Therepy against anti-semitism: Freedom of choice - Event Date: 14 November 2012

When I see Muslims debating Muslims I am very hopeful for a better future, because I think civilized debate is so important. Two quotes come to mind:

"When all people think alike, no one thinks very much."

"The surest way to corrupt a youth is to instruct him to hold in higher esteem those who think alike than those who think differently."

Well, I think we're done here.

Assalamu alaika Abuayisa.

Read carefully applying the methodology giving by the holy apostle and Sahabas on deductions and ruling from the Qur'an and the ahadith of the holy apostle. The answer is there clearly given by the author. I am sure the author is referring to what we see from those Westerners who accept Islam. They immediately visit Makka without knowing the rules and regulations on prayers and hajj. But why skipping the reality? Is Arafat supposed to held on the 9th of Zulhajj? Please try to reason. You should understand what I am saying. As I said earlier, I listened to the video of Martin Lings and I was disturbed when he said that Arafat was observed on the 9th in 1948. I checked his book and found that. do you his book on the history of the holy apostle?
From that date,  there was never an Imam and probably you if you were ever there who read the exact date Arafat was observed. It was observed on Friday. Then when was Friday in 632 A.D? Was there ever a historian who said that that Arafat was not observed on Friday. I read that book also and I am convinced by the author after checking his references. I  checked the commentary of Qur'an by Imam Shankiti on chapter 22 and I understood what the author said. If you do not understand why not read the tafsir of shankiti?
Please do not be shy to discuss with your Imam and other brothers. It is important they buy that book.

Friendship.

Friendship wrote: Assalamu alaikum abuayisa.  Why did you not comment on what the author says on page 33? Friendship