Quran Verse

jgnana wrote: Mohammed had received Quran from Allah, through Gabriel. Is this correct? When, where and how Gabriel received Quran? What is the position of Gabriel and why we are not like him/her now?

The Jews in Madinah at the time of Prophet Muhammad (saw) had posed the same question, they asked the Disbelievers of Makkah to go an ask him about the 'Ruh' or 'Holy Spirit', ask him (saw) to inform us about it.

To which Allah (swt) had revealed the following verse of the Quran in Surah Bani Israel (17:85):

And they ask you concerning the Ruh (the spirit). Say: "The Ruh (the spirit) is one of the things, the knowledge of which is only with my Lord and of knowledge, you (mankind) have been given only a little.'')

The Ruh means Soul, which has been blown in to each one of us, which keeps us alive.
The classical and contemporary commentators of the Quran say that Ruh could also refer to the Holy Spirit i.e. Gabriel (a.s) the Greatest Angel of all the Angels, who brought revelation. The answer to your question is visible in the shared Verse.

1. Can you certainly say, whether Allah has form or not? why you are not keeping his form in mosques?

2. where were you before taking this birth? why you took birth? why you took this whatever form you have? how allah decided you to take birth here? why you are not taking birth in my place, why not I in your place? what is the difference between human form and others form?

3. if humans are made up of clay, then what is mind? how it was created?

Edited by jgnana - 22 February 2014 at 12:48pm

Sir, you have given answer to one of my three questions, that too partial. Please answer my all questions.

If you say God is great, but he cannot beget children. Your father got you, your grand father got your father, and you (may be already or soon) will get your heir. then why not God? Please explain how he is great in that situation? whatever he is creating is doing some action, but he cannot, then how he will be supreme in all?

Edited by jgnana - 23 February 2014 at 8:16am

Sir, i am also believing God, there is no second question about that. But it doesn't mean like, we cannot try to understand how gloriously God or his creations are working (at least up to our level of understanding).

If everything is Allah's will, why he created Kabirs. Why he created people to disrespect him? Then why he is sending them to eternal hell?

Is it your mistake to go to hell? it is Allah's creation. If God is going to hell or heaven, then there is no question about his creation. But it is we, who are going to suffer in the hell, then i have full rights to ask why you have created like this, and sending me to hell. If we don't understand the procedures how it works(upto my level), then i will be so called fanatic sentimentalist, God will NEVER LIKE THIS TYPE OF FANATIC SENTIMENTALIST.

I hope you will understand this. Then he has to answer all these questions. If you say, Quran is coming from God and it is having complete knowledge(than other scriptures), it should have this information also. If i simply take your answer, then as per Allah's will i am asking these question, please think and answer.

Please let me know in detail. I am so much interested to understand answers to my questions in detail.

If you want, please loop others also. Basically i need elaborate discussion and understanding on these subjects.

similarly, regarding form, "not important" is completely different from the question of its "existence". I would like to get proof from Quran, whether god has form or not. It is not the subject of how much importance you are giving to it.

As per this verse 2.115, God has face. Then there is no question of his legs and hands. Those who are denying that, will have no faith or knowledge on this verse. Am i correct? If i am correct, why mosques are empty?

Thanks again.

Edited by jgnana - 24 February 2014 at 1:58pm