify it among the 10 most pointless books I've ever read (sure my eyes must be sealed). From my side it reads as: Funny fairy tales about beings out of smokeless fire, 7 Heavens (why not 8 ?), rivers of wine (but devoid of alcohol) stories of a huge ship built by one guy without decent tools; so big that it could take all species; so much rain that the ship could even end up on top of a mountain (strange that the water didn't flow away), Allah creating humans which interestingly enough share 98% of their genes with monkeys, us made out of water ? or dust ? or hold on, was it clay after all ? Never mind, nobody will notice the difference anyway. Still, I found that it takes a lot of belief to accept the story of Muhammad having a hike to heaven[s] ending up negotiating the number of prayers per Day with God. Why did God even enter into the negotiations ? He's all-knowledgeable, I think he should have known the result before. But well, these are just stories after all... Answer: Yes Airmano, the Qoran was revealed for those who can ponder and express its true meaning because its contents are universal. Therefore, only people who can use common sense can learn from all the verses in the Qoran (Allah said in the Qoran). Your question about: "7 Heavens (why not 8?)" is almost similar to the question of the people of Moses who asked about vegetables. You may not believe what you have read in the Qoran, even though that is true. And please remember that there is nothing in the Qoran explaining about (Allah creating humans which is interestingly enough to share 98% of their genes with monkeys) (like Darwin's theory), instead humans are civilized and intelligent creatures, unlike animals. Sometimes there are people who only think according to what they see now, which is finally associated with what actually happened around thousands of years ago. The Qoran doesn't explain the negotiations on prayer, but it is in the hadith. And maybe you don't know much about why the Prophets and their people were ordered to pray. Have you really read the Qoran ? |
|||
airmano
Senior Member Joined: 31 March 2014 Status: Offline Points: 884 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
||
@Asep
"And please remember that there is nothing in the Qoran explaining about [Darwin]" Correct, but Adam is mentioned as the first human being created by God. Science says otherwise. How do you reconcile the two ? ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- "The Qoran doesn't explain the negotiations on prayer, but it is in the hadith" I know. I also didn't say so. But there are still many Muslims buying this story. -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- "Have you really read the Qoran ?" About 2/3 of it and even with an 'open mind', but then I got really bored. For the rest I browsed through to see whether it would get any better but I stopped when I saw that it didn't. I think it is a myth to believe that an interested reader gets automatically impressed by the Quran. I actually believe that most of the non-Muslim readers don't really make it beyond the first three pages. In any case I think the [historic] purpose of this book is all too obvious,.. |
|||
The word God is for me nothing more than the expression and product of human weaknesses (Albert Einstein 1954, in his "Gods Letter")
|
|||
asep garutea
Senior Member Male Islam Joined: 18 January 2019 Location: Indonesia Status: Offline Points: 281 |
Post Options
Thanks(0)
|
||
@ Airmano (Correct, but Adam is mentioned as the first human being created by God. Science says otherwise. How do you reconcile the two ?) Answer: If we are really careful in reading the contents of Allah's words in the Qoran, we will know about the genetic differences and the time of creation between humans and animals, for example in the Qoran 36: 71. Allah Said: اَوَلَمْ يَرَوْا اَنَّا خَلَقْنَا لَهُمْ مِّمَّا عَمِلَتْ اَيْدِيْنَاۤ اَنْعَامًا فَهُمْ لَهَا مٰلِكُوْنَ "And do they not see that He (Allah) has created animals for them (humans) ?, which is part of what He has created with His authority, then they have mastered it." (Qoran 36: verse 71) This implies that animals were created by Allah before the Prophet Adam. It also explains that Allah had prepared all the needs for humans on earth before humans were created. In a hadith narrated by al Muslim from Abu Hurairah r.a., he said: The Prophet Muhammad hold my hand and said: Allah created the earth on Saturday, created mountains on Sunday, created trees on Monday, created that ugly (hated) on Tuesday, created light on Wednesday, created animals on earth on Thursday. And created the Prophet Adam after the Asr time on Friday, and the end of the event, end of the time between Asr at night." The above verse and hadith prove that human genetics are not the same as animals. Another prove: Humans are given the ability to change civilization from primitive to modern, while animals are not, etc. "The Qoran doesn't explain the negotiations on prayer, but it is in the hadith" (I know. I also didn't say so. But there are still many Muslims buying this story.) Answer: The hadith on this subject is saheeh, almost all hadith collectors justify this hadith, including al Bukhari and al Muslim. Negotiation about the prayer (salah) for Muslims is not a problem because it's Allah's willing. It's almost the same with the suspension of one's death (lengthened) because he always prays to be extended, and whether it is granted or not, only Allah has the absolute right to decide. Likewise related to negotiations about prayer (salah). Allah Said: يَمْحُو اللهُ مَايَشآءُ وَيُثْبِتُ وَعِنْدَهُ �£ُمُّ الْكِتَابِ “Allah removes and determines what He wants, and on His side is the Ummul of the Book (Lawh Mahfudz)." (Qoran 13:39) Have you really read the Qoran ?" (About 2/3 of it and even with an 'open mind', but then I got really bored. For the rest I browsed through to see whether it would get any better but I stopped when I saw that it didn't. I think it is a myth to believe that an interested reader gets automatically impressed by the Quran.) Answer: Yes Airmano, not everyone will quickly understand the Qoran, because it will require sufficient time to read it often, including being very careful in understanding it. (I actually believe that most of the non-Muslim readers don't really make it beyond the first three pages.) (In any case I think the [historic] purpose of this book is all too obvious,..) Answer: Of course, even not all Muslims have really understood it. |
|||
Post Reply | Page <1 1920212223 27> |
Tweet
|
Forum Jump | Forum Permissions You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot create polls in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum |