how do you disprove god?

good response chris,
I agree with your swan example, and relent that the dawn aspect is a prediction, not an explanation. That would be more of a why does the tide come in and go out...well it's because of allah. That's easily disprovable, because we can test for it ,and observe and see that's not the case. In fact there's an explanation that doesn't require allah, and it's a lot more simple, then a magic being that's infinite, and no one can see or test for. But nonetheless, I will maintain, that there is a way to prove it. There is a method. Therein is what I'm pointing out. That there is no method of proving allah exists. In that, Allah, is no different from a pink unicorn.

As far as humanity is concerned, there is only one method we have come up with, that has a high degree of success, in finding the truth. That is.....the scientific method. There is nothing that has created as much knowledge of what the truth is, other then that. If you say Islam, or christianity, or hinduism is the truth...that's BS. And i'm gonna call every muslim on this board out on that. What does islam have to say about gravity?, or sonic booms? or the speed of light? absolutely nothing. Islam is worthless as a path to truth. Because it has never explained anything. It makes up stuff, and provides no proof for it.

As for evolution, its actually really easy to disprove. You just need to find a new specie, that has no genetic commonality with anything in existence. That would show that evolution is false, and that complex organisms can just come into existence without pre-existing species. Unfortunately....that not the reality. Every thing has a gentic commonalities with everything else.

Omer

That's quite a bit of a cop out to say that you can't prove there will be a dawn, is absolutely false. First we define dawn. It's when the first rays of light break the horizon. Thereafter you make the statment based on your understanding that tomorrow at 5am the sun will break the horizon. Now to prove that this is true or not, we simple look to see what happens tomorrow at 5 am. Either it will break and dawn will occur or it won't. So it is provable. Every statement has to have a way to disprove it if it doesn't it;s a worthless question. Such as what is the sound of the color green. The sound of the color green is a horn. How do you prove it. You can't does that then make it true? No it just makes it a non sense question.

If you claim to know about the world, then you should be able to state that if this happens then i'm wrong. Gravity has that aspect to it as well as every statement about the world that people who don't use god as a reason can put forth.

For those who make statements about the world, you need to be held to the same standard as every other person who makes statements about the world (i.e. scientists). If you want to say no, becuase it's religion i don't need proof, then you should remove your statments from the realm of reality, and put it in the world of fiction such as dragons, and fairies, and zeus.

See i can say dragons exist, but they can't be tested for because they are magic. But they exist.

There's no way to disprove this statment. So it's of no value.

In programming you can define a boolean A and make the statement (assignment): A=true.

There is no way to (dis)prove that A is "false".
Even God could not decide on it.

In other words: we have to live with uncertainties.

Bad luck:

Airmano


Edited by airmano - 10 December 2014 at 12:57am

Tim the plumber wrote: How come you get to post stuff like this when my posts are most often deleted?

Hi Tim the plumber,

I used to often have the same question.  So many of my posts were denied while others I considered far more challenging were allowed.
It may have something to do with what forum you are posting in?

asalaam,
Caringheart