IslamiCity.org Homepage
Forum Home Forum Home > Culture & Community > Groups : Men (Brothers)
  New Posts New Posts RSS Feed - Marijuana  What is Islam What is Islam  Donate Donate
  FAQ FAQ  Quran Search Quran Search  Forum Search   Events   Register Register  Login Login

Topic ClosedMarijuana

 Post Reply Post Reply Page  <12345 7>
Author
Message Reverse Sort Order
inhale View Drop Down
Starter
Starter

Joined: 30 November 2005
Status: Offline
Points: 2
Direct Link To This Post Posted: 30 November 2005 at 6:15pm
Quote
Before I address the issue which Brother Mankind has put forth for us to consider, I want to take a moment or two to address what Inhale has said.  We are not discussing here any of the issues you bring up.  This is not a "should or should not marijuana be legalized" issue.  This is a thread about whether it is haraam to smoke marijuana.  It's too bad that people got off track by bringing up other issues, but I think they did so to help Brother Mankind see the dangers in smoking marijuana because he simply doesn�t accept the fact that Allah forbids its use.

I was just commenting on what Angel pasted from a site. I didn't want the thread to end with misinformation.

Quote
But the truth of the matter is it doesn't matter if no one has ever died from using it (which by the way is not true),


People have died from mixing drugs, or driving while intoxicated. No healthy human being has ever smoked pot and died. At least we have no such record of this. What I mean by this is just LD50 (Amount needed to kill a lab rat 50% of the time) wise, like LSD (Acid), If you plan on ODing on THC, you would get to a state where you would be too messed up to consume a lethal amount of the stuff.

Quote
whether it is the lesser of evils (that is a very controversial subject), whether the government condones it or not (you tend to judge the evilness of the government simply by whether or not you are free to get high)

Evil is a bad word here, maybe stupid would of worked better? Prohibition is stupid. I'm not saying I want to see OTC Heroin, but there are ways of dealing with drug issues that might actually work. Are we benefiting from the War on Drugs?

Quote
, whether it enhances memory (go back and read the studies again, you are definitely missing something)

I read this in a magazine while waiting for someone in the doctor's lobby. I don't remember the mag though..
http://en.wikinews.org/wiki/Study_finds_marijuana_use_leads_ to_brain_development_in_rats

Quote
Most "drugs of abuse" such as alcohol, heroin, cocaine and nicotine suppress growth of new brain cells. However, researchers found that cannabinoids promoted generation of new neurons in rats' hippocampuses.

Hippocampuses are the part of the brain responsible for learning and memory, and the study held true for either plant-derived or the synthetic version of cannabinoids.

"This is quite a surprise," said Xia Zhang, an associate professor with the Neuropsychiatry Research Unit at the University of Saskatchewan in Saskatoon.

"Chronic use of marijuana may actually improve learning memory when the new neurons in the hippocampus can mature in two or three months," he added.

The research by Dr. Zhang and a team of international researchers is to be published in the November issue of the Journal of Clinical Investigation, but their findings are on-line now.

The scientists also noticed that cannabinoids curbed depression and anxiety, which Dr. Zhang says, suggests a correlation between neurogenesis and mood swings. (Or, it at least partly explains the feelings of relaxation and euphoria of a pot-induced high.)



[quote]
To be honest with you, your head is so twisted toward N.O.R.M.L. that it's no wonder you can't see straight on this issue.  Do you even realize how bad you logic is on this subject?  Or how your bad logic regarding this matter may affect Brother Mankind?
[\quote]
I don't care for NORML, and I was not trying to get Mankind, nor anyone else to try Marijuana. I just don't like seeing people base their conclusions on topics they researched at *.gov websites, or they learned from one side of the story. I want people to see both sides and then come up with their own opinion on something. I feel like the previous posts only showed Mankind BS answers that were either made up on the spot or pasted from an anti-Marijuana website. He needs to see both sides first.

I would never argue that "oh it's natural, pass the bong!" -- Lots of things are natural, doesn't mean I should be ingesting them. Datura comes to mind..

