Muslims In Non-Muslim Countries

Since you people know so much about Islam and you think that I don't - then why are you promoting a Political brand of Islam in your adopted Western country ? Since when did the British or the Americans want to give up their democracy for your Islamic State ? As for Singapore - Muslims have many problems. Denying this is closing your eye towards the ugly reality that Muslims FAIL to integrate into Non-Muslim societies. As for India - I don't think that even you will accept their so-called Muslim commander as a true Muslim. Indeed I put it to you that this commander of yours will never shoot at Pakistan. And thats the reality you have to live with....That you cannot uphold the aspirations, values and political interests of your fellow Non-Muslim citizens. Indeed - where are Muslims integrated well into a Non-Muslim society ? NOWHERE ! So don't tell me nonsense before you think hard. Go and dream of your Islamic State in the West. Carry on.....for the rest of the world can see through your denial syndrome. Maybe when the next bomb explodes - then perhaps you will admit the failure of Muslim minorities to integrate into Non-Muslim societies.

Edited by Dr Syed Alwi

I only know one doctor,DR.Eutker...no need more,insh'Allah...

Dr Syed Alwi wrote:  To me - this is just another piece of evidence that Islam needs a reform.

To many I hope, this is a peice of evidence you know very little about Islam, and need some sincere efforts to understand better.

Regards,

Dr. Nausheen

Can a Muslim be committed to a Non-Muslim country ? I do not know. Ask yourself whether you are prepared to uphold the political interests of the Non-Muslim majority ? What happens when the political interest of the Non-Muslims is at the expense of other Muslim countries ? Will you hurt Muslims elsewhere just to promote the political cause of your fellow Non-Muslim citizens ? So you see - it is no simple matter to be a Muslim minority in a Non-Muslim country. Think about it...and tell me your dilemmas here.....God above State or State above God ? Perhaps one way of seeing this is to acknowledge that we need to re-interpret Islam so that Muslim minorities will not be left in a very difficult situation. As a minority, Muslims cannot be expected to form an Islamic State/Khilafah in a Non-Muslim democracy. Because the Non-Muslim majority will never ever support such a political cause. You won't get the votes in a democracy ! To me - this is just another piece of evidence that Islam needs a reform.

Regards

Dr Syed Alwi