Muhammad: A Prophet for Our Time

Category: Faith & Spirituality, Featured Topics: Interfaith Views: 21161

The history of a religious tradition is a continuous dialogue between a transcendent reality and current events in the mundane sphere. The faithful scrutinize the sacred past, looking for lessons that speak directly to the conditions of their lives. Most religions have a figurehead, an individual who expresses the ideals of the faith in human form. In contemplating the serenity of the Buddha, Buddhists see the supreme reality of Nirvana to which each of them aspires; in Jesus, Christians glimpse the divine presence as a force for goodness and compassion in the world. These paradigmatic personalities shed light on the often dark conditions in which. most of us seek salvation in our flawed world. They tell us what a human being can be. 

Muslims have always understood this. Their scripture, Qur'an, gave them a mission: to create a just and decent society, in which all members were treated with respect. The political well being of the Muslim community was, and is, a matter of supreme importance. Like any religious ideal, it is almost insuperably difficult to fulfill, but after each failure, Muslims have tried to get up and begin again. Many Islamic rituals, philosophies, doctrines, sacred texts, and shrines are the result of frequently anguished and self-critical contemplation of the political events of Islamic society. 

The life of the Prophet Muhammad (c. 570-632 CE) was as crucial to the unfolding Islamic ideal as it is today. His career revealed the inscrutable God's activity in the world, and illustrated the perfect surrender (in Arabic, the word for "surrender" is islam) that every human being should make to the divine. Beginning during the Prophet's lifetime, Muslims had to strive to understand the meaning of his life and apply it to their own. A little more than a hundred years after Muhammad's death, as Islam continued to spread to new territories and gain converts, Muslim scholars began to compile the great collections of Muhammad's sayings (ahadith) and customary practice (sunnah), which would form the basis of Muslim law. The sunnah taught Muslims to imitate the way Muhammad spoke, ate, loved, washed, and worshipped, so that in the smallest details of their daily existence, they reproduced his life on earth in the hope that  they would acquire his internal disposition of total surrender to God. 

At about the same time, in the eighth and ninth centuries, the first Muslim historians began to write about the life of the Prophet Muhammad: Muhammad ibn Ishaq (d. 767); Muhammad ibn 'Umar al-Waqidi (d. c. 820); Muhammad ibn Sa'd (d. 845); and Abu Jarir at-Tabari (d. 923). These historians were not simply relying on their own memories and impressions, but were attempting a serious historical reconstruction. They included earlier documents in their narratives, traced oral traditions back to their original source, and, though they revered Muhammad as a man of God, they were not entirely uncritical. Largely as a result of their efforts, we know more about Muhammad than about nearly any other founder of a major religious tradition. These early sources are indispensable to any biographer of the Prophet. 

The work of Muhammad's first biographers would probably not satisfy a modern historian. They were men of their time and often included stories of a miraculous and legendary nature that we would interpret differently today. But they were aware of the complexity of their material. They did not promote one theory or interpretation of events at the expense of others. Sometimes they put two quite different versions of an incident side by side, and gave equal weight to each account, so that readers could make up their own minds. They did not always agree with the traditions they included, but were trying to tell the story of their Prophet as honestly and truthfully as they could. There are lacunae in their accounts. We know practically nothing about Muhammad's early life before he began to receive what he believed were revelations from God at the age of forty. Inevitably, pious legends developed about Muhammad's birth, childhood, and youth, but these clearly have symbolic rather than historical value. 

There is also very little material about Muhammad's early political career in Mecca. At that time, he was a relatively obscure figure, and nobody thought it worthwhile to make note of his activities. Our main source of information is the scripture that he brought' to the Arabs. For some twenty-three years, from about 610 to his death in 632, Muhammad claimed that he was the recipient of direct messages from God, which were collected into the text that became known as the Qur'an. It does not contain a straightforward account of Muhammad's life, of course, but came to the Prophet piecemeal, line by line, verse by verse, chapter by chapter. Sometimes the revelations dealt with a particular situation in Mecca or Medina. In the Qur'an, God answered Muhammad's critics; he reviewed their arguments; he explained the deeper significance of a battle or a conflict within the community. As each new set of verses was revealed to Muhammad, the Muslims learned it by heart, and those who were literate wrote it down. The first official compilation of the Qur'an was made in about 650, twenty years after Muhammad's death, and achieved canonical status.