It's true that Marijuana in the past contained less THC than it does today, but so what? That just means that back then, it took more eating or smoking to get you as high as you would need to be today. The reason today's Marijuana is more potent is NOT because chemicals are added to the crop, but because humans evolve. We learned new ways of growing plants (Hydroponics, Aeroponics, etc.) We have better equipment now, artifical lighting, etc..

Now about addiction, let's get something out of the way: Marijuana is NOT physically addicting. I think we both agree on this. Now about being habit forming, or psychologically addicting, I think that this depends on the person.

As I said, people who have problems, especially depression, should not smoke Marijuana. Why? Because it's fun. It makes life fun and when you are sitting around and have nothing to do, you will smoke it again to pass time. And again and again just because you find it FUN, not because if you stop using it, you'll have withdrawal symptoms. Most people I know smoke maybe once a week, IF that. The dirty teen who steals to get his drug fix and lives in the slums is only about 1% of all drug users.

Dealers usually do NOT add any additive to the Marijuana they sell. The main reason is because it's too expensive to do so. I would *love* if I pay $20 a gram for Marijuana and recieve Opium with it, but it won't happen! This is just to scare people. If it really worries you, then just grow your own or find a dealer you can trust, or take a trip to Amsterdam : )

Marijuan does stay in your system for a long time, but after a day or two, you feel normal again, as if you've not taken anything. Now if the inxoticant is not altering your brain (And at that point -- It's not.) Why doesn't your prayer count?

And what about the issue of prescription drugs? Benzos, SSRIs, MAOIs, they all alter your conciousness and some are even fatal if taken in large doses or if you don't follow a very strict diet. They are legal however, so what about them and Islam?



Edited by inhale
Back to Top
Jenni View Drop Down
Senior Member
Senior  Member
Avatar
Joined: 10 June 2005
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 705
Direct Link To This Post Posted: 30 November 2005 at 1:20pm

I am not a doctor but have medical experince and believe that if someone is very ill like with cancer or H.I.V. I see some medical benifit from the medical use of Marijuana. Here in California in the bay area it is legal. If someone in my family was undergoing chemotherapy and was losing weight and feeling awful, I would have no qualms about them using marijuana for medical purposes only as it increases apetite, reduces nausea and discomfort. There are many perscription drugs such as vicoden,perkaset,codine,oxycontin ect ect ect that are VERY VERY addictive, much more so than marijuana. And some these drugs are often available online with no perscription or from Mexico. And some muslim countries sell these drugs freely in pharmacies without a perscription as well. I think any mind, mood altering substance used for any other reason than what is medically needed is haram. But in the case of marijuana, how is it any worse than morphine or any other addictive perscription drug???

You cant be a good muslim if you are not decent and have a cold heart. Be a decent and kind person and care for women and children and the elderly.
Back to Top
Khadija1021 View Drop Down
Moderator Group
Moderator Group
Avatar
Joined: 30 June 2005
Status: Offline
Points: 530
Direct Link To This Post Posted: 30 November 2005 at 11:46am
Assalamu Alaikum

Before I address the issue which Brother Mankind has put forth for us to consider, I want to take a moment or two to address what Inhale has said.  We are not discussing here any of the issues you bring up.  This is not a "should or should not marijuana be legalized" issue.  This is a thread about whether it is haraam to smoke marijuana.  It's too bad that people got off track by bringing up other issues, but I think they did so to help Brother Mankind see the dangers in smoking marijuana because he simply doesn�t accept the fact that Allah forbids its use.  But the truth of the matter is it doesn't matter if no one has ever died from using it (which by the way is not true), whether it is the lesser of evils (that is a very controversial subject), whether the government condones it or not (you tend to judge the evilness of the government simply by whether or not you are free to get high), whether it enhances memory (go back and read the studies again, you are definitely missing something) or even if the majority of users are �doctors, lawyers, and other professionals (which by the way is also not true�although there are those within the group of those who use marijuana, there is not study that shows they are the majority�if you are saying you know because you are a �white collar professional� and you use it or that you are a dealer and most of your clients are �white collar professionals�, then that is simply bad logic on your part) what does that have to do with the issue of it being haraam or not anyway?  What Allah commands to be haraam no man can cause to be otherwise.  To be honest with you, your head is so twisted toward N.O.R.M.L. that it's no wonder you can't see straight on this issue.  Do you even realize how bad you logic is on this subject?  Or how your bad logic regarding this matter may affect Brother Mankind? 

Brother Mankindm

I haven't been keeping up with this post so forgive me if I am commenting at a time when you have no more desire to discuss the issue; however, maybe my comments will be helpful to someone.  Let me start by saying that I worked in the chemical addiction field for 15 years.  Now, maybe you will take that to mean I am biased and of course that is your right; however, I pray that you will read what I have to say with an open mind.  Ameen.

First of all, your comparison of marijuana to other intoxicants saying that marijuana is natural, made by Allah, while others are not is not correct.  Cocaine, which is derived from the coca leaf is a natural product.  In fact, in places where coca is grown, people use it directly from the tree, preferring to chew the leaves instead of using the processed form of coca we know as cocaine.  Even though the intoxicate affect is not the same in all cases, tobacco, cola, coffee beans, some forms of tea, some mushrooms and peyote are all also natural forms of intoxicants.  Wine, which is make from fermented grapes or other fruits, is also a natural substance�unless you consider fermentation (allowing crushed grapes or other fruits to rot) to be somehow un-natural.  And how about opium?  It is derived from the poppy.  Poppies are not only natural, they are one of the most beautiful flowers Allah has graced our planet.  So, you are wrong in saying that marijuana is different because it is natural and other forms of intoxicants are not. 

Second, if you are going to argue that other forms of natural intoxicants are altered by humans while marijuana is not, well, let�s just take a look at your good friend MaryJane and see what she�s really made of.  Sure, Cannabis sativa (marijuana) is a plant that Allah created; however, what you roll up and smoke in the year 2005 is a far cry from what Allah placed upon this earth at the beginning of creation.  If you think that today�s marijuana is a �natural� substance, you are truly fooling yourself.  The active chemical ingredient in marijuana which produces the high that users of it enjoy so much is THC (delta-9-tetrahydrocannabinol).  In its Allah give form, marijuana only contains a trace amount of THC; however, over the years marijuana growers have found ways to increase the THC content of marijuana.  To show you how much growers have advanced the THC content in marijuana I will make a simply comparison.  In the 1970�s the best marijuana in the world contained roughly a 5% THC content.  Today, even the stuff you would only smoke as a last resort has that much THC content.  Most �decent� marijuana contains a THC content of 10 � 12% while the really �good stuff� has a THC content of up to 18%.  If you don�t believe me on this issue, check out the history of marijuana cultivation.  Those who cultivate it simply love to brag about what they have done to your dear friend MaryJane.  After that, if you are still in doubt, let me know; I�ll invite you over to my state and you can try out the truly �all natural� marijuana.  My state was a grower of natural marijuana back in the day when it was grown as a means to produce paper products.  Because marijuana is basically a weed (no pun intended), you can find plenty of it growing in its natural state out in the western part of the state I live in.  Another thing I would like to point out is that despite what you think, the marijuana you buy on the street has a wide range of potential additives which dealers use to enhance the affect of the high and to keep their customers �coming back for more.�  Other chemical substances which are popularly added to marijuana (not necessarily reported to the buyer) are hallucinogens such as PCP and stimulants such as cocaine.  So, despite you claim that marijuana is �natural�, its not; at least not the marijuana you and others use to take you little mini-vacations with.