The Qur'an is the holy word of God, and its authority remains absolute. But Muslims know that it is not always easy to interpret.  Its laws were designed for a small community, but a century after their Prophet's death, Muslims ruled a vast empire, stretching from the Himalayas to the Pyrenees. Their circumstances were entirely different from those of the Prophet and the first Muslims, and Islam had to change and adapt. The first essays in Muslim history were written to address current perplexities. How could Muslims apply the Prophet's insights and practice to their own times? When the early biographers told the story of his life, they tried to explain some of the passages in the Qur'an by reproducing the historical context in which these particular revelations had come down to Muhammad. By understanding what had prompted a particular Qur'anic teaching, they could relate it to their own situation by means of a disciplined process of analogy. The historians and thinkers of the time believed that learning about the Prophet's struggles to make the word of God audible in the seventh century would help them to preserve his spirit in their own. From the very start, writing about the Prophet Muhammad was never a wholly antiquarian pursuit. The process continues today. Some Muslim fundamentalists have based their militant ideology on the life of Muhammad; Muslim extremists believe that he would have condoned and admired their atrocities. Other Muslims are appalled by these claims, and point to the extraordinary pluralism of the Qur'an, which condemns aggression and sees all rightly guided religions as deriving from the one God. We have a long history of Islamophobia in Western culture that dates back to the time of the Crusades. In the twelfth century, Christian monks in Europe insisted that Islam was a violent religion of the sword, and that Muhammad was a charlatan who imposed his religion on a reluctant world by force of arms; they called him a lecher and a sexual pervert. This distorted version of the Prophet's life became one of the received ideas of the West, and Western people have always found it difficult to see Muhammad in a more objective light. Since the destruction of the World Trade Center on September 11th, 2001, members of the Christian Right in the United States and some sectors of the Western media have continued this tradition of hostility, claiming that Muhammad was irredeemably addicted to war. Some have gone so far as to claim that he was a terrorist and a pedophile. 

We can no longer afford to indulge this type of bigotry, because it is a gift to extremists who can use such statements to "prove" that the Western world is indeed engaged on a new crusade against the Islamic world. Muhammad was not a man of violence. We must approach his life in a balanced way, in order to appreciate his considerable achievements. To cultivate an inaccurate prejudice damages the tolerance, liberality, and compassion that are supposed to characterize Western culture. 

Strangely, events that took place in seventh-century Arabia have much to teach us about the events of our time and their underlying significance-far more, in fact, than the facile sound bites of politicians. Muhammad was not trying to impose religious orthodoxy- he was not much interested in metaphysics-but to change people's hearts and minds. He called the prevailing spirit of his time jahiliyyah. Muslims usually understand this to mean the "Time of Ignorance," that is, the pre-Islamic period in Arabia. But, as recent research shows, Muhammad used the term jahiliyyah to refer not to an historical era but to a state of mind that caused violence and terror in seventh-century Arabia. Jahiliyyah, I would argue, is also much in evidence in the West today as well as in the Muslim world. 

Paradoxically, Muhammad became a timeless personality because he was so rooted in his own period. We cannot understand his achievement unless we appreciate what he was up against. In order to see what he can contribute to our own predicament, we must enter the tragic world that made him a prophet nearly fourteen hundred years ago, on a lonely mountain top just outside the holy city of Mecca.

Excepted from "Muhammad: A Prophet for Our Time" by Karen Armstrong.


  Category: Faith & Spirituality, Featured
  Topics: Interfaith
Views: 21161

Related Suggestions

The opinions expressed herein, through this post or comments, contain positions and viewpoints that are not necessarily those of IslamiCity. These are offered as a means for IslamiCity to stimulate dialogue and discussion in our continuing mission of being an educational organization. The IslamiCity site may occasionally contain copyrighted material the use of which may not always have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. IslamiCity is making such material available in its effort to advance understanding of humanitarian, education, democracy, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a 'fair use' of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law.

In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, and such (and all) material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes.

Older Comments:
Karen wrote this article trying to balance the old time and the
current era of Islam. what I acknowledge that she has love for
Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) but she needs to admire it and expose her
inner believe. I don't know if she accepted Islam or not. If not I
invite her to accept Islam. She will taste the fruitiness of truth
and she can do a lot better with study and guidance. May Allah
(SWT) help us and guide us towards TRUTH. (search the truth and
truth will come to you)......go to JAZAK ALLAH

IT is reported in Hadith narrated by Jabir Radhiallahu Anhu)
Some Angels came to the Prophet while he was sleeping.Some of
them said he is sleeping.Others said "His eyes are sleeping but
his heart is awake."Then they said His example is that of a a
man who built a house and then offered therein a banquet,and
sent to invite people.So whoever accepted the invitation entered
the house and ate of the banquet and whoever did not accept the
invitation did not enter the house nor did he eat the banquet.So
they interpreted it to mean the house stands for Paradise and
the call maker is the Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W) and whoever
obeys Muhammad obeys Allah and whoever disobeys him disobeys
Allah.May Allah give us guidance he is the Prophet of all times
up to the Day of Judgement sent to the whole mankind.