Third, marijuana is powerfully addictive.  In fact, it is highly likely that it is one of the most addictive substances on the planet (right up there with nicotine and caffeine).  Although marijuana is not physically addictive, it is extremely physiologically addictive.  I know most people try to argue that if it�s not physically addictive then it is not so bad; however, that is simply ignorance on their part.  The truth of the matter is that only one class of chemical substance is actually physically addictive and that is the class known as depressant drugs.  What this means is that anyone who becomes addicted to depressant drugs is at risk of serious health problems during withdrawal and therefore should seek medical attention during withdrawal.  However, once the physical withdrawal is over, there is still the psychological addiction to deal with.  It is truly the psychological addiction which is by far more difficult to overcome.  Since marijuana�s addictive process is unlike any other in that THC is stored in fat cells and remains there for a substantially longer period than other chemically addictive substances, it is important not to overlook what that process it.  Since the brain is made up of mostly fat cells, the proportion of THC stored in the brain is grossly higher than in other parts of the body.  On the one hand, that is what marijuana smoker like about it; however, on the other, it is truly the heart of the problem.  THC stored in the fat cells of the brain cause the functions of the brain to slow down.  That is why you get that �just chillin� feeling from the high.  However, because the THC is not released from the body like other mind-mood altering substances, it builds up in the brain causing other problems such as short and long term memory loss. 

Regardless of whether you want to believe it or not, THC takes anywhere from 3 days to more than 45 days (depending on the amount and frequency in which it is ingested) to be released from the body.  Now I don�t know about you, but if Allah tells me not to use intoxicate because it keeps me from being about to communicate with Him, then why would I chose an intoxicant that takes days, weeks or even more than a month to get out of my system?  It is bad enough missing one prayer because of such actions but 15, 35, 105 or even 225 missed prayers all for the sake of wanting to get high?  And I�m not talking about missing prayers as in you ain�t getting down with the prostrating business.  What I�m saying is that Allah says that if we have an intoxicant in our system, the channel between Him and us just ain�t gonna happen.  So, even if you think you are praying, it ain�t no prayer according to Allah.  And if it ain�t good for Allah, it simply ain�t good.

Forth, one last comment before I�m through, one of your biggest pro-marijuana statements is the classic �It�s natural, if Allah didn�t want us to use it, then why did he put it here?�  As I pointed out above, there are many �natural� intoxicants on this earth and sure, Allah did have a reason for putting them here even if that purpose is clearly not for you to get �high� with.  Allah states in the Qur�an that all things are clear even if we can�t see them clearly.  Don�t forget we are merely human.  But what I want to pose to you at this time is why don�t we consume hemlock?  You know, it too is a natural substance but I don�t see anyone running out to smoke it up or consume it in any other way.  Sure, the reason is because it is poisonous, but the point is, just because something it natural doesn�t mean we should consume it.  It is simply absurd to claim that because something is natural it is good for us.  It is exactly for this reason that Allah guided us on this matter.  He knows best and history has proven with respect to intoxicants (all causing addiction), He was so merciful in commanding us to stay clear of them; by doing so, we stay close to Him and clear of the devastating problems that afflict those who become chemically dependant.

Brother Mankind, the fact that you are asking about this issue shows that on some level, you are conscious of the conflict that exists between smoking marijuana and what Allah commands of us.  I will pray for you because I know that if you are smoking marijuana, the likelihood of you taking advice from anyone, including me, is not very likely.  This truly is your struggle and I pray to Allah that He is merciful to you.  Ameen.

Allah Hafiz

PAZ,

Khadija



Edited by Khadija1021
Say: 'My prayer and my rites, my living and my dying, are for Allah alone, the Lord of all the worlds. (Qur'an, 6:162)
Back to Top
inhale View Drop Down
Starter
Starter

Joined: 30 November 2005
Status: Offline
Points: 2
Direct Link To This Post Posted: 30 November 2005 at 6:45am
As a Muslim and Marijuana user, I am going to state my opinion on this. As was stated above, I believe that the top scholars would tell you that Marijuana, Shrooms, Tobacco or whatever is Haram because it would have a very negative impact on Islam if they told you otherwise. Being that most major places prohibit Marijuana (and they only did so after the US did so.. *sigh*), what sort of view would this give the Western world about Islam?! We would be seen as barbarians.

I will address what Angel said about Marijuana:

Quote
Lung problems (eg chronic bronchitis, lung cancer). Cannabis smoke contains ingredients that can damage the lungs, affect your physical health and fitness and possibly cause cancer. If cannabis is smoked over many years it may get in the way of the functioning of the lungs, this may increase the chances of developing lung disease.


Yep, smoking anything is harmful. So? You can take the Marijuana and use a vaporizer, which releases no tar and causes no irritation to the lungs. If you can't afford one, then you can just cook the Marijuana and make 'special' brownies or even toast. There, happy lungs + happy mind!


Quote
Difficulties with memory and attention - It has been shown that cannabis use over the longer term can cause problems with memory, attention and processing of complex information. This may affect everyday life when you are learning something new or doing something difficult.

Marijuana *does* affect your short term memory, but only while you're under the influence. Over time, studies have shown that it actually increases your memory capacity. This is because while you're high, you're brain compensates for your weak short term memory by increasing the capacity of it. This is why over time, the daily Marijuana user can remember everything he thought of while high in detail.

Quote
Development of dependence - most people who use cannabis don't go on to use it regularly, or develop problems with it. However, there are a number of people who will become dependent on cannabis. The chance of becoming dependent on cannabis is similar to the chance of becoming dependent on alcohol. If someone is dependent on cannabis they may experience a difficulty controlling their use or be spending a lot of time involved in cannabis and less time on other things in their life.

Key statement here is 'there are a number of people'.. there is ALWAYS a number of people who would do anything. If you have a state of mind where you get addicted to Cannabis (and by all means, it's NOT addicting, chocolate, junk food and video games are 100x more addicting), then if Marijuana didn't exist, they would be addicted to something else. Alcohol, tobacco, anti-depressants, benzos (pain killers), cough syrup, etc.. Like I always say: If you messed your life up on drugs, you had a messed up life to begin with, for getting you into that situation.

Quote
Increased risk of mental health problems - some people have a greater risk of developing mental health problems than others. Cannabis use may trigger problems if you have a family history of serious mental illness (such as schizophrenia or depression), or you are vulnerable to developing it. If you already have a serious mental illness, cannabis use may make some of your symptoms worse.

This might be true, although no studies have proven it and nowadays it comes across as nothing more than a rumor, because in decades of study, we've never been able to get a real conclusion on this. I will say this however, if you're depressed or schizophrenic, you shouldn't take any drug. I have had *no* problems (but please don't take that as medical advice, I don't know you or your current state of mind.)

Quote
Now mankind don't you think this is a good enough reason not to use marijuana ??

Why do you want the qur'an to states so ??

You are just trying to justify your use despite the known effects, do you really need God to spell it out ??

Don't just copy and paste sh*t from a random site and then use that for your argument.

Do you even know *why* they made Marijuana illegal in the first place? Do you REALLY think the government cares about your health?! hint: Alcohol and cigarettes are legal, and cigarettes kill more people in a year than ALL illicit drug use in history combined.

Oh and might I point out: Marijuana has NOT caused a single death in its WHOLE history of use (This doesn't account for mixing Cannabis w/ Alcohol or Crystal Meth, etc, for obvious reasons.)

It's funny how people's view on Marijuana is so negative, I can't believe how many people just blindly listen to the government. Most people who buy and use Marijuana are doctors, lawyers, professors and the likes (and I would know!). NOT a drop-out fat teen, as the media potrays.

The government started out by telling us that Marijuana makes you go insane or lose your head. Obviously this is fake. You're FULLY aware of your actions while under the influence of Marijuana, unlike Alcohol.

I also believe that Marijuana was smoked (or eaten) and used throughout the whole world at one point or another. I think before it became illegal (because the government is racist), people (muslims, hindu, shamans, whatever) ALL used Marijuana for pleasure, medical purposes (did you know that Marijuana might actually have the benefit of reversing cancer cell production?!), celebration, cooking, and not to mention Hemp has LOTS of legitimate uses. We could be saving billions of we use Hemp instead of trees to make paper/clothing/rope/etc.

Think of it this way.. take something you ingest and pretend the government makes it illegal. What do you think they would tell you about it?

Let's take coffee for example. Caffeine is a drug, no doubt about it, withdrawal symptoms, cravings, the works. Now pretend the government bans coffee because the government is evil. The government will now tell you ALL the negative effects of caffeine on your body and mind (and there are dozens, if not hundreds.) If you read a brochure or see a commercial about all these negative effects, you will think coffee is bad like Marijuana. Right?