Salaam on Muhammad,Jesus,Muses,all prophets of God,and all believers
of them.I wish you would write historical facts rather than your
opinions Ms Armstrong.Any person who wants to know life of Muhammed
can easily get many considerable sources which have extremely
historical value.As soon as each statements of Quoran were declared
by God to Muhammad,those statements were written on a paper or
something like paper, and memorized by muslims who lived when
Muhammad was alive.That means when Muhammad was alive Quoran was
being protected with memorization by many muslims.After the death of
prophet Muhammad,to prevent losing of the statements of
God,they were gathered as a book by halifah Omar.But,Omar ordered
that the statements which were not memorized at least by two muslims
who lived when Muhammad was alive wouldn't been gathered in the
book.That means there is no difference between the Quoran we read
today and the Quoran which was declared by God in the fifth
century.Also Quoran is not a book which adresses only the people of
fifth century, but it adresses all people of all centuries.Because
it guides people how to become a society whose members are
honest,kind, friendly,PEACEFUL.It is true that the first statements
were declared to Muhammad when he was in Hira,a part of a
mountain.Because until Quoran was declared, his society was
collapsed by means of ethic.He prefered to be far away from that
collapsing,then the first
statements of God were declared,and he started to make people aware
of those statements,of course either by practicing,or telling
them.Unfortunately,people has been cheating either about life of
prophet Muhammed,or about the reality of wars with which muslims had
to face.Also,9/11/2001 events usually has used to display muslims as
terrorists, but after that event the USA has gone WARS in
Afghanistan,Iraq,middle east,to have more oil.Terrorism is forbidden
in Is

As always, Karen writes a well articulated and balanced view of islam and the prophet pbuh. There is one misleading statement about the quran being 'officially compiled 20 years of the peophet's death'. Iwonder what she attributes to the word 'officially' but the fact we all know including Karen is that the quran was avaialble in a material form on separate parchments and thousands of companions knew the quran by heart. It is a slight distortion to think the quran was compiled years after the prophet's death.

All that is written is just deception and can not be proven without the distortion of the facts. For that you will be judged by God.

Great job Karen on this article ! Liked the part of getting past the Crusaders bashing of the Prophet ( pbuh ) to talk about the REAL man. I think one must just read the Quran to see it is divinely inspired . The Prophet ( pbuh ) was an unread man , no way he could of made it up. Muhammad ( pbuh ) really is a prohet for ALL times !

The article was well and good written. I truly respect Karen Armstrong's in deepness of study ...

Assalamu alaykum. The article was well written. I really admire Karen Armstrong's in depth study of Religions and her courage for speaking up to defend her own understanding inspite of the western Islamaphobia and the tendency for her to be termed pro-terrorist. Karen has really shown in-depth understanding of Islamic Principles, values and more importantly Islam's stand on Jihad and its exhortation to peaceful coexistence of human kind which Allah (SWT)describes as His best creation. I sincerely hope that we will have more Armstrongs among Westerners and may Allah (SWT) guide them aright,ameen.

This is too much to publish the insulting comments as below.
We should be open for discussion but not for insults.
If I say evangelicals believe jesus (with small j) is eventually a mass murderer, as he will come back and kill all except 'true christians', will they publish it? Too much!

To O.G,
Your comment shows how ignorant you are on history. When you compare the real humans there is no one that comes closer to this Prophet. Probably you are behinf comic characters.

Well, the "Prophet for Our Time" would probably find himself in prison in virtually any country on t...


To Muhammad: Salaam, Karen Armstrong is a woman and a Religious Scholar. The reason she did not refer to Allah (SWT) and the Holy Prophet (SAWS) in the Muslim way is, she is probably not a Muslim. I thinks this is a good article.

I love all my brothers and sisters i don't believe religion should be segrated life has been better in this country for years so why change it.

My only disagrement with the writer is he doesnt always dignify our belove prophet Muhammad (SAW)with RASULULLA SALLAHU ALAIHI WASALLAM (SAW)when ever he mentioned his name, PLEASE TAKE NOTE.

AOA. This is an extremely good effort to put forward the most
basic point about Messenger of Allah Muhammad (PBUH) that
the entire west (and many Muslims) so conveniently try ignore
for their own ends i.e. One should study Islam and Messenger of
Allah Muhammad (PBUH) objectively and see for themselves what
is it all a bout....instead of just watching CNN/BBC and believing
what every one says. Insha-ALLAH every one will see the truth.

But I would like to point out some assumptions of the author
(which may seems OK from western perspective but not what
muslims believe)....

"political career" please understand Messenger's of Allah,
whether be Muhammad(PBUH) or Jesus (PBUH) or Moses (PBUH)
have no careers in terms of our thoughts but they simply follow
what is revealed to them by ALLAH (SWT) and it is ALLAH WHO
through them brings humanity from darkness to light.

"Pious legends"...not legends because the Messengers of ALLAH
are protected by ALLAH Himself to have sound character from
birth to death as they are meant to be guides of
humanity...again any of them, Jesus(PBUH) or Moses(PBUH) or
Muhammad(PBUH) or for that matter ADAM (PBUH).

"made him prophet.." No circumstances can make any one
Prophet, only ALLAH selects among Humans the Prophets".
Please note Prophet is not an optimum description of any
Messenger of ALLAH....instead a better word is "Messenger of

I hope you get the is not religion or or
hereafter...this messenger or that messenger...IT IS ABOUT THE

May ALLAH(SWT) guide us all to his way...Amin

O.G. FROM U.S.A. said:
Well, the "Prophet for Our Time" would probably find himself in prison in virtually any country on this planet for some of the things he did.