This is why Marijuana *might* be a gateway drug, because a law-abiding citizen might try it and enjoy it, and think "Wow, that wasn't so bad, why is it illegal?? Maybe the government is lying to me about Heroin! or Crystal Meth!" PROHIBITION DOES NOT WORK. WE HAVE EXPERIENCE (ALCOHOL, REMEMBER?)

I will end this by saying one thing: I believe that there IS a danger when mixing religion and mind altering drugs. This danger is that the user will start to explore his mind and THINK for himself! This can either be bad for religion, or it can be the best thing that ever happened to someone.

It's not hard to imagine that everyone back in the day was tripping on LSA/LSD/whatever (from eating shrooms that grow naturally, or ingesting one of a thousand other plants that alter your mind.) and just came up w/ the idea of god, or a entity talking to him/her. I'm not saying this happened but it's VERY possible. Maybe this is why the West (or just everyone in general now) is not spiritual/religious? Maybe this is why society is turning to material things instead of love/religion? This is what I believe.

I have an athiest friend, VERY anti-god, anti-religion. He tried LSD and I asked 'well, how was it?' the first thing he told me was "Well.. I'm def more spiritual now, there has to be something out there you know? I felt it."

I'm not telling ANYONE to do drugs. I'm just saying, do your research.

Some links:
http://www.erowid.org/plants/cannabis/cannabis_timeline.ph p

http://www.erowid.org/plants/cannabis/cannabis_health.shtm l

http://www.erowid.org/experiences/exp.cgi?S1=1&S2=-1&a mp;a mp;S3=-1&C1=9&Str=

Edited by inhale
Back to Top
mankind View Drop Down
Newbie
Newbie

Joined: 19 September 2005
Status: Offline
Points: 29
Direct Link To This Post Posted: 15 October 2005 at 1:57am
my bad..didnt think this subject will get that emotional..but am sry you have to deal with that by the way..n its gud u helping ppl...but i just think i had enuf of this discussion...maybe all of u r ryt..n i know nobody agrees with me here..n every now n then ppl cum up with the sammmme thing...so am done on my part thank you all..but i would like to see ur discussions as always..am not tryin to end this for every one..have a gud one peeps..
Back to Top
Unhappy View Drop Down
Newbie
Newbie
Avatar
Joined: 24 September 2005
Location: Canada
Status: Offline
Points: 12
Direct Link To This Post Posted: 15 October 2005 at 1:46am

Just because something is not "man-made" doesn't mean it is okay.  Opiates come from naturally occuring plants and are considered a drug just as bad as cocaine.

The notion that "naturally occuring" "non-man-made" materials are different in any way from synthesized chemicals is ludicrous.  St. John's Wort, a popular herbal drug used to treat depression, causes effects similar to many man-made psychotropic drugs.  Many of the man-made drugs exist because a chemical from a plant was extracted from it.

I work in a hospital and if you see what effects smoking does to a person, I have no idea how you could ever consider it mukru at all.  It is clearly haram.  It destroys your lungs making them prone to infection, causing breathing difficulties which destroys your entire body.  Not to mention lung cancer.  Have you ever seen someone in the late stages of lung cancer?  It's the saddest thing ever.  They are bald from the chemotherapy, their teeth fall out and their body rots.  Bacteria invade their body from every orifice and their last months on earth are a nightmare.  I have to deal with this every day so don't tell me because you read on a bunch of websites and some guys you knew who are super religious that it's okay to smoke.  I ask those guys and yourself to come down to my hospital and see some COPD patients and lung cancer patients.  You can all tell them that smoking is not haram when they cough up blood from their lungs or when they're on their deathbead and can't breathe on their own.  

Back to Top
mankind View Drop Down
Newbie
Newbie

Joined: 19 September 2005
Status: Offline
Points: 29
Direct Link To This Post Posted: 12 October 2005 at 5:37pm
Hey Usama, i havent seen n e of ur posts but am sure u have been followin this discussion..well as for me as u can see i decided to take things for myself n think it from here..ofcourse all these ppl on this site have helped me..but i decided to drop it for a while..but i guess sum1 like u had to ryt a decent comment..which impressed me becuz doesnt sound biased at all i like that..but usama if u read ur 7th n 8th paragraph..n u replace the word cigz with marijuana...it just makes as much sense..except marijuana is NOT chemically treated..thank you for your comment..and like i always say we r all here to learn..so plz pplz lets enjoy our ramdan n have a nice talk...lets not be different from eachother lets treat eachother with same respect n love..we r all the same..usama i didnt say this becuz of sumting u mentioned ok..am just saying..hope u have a gud one man..peace
Back to Top
usama View Drop Down
Groupie
Groupie
Avatar
Joined: 07 October 2005
Location: United States
Status: Offline
Points: 49
Direct Link To This Post Posted: 12 October 2005 at 5:11pm

Asalaam alaikum

Ramadan Mubarak, eventhough its the 2nd week (can we ever seek too many blessings in Ramadan?).

  I don't like getting into the halal vs. haram debates unless there is some intellectual or knowledge based benefit that may aid the believer in the future, insha Allah.  In this case, and Allah knows best, but I believe there is some benefit in addressing this matter just as if we were brothers sitting around discussing this over dinner.

  First, let us use the arabic word regarding intoxicants, khamr. 'Khamr' refers to any drink that intoxicates, so wine, beer, whiskey, vodka, cocktails, etc.  This is known in the arabic.

Am Maidah (5):90-91.

Oh you who believe, Truly 'khamru' and gambling and divination by arrows are an abomination of Satan's doings: avoid it in order that you may be successful. Assuredly, Satan desires to sow enmity and hatred among you with 'khamru' and gambling, and to hinder you from the remembrance of Allah and from salat. Will you not then desist?    

There are many ahadith addressing the prohibition of khamr. One includes: The Prophet (saaw) cursed ten categories of people saying:

Truly, Allah has cursed khamr, and the cursed the one who produced it, the one for whom it is produced, the one who drinks it, the one who serves it, the one who carries it, the one for whom it is carried, the one who sells it, the one who earns from the sale of it, the one who buys it, and the one for whom it is bought. (reported as sahih in Tirmidhi and Ibn Majah).

The illegality of any khamr, intoxicant, is prohibited. Qiyas extends this illegality to any known natural intoxicant, namely the common khat, marajuana, hashish. And this matter IS conclusive and Allah knows best.

  As for cigarettes. It is true anything that is definitively harmful is haram.  That is to say, to use something in a way that will bring haram to you is haram. Thus, to DRINK bleach is haram. Bleach will definitively erode the lining of your mouth, throat, stomach. It will definitively destroy your organs and if taken enough, will kill you. There is a direct causal relation between drinking bleach, or let's say a gallon of bleach and irreparably harming and even killing oneself. Drinking 6 oz.s of bleach is enough.  

  But smoking tobacco, or let's say smoking standard commercial cigerettes (cigz), since tobacco grows naturally and commercial cigerettes are chemically treated,  is not definitively harmful and fatal as drinking bleach is. Commercial cigz are not directly tied to harm or cancer. That is to say, there is no medically definitive tie which rises to level which is as  conclusive as drinking bleach is. As well, there are many many cases of people who smoke all their adult lives and do not necessarily suffer from cancer nor suffer harm from smoking. The same can never be said of drinking bleach. As well, the addictive nature of cigz do not necessarily render it haram being that cigz are not a khamr and nicotene is not a khamr.   That is not to endorse cigz or smoking as a habit. Certainly not. But the stronger legal position is that smoking cigz do not rise to the level of haram. 

  So the question of definitiveness and conclusivity has to be held to a high standard and not surrendered or lowered to mere rhetorical or weak legal argument.  That is not to protect people's bad habits, but to retain the high ideological standards and legal principles which have led the sharia`ah for 1400+ years.    

May Allah forgive me for any misguidance and  and misunderstanding and He is Allah, All Knowing, Wise.

Usama

Back to Top
 Post Reply Post Reply Page  <12345 7>
  Share Topic   

Forum Jump Forum Permissions View Drop Down

Forum Software by Web Wiz Forums® version 12.03
Copyright ©2001-2019 Web Wiz Ltd